Background
- Ratzel's ideas spread to neighbouring countries, and Humboldt (who published his 30 volumes in Paris) stimulated the French.
- In the mid-19th century geography in France was taught by historians, geologists, the military and engineers. Even the Sorbonne chair was held by a historian (Faculty of Letters).
- Philippe Buache (1752): first to criticise showing data by administrative units. Data should be shown in natural regions, and the river basin is the best natural region.
- Baron Coquebert (Director of the French Statistical Office, 1796): proposed dividing France into natural regions.
- Omalius d'Halloy (1833): a geological map of France relating landforms and soils to the underlying rocks (this contradicted Buache's river-basin idea).
- About 1870: a breakthrough, with geographical societies in the universities. The real take-off came with Vidal de la Blache. French geographers focused on the unique character of regions.
Paul Vidal de la Blache (1845–1918) ⭐⭐
A scholar of classical languages and literature. His interest in geography grew in 1865 while studying archaeology at Athens. Taught at Nancy (1872–77), then the École Normale Supérieure, and was Professor at the Sorbonne from 1898/99 until his death in 1918. Trained teachers for about 26 years. By 1921, all 16 French university geography chairs were held by his pupils.
Titles
- Founder of French human geography / "Father of Human Geography"
- Father of possibilism (the term "possibilism" was coined by Lucien Febvre)
- Founder of the regional (pays) tradition
📚 Works and institutions
Year | Work |
1891 | Founded the journal Annales de Géographie |
1894 | Atlas Général Vidal-Lablache |
1903 | Tableau de la Géographie de la France |
1917 | La France de l'Est (commonly cited) |
1921 (posthumous) | Principes de Géographie Humaine (Principles of Human Geography), completed by his son-in-law Emmanuel de Martonne |
1. Possibilism ⭐
- A strong critic of environmental determinism.
- Nature (milieu) sets limits and offers possibilities, but how man reacts depends on his traditional way of life.
- Man "joins in nature's game". The external environment (milieu externe) is a partner, not a slave, of human activity.
- "Nature is never more than an adviser."
- Lucien Febvre (historian): "There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities; and man, as master of these possibilities, is the judge of their use." Febvre regarded the earth's surface as a terrestrial organism.
- It is futile to set man's natural surroundings against his social milieu and regard one as dominating the other. It is also futile to seek general laws of man–nature relations.
2. Genre de vie (way of life) ⭐
- The complex of institutions, traditions, attitudes, purposes and technical skills of a group. Inherited traits learnt by members = culture. (The book credits Febvre with the term, but genre de vie is Vidal's concept.)
- The same environment has different meanings for groups with different genres de vie.
- Genre de vie is the basic factor deciding which of nature's possibilities a group selects.
- Genres de vie reflect nature even as they transform it. Vidal conceived human geography as a natural, not social, science (Buttimer, 1971).
3. Pays and regional geography
- First Sorbonne lecture (2 February 1899): man–milieu relations are best studied in small homogeneous areas, the pays.
- A country is inseparable from its inhabitants.
- Tableau: harmonious blending of physical and human features of France, describing the pays one by one:
- Each pays has distinctive agriculture (from soil and water, and economic specialisation driven by towns).
- Modern trade accentuated rather than reduced the individuality of the pays.
- Settlement relates to soil and water: scattered in some places, compact villages in others.
- Pays were not perfectly homogeneous (e.g. loam over chalk gave contrasting land use).
- A deeply human work with a firm physical base. It launched a series of French regional monographs.
- Opposed the drainage basin as the unit of study. Example: the Central Massif is a clear natural region, but dividing it into basins would obscure the culture, traditions and attitudes of its people.
- Small regions (pays) are ideal units for study and training. Regional geography became doctoral-work tradition in France.
- But meso and macro regional studies help planning. His scheme to study France's larger regions was partly carried out by Lucien Gallois.
4. Man–nature unity
- It is unreasonable to draw boundaries between natural and cultural phenomena: they are united and inseparable.
- Man changes nature most where material culture is highest. The natural landscape cannot be studied apart from the cultural landscape.
- Each community adjusts to nature in its own way. Man and nature adapt to each other like a snail and its shell.
- A region = an area where an intimate man–nature relationship has developed over centuries. Regional geography is the core of geography.
- Population: constantly changing. Man is the most adaptable and mobile organism. Population did not spread like a drop of oil but grew in clumps like corals.
- Lake analogy: wind disturbs a shallow lake surface, but the contours of the bottom soon show again. Likewise war, epidemics and strife interrupt a region's development, but fundamental trends reassert themselves.
5. Principle of terrestrial unity ⭐
- "The dominant idea in all geographical progress is that of terrestrial unity": the earth is a whole whose parts are co-ordinated, follow sequences and obey general laws.
- The idea came from astronomy (Ptolemy: geography is "the sublime science which sees in the heavens the reflection of the earth"), but it had been limited to mathematics until Vidal brought it into geography.
- Borrowed from botanical geography, the first to use the concept of environment. Humboldt showed that vegetation gives a landscape its character (steppe, savanna, silva, taiga). Plant associations form in unstable equilibrium through competition and adaptation.
- Animals (locomotion) and man (intelligence) cope better than plants. The environment groups heterogeneous plants, animals and men in mutual, vital interrelationship: the law governing the geography of living creatures.
- Man has modified the earth since prehistory (fire, tools; Palaeolithic hunters and Neolithic farmers destroyed some species and favoured others).
- Heterogeneous groups (hunters, farmers, shepherds) blend into a social organisation and supplement each other (except some migratory groups: Gypsies, Gaddis, Bakarwals, Bedouins).
- "No one knows what winds brought them together … but they are living side by side in a region which has gradually put its stamp upon them."
6. Limits and later views
- His model fits pre-industrial agrarian societies. After the industrial revolution (railways, canals, industry, wider markets), the local self-sufficient economy declined and the regional method lost value. "Cultural determinism" became more dominant.
- Late in life: study the economic interplay between a region and its dominating city rather than natural–cultural interplay. This anticipated nodal/functional regions.
- Principles of Human Geography chapters: aims of human geography, terrestrial unity and milieu, man as a geographical factor, patterns of civilisation, circulation (transport), cultural regions and cities.
Jean Brunhes (1869–1930) ⭐
A disciple of Vidal. Studied history and geography. Held a chair at Fribourg (Switzerland), later the Collège de France (commonly cited).
- 📚 La Géographie Humaine: Essai de Classification Positive (1910).
- Limited human geography to three essential facts (the book's version):
- Unproductive occupation of the soil (houses, roads)
- Conquest of the plant and animal worlds (cultivation, domestication)
- Destructive economy (économie destructive, "robber economy"): a violent attack on nature that may lead to poverty (mining, deforestation)
- Beyond these, the geography of history and social geography are also components of a region. In regional geography "the range of observation is well-nigh unlimited": epidemics, moral habits, property rights, social organisation, social anarchy in big cities, so long as they relate to the earth's surface.
- "Nature is not mandatory but permissive." A possibilist.
- Two principles of method:
Principle of Activity | Principle of Interaction |
Physical and cultural phenomena are in perpetual change and must be studied in time, not as static | Phenomena (physical and social) are closely interrelated and must be studied in combinations (permutations) |
"Everything is either growing or diminishing, expanding or shrinking": mountain heights, sea level, glaciers, valleys, deltas, forests | Borrowed from Vidal's terrestrial unity / whole. Inspired regional synthesis |
— | Example: relations of domestic animals and cultivated plants with forms of soil use and economic organisation |
Élisée Reclus (1830–1905)
French geographer and social anarchist, an uncompromising idealist. Ritter's most successful student (attended his Berlin lectures). Expelled from the Montauban seminary for supporting 1848. Fled after Napoleon III's coup (1851). Travelled in the Americas. Friend of Bakunin, member of the Fraternité Internationale. Took part in the Paris Commune (1871) and was imprisoned. Deportation to New Caledonia was commuted to banishment after appeals by geographical societies and Darwin. Lived in Switzerland. Taught at the New University of Brussels without salary. Supported the anti-marriage movement.
📚 Works
Year | Work |
1866–67 | La Terre: systematic physical geography |
1875–94 | Nouvelle Géographie Universelle (The Earth and Its Inhabitants): 19 volumes, regional. Clearer and more popular than Erdkunde; a model for encyclopaedic world geographies; about 3,000 maps |
1905–08 (posthumous) | L'Homme et la Terre: social geography, a historical account of humanity's life and use of resources |
Ideas
- "Ritter of France". Probably the most productive geographer of all time. Lucid, systematic style.
- Never held a French university chair (exile), so had no direct influence on French academic geography.
- Central theme: inequalities of human conditions and social justice. Described poverty in London.
- Linked geography with town planning and sociology. Influenced Frédéric Le Play and Sir Patrick Geddes, who spread his social geography in Britain.
- A possibilist who recognised man's negative impact. "Man is not the product of his environment but an important part of it." Man may overcome nature and convert the earth's energies into domesticated forces. Space must be studied with time.
- Conservation of nature and natural beauty. Through abuse "the barbarian gives the earth an aspect of brutality". Where grace disappears from the landscape, imagination dies. Rural life is preferable to town life.
- Man destroyed natural flora and fauna and broke the harmony of nature. Needed: "a robust education face to face with nature".
Emmanuel de Martonne (1873–1955)
- Pupil and son-in-law of Vidal. Trained in geology, geophysics and biology. Specialised in physical geography, especially Central Europe: the Carpathians and glacial erosion in the Alps.
- Met W.M. Davis at the 8th International Geographical Congress (USA, 1904) and was impressed by his geomorphology.
- 📚 Traité de Géographie Physique (1909), La France Physique.
- Completed Vidal's Principles of Human Geography. Known for the aridity index (commonly cited). Inspired French physical geography.
Albert Demangeon (1872–1940)
- Pupil of Vidal, concentrated on human geography.
- 📚 Thesis La Picardie et les régions voisines (1905): regional monograph. Taught at Lille (to 1911), then the Sorbonne.
- Edited the Annales (31 articles, 89 notes).
- Lifelong work on spatial variation of farmsteads (rural house types). Also transport, population, international economics, land classification and land-use maps. Wrote The British Empire (commonly cited).
- Suggested research on Far Eastern populations, White–Negro relations, irrigation in arid lands and the growth of great cities.
Later French trends (inter-war onwards)
- The Vidalian tradition weakened. Analytical study grew (especially agricultural geography), with statistical techniques, an interdisciplinary approach, regional synthesis and locational analysis.
- Phenomena explained as part of the geographical whole (ensemble), not just by correlation.
- Less description, more genetic explanation:
- Physical: processes, systems of erosion, morphogenetic stages.
- Human: economic factors, systems, zones of influence, economic regionalisation, traffic flow.
- Regional geography now explains the complex organisation of space, using detailed maps and aerial photographs.