1. Areal differentiation ⭐
- The study of areal variation of human and physical phenomena as they relate to other spatially proximate and causally linked phenomena.
- Term coined by Richard Hartshorne, The Nature of Geography (1939), drawing on Hettner. Its central claim: geography's integrative or synthetic purpose.
- Also called chorology / chorography: geography is concerned with the unique character of areas, so it is idiographic.
- The oldest tradition of Western geography: first set out by Hecataeus (6th century BC) and codified as chorology by Strabo (17 books, 8 BC–18 AD). A geographer "describes the parts of the earth". Key words: describe and parts, i.e. regional geography as the core.
- Revival in the 1980s from three directions:
- Humanistic geography: human awareness, agency, consciousness, creativity. The iconographic method reads the symbolic content of landscapes in their social and historical context. Landscapes are both shaped by and shape social processes, so they have ideological significance.
- Uneven development and the changing spatial division of labour (Marxist approach).
- Contextual theory: place or region mediates human agency and social structure, producing geographical sameness and difference.
- (1) privileges subjective experience of place. (2) and (3) see space through objective socio-spatial processes.
- Criticisms: difficulty of neat boundary delimitation when territoriality is dynamic. Cannot produce effective generalisations.
- It helped reconstruct regional geography: regions must not be studied as wholly separate entities. Focus on uniqueness, but not as if regions were singular.
- Still considered a rational and scientific definition of geography.
2. Exceptionalism in geography ⭐⭐
- Father of exceptionalism: Immanuel Kant. He claimed an exceptional position for both history and geography, unlike the systematic sciences. His statement became the cornerstone of geographical method for Humboldt, Ritter, Hettner and Hartshorne.
- Kraft: geography seeks laws, is limited to the earth's surface, is essentially chorological, and so is logically exceptional.
- Hettner: history and geography both integrate heterogeneous phenomena that are unique. History = Zeitwissenschaft (time science), geography = Raumwissenschaft (space science), as translated by Hartshorne.
- The term is usually identified with Fred K. Schaefer:
- An economist who fled Nazi Germany and taught with geographers in the economics department at the University of Iowa.
- Paper: "Exceptionalism in Geography: A Methodological Examination", Annals of the AAG, 1953, Vol. 43. A rallying point for the new generation (the QR).
- Attacked Hartshorne's claim of an exceptional, regional geography and argued for geography adopting the philosophy and methods of positivism.
- Calling geography the "integrating science" was arrogant, and its products lacked new insights.
- "A science is characterised by its explanations, and explanations require laws." To explain is to recognise phenomena as instances of laws.
- "Geography has to be conceived as the science concerned with the formulation of the laws governing the spatial distribution of certain features on the surface of the earth." The spatial arrangements, not the phenomena themselves, are the object of law-seeking: "morphological laws".
- Geography is not peculiar: all sciences deal with unique events explained by integrating laws (analogies from physics and economics).
- Rejected the idiographic orthodoxy in favour of nomothetic geography.
- Placed human geography among the social sciences (not the humanities or natural sciences). Geography must be like other social sciences, not exceptional.
- Among the first to teach Christaller, von Thünen and Lösch, the mainstay of 1960s human geography.
- Hartshorne's real position was more nuanced. He never accepted a clear idiographic/nomothetic split (both exist in all sciences). But he insisted that general concepts be directed towards analysing specific regions: the task is areal differentiation, not laws of location.
- Both relied on German sources (Kant, Humboldt, Hettner), and both directed geographers to spatial patterns.
- Humboldt and Ritter: geography examines how things combine "to fill an area". Spatial arrangements matter. Non-spatial relations belong to ecologists, anthropologists and economists.
3. Spatial analysis
- The quantitative techniques used in locational analysis (sometimes a synonym for it).
- Unwin (1981): the study of the arrangement of points, lines, areas and surfaces on a map.
- Human geography as the social science in which space is a fundamental variable influencing society and individual behaviour. Popular in the QR and tied to positivism.
- Goal: "building accurate generalisations with predictive power by precise quantitative description of spatial distribution, structure, organisation and relationships".
- Three fundamental spatial concepts: direction, distance, connection (relative position).
- Some apply the General Linear Model. Others stress special problems like spatial autocorrelation.
- Criticisms: spatial determinism (it is impossible to define spatial variables independent of context); ignores cultural values and normative questions; Marxists see it as a tool of capitalism.
4. Locational analysis
- An approach to human geography focused on the spatial arrangement of phenomena using spatial science. Aim: accurate generalisations, models and theories with predictive power (Berry). Based on positivism and empiricism (facts "speak for themselves"; geometry as the language of spatial form).
- Bunge (Theoretical Geography, 1962/66): "geography is the science of locations". McCarty: brought economics in. Close ties with regional scientists (economists) in the 1960s–70s.
- Haggett, Locational Analysis in Human Geography (1965): adopt the geometrical tradition to explain locational order. Needs (1) a systems approach, (2) models, (3) quantitative techniques. Tools: linear model, spatial autocorrelation, regression.
- Others: Morrill, Cole, Chorley, Cox, Harvey, Johnston, Pooler, Sack, Smith.
- Morrill, The Spatial Organization of Society: people seek to maximise spatial interaction at minimum cost, bringing related activities together. So society is surprisingly alike from place to place.
- Haggett (1978): "theoretical bridges, albeit incomplete and shaky, span from pure spaceless economics to a more spatial reality." (1990): whether order is found "depends on what we are prepared to look for".
- Criticisms:
- Ignores normative questions (the false belief that "positive theory would lead to normative insight").
- Does not reflect real decision-making, so predicts poorly.
- Models conceal real complexity.
- With global interdependence, local environmental dependencies lost their rationale.
- Encourages capitalism, so the rich get richer.
- Licence for plunder and "miscalled profit".
- Over-production and over-industrialisation.
- A "total newness": new technology, morals, media, weapons, violence, terrorism, exploitation.
- Treats people as "dots on a map", data on a graph, numbers in an equation.
- Hence behaviouralism and humanism rose. Locational analysis changed human geography from the mid-1960s, though it may never have dominated it (Mikesell, 1984).
5. Definitions and views of geography ⭐
View | Proponents | Key points and criticism |
Chorographic / chorological (regional) science | Strabo (chorographein = describe the parts), Hartshorne (1939), Volz, Sauer, Vidal | Satisfies people's curiosity about other places. "Home geography" is as necessary as history. Volz: geography teaches us "to know the space". Sauer: no other subject studies areas; every schoolchild knows geography describes countries. Geography deals with heterogeneous phenomena (hence branches). Vidal: men live in restricted areas, so the study of areas is a key method. Strabo's geography served social, political and military ends |
Science of relationship (man–environment) | Greeks, Romans, Indians, Chinese, Arabs; Kant (torrid zone lazy, Mediterranean industrious); Humboldt; Ritter; Darwin; Ratzel (Anthropogeographie 1882/1891; Political Geography 1897; Lebensraum); Semple; Vidal, Brunhes, de Martonne; Barrows (1922/23): study "man's adjustment to environment rather than the reverse" = human ecology; Hettner (1907); Sauer, Agricultural Origins and Dispersals (1952) | Ended up as environmental determinism ("pure geography"; environment = "the geographic factor"). Darwin's three points: organisms vary and pass on variations; they over-produce; the best-adapted survive. Darwin challenged teleology. Dickinson and Gumplowicz: Ratzel's work contains more knowledge about the state than all of political science. Criticisms: similar locations do not give similar lives: Eskimos vs Tungus, Yakuts, Yukaghirs; Khasis vs Nepalis; Gujjars and Bakarwals vs Kashmiris; Hanjis (Dal Lake water-dwellers) vs Srinagar townsfolk. Lost ground after WWII; spatial scientists, behaviouralists, radicals and humanists called it deterministic and unscientific |
Science of distribution | Pre-classical period. Marthe ("the where of things"), De Geer; Humboldt ("that which exists together"); Ritter; Hettner ("distribution by place"; Wallace Line); Sauer | Hettner: if history is the science of when, geography is the science of where. Criticism (Michotte): a botanist mapping plants, a geologist locating a volcano or a sociologist mapping population does not become a geographer; each works from his own science. Locating "where" is not geography's distinctive function. So not accepted as the main sphere |
Science of the planet earth | Gerland, Richthofen, Lehmann, Penck | Should geography cover the whole earth (including the interior) or only the surface? Richthofen (Leipzig, 1883): the geographer's concern is the outer shell (Hettner called this illogical). Gerland: the whole earth as a body. The interior cannot be directly observed. There is geography but no "Mars-ography", so geography is the study of the earth's outer shell: the unique planet where matter exists as solid, liquid and gas in a narrow temperature range and where life exists. Lehmann: the everyday sense of "world" (world tour, world map, world war) means the outer shell, as high and deep as man can experience. Conclusion: the domain is the outer shell where the atmosphere, hydrosphere, lithosphere and biosphere converge |
6. Idiographic vs nomothetic ⭐
Idiographic | Nomothetic |
The unique / particular | General laws |
Kant, Hettner, Hartshorne | Humboldt, Sauer and followers; systematic geography |
Hartshorne: geography studies spatial differentiation and peculiar phenomena of regions, so laws are useless and prediction has little value | Laws, theories, models |
Kant: geography = description. Hartshorne: a "naive science", "naive description" | — |
- P.E. James: "There is no such thing as a 'real region'." A region exists only as an intellectual concept useful for a purpose.
- Geography failed to formulate nomothetic laws until after WWII, when diffusion models, location theory, gravity models and geometric models appeared. The process has "passed the take-off stage".
7. Geography as a discipline of synthesis
- Allegation: geography has no area of its own and encroaches on other disciplines.
- Ackerman: the fundamental approach of geography is "the differentiation of the content of space on the earth's surface and the analysis of space within the same universe".
- Fenneman (1919), "The Circumference of Geography": a diagram of overlapping circles (geology, meteorology, botany, zoology, sociology, history, economics, etc.) around geography. Each overlap is a systematic branch shared with another science.
- Other sciences fail to consider overall interaction. Geography studies the interaction of biotic and abiotic phenomena in time and space, with an anthropocentric approach, where the four spheres converge. Hence a science of synthesis: physical and human phenomena are synthesised in a region, and general laws are tested in regional studies.
- Before the QR, geography was "short on theory and long on fact".
- Burton: theory "provides the sieve through which myriads of facts are sorted; without it the facts remain a meaningless jumble".
8. Explanation in geography: David Harvey (Explanation in Geography, 1969) ⭐
Six forms of explanation (per the book):
# | Form | Meaning and example |
1 | Cognitive description | Collection, ordering and classification of data. An implied primitive theory. Amorphous in the early stages of a discipline |
2 | Morphometric analysis | A type of cognitive description using a space-time language: measuring shapes and forms in space. Leads to predictive and simulation models (locational theories, central places). Geometric prediction |
3 | Cause and effect analysis | "Cause A leads to effect B", not the reverse. Found via hypothetico-deductive methods or by comparing maps. E.g. black cotton soil (Maharashtra, Gujarat, west MP) and cotton output: soil influences yield, not vice versa. Needs multiple regression or factor analysis |
4 | Temporal (historical) analysis | Cause and effect over long time: origin and development by process laws. Darby: "The foundations of [geographical] study lie in geomorphology and historical geography" (both temporal). Must be restricted to a definite period |
5 | Functional and ecological analysis | Developed by positivists to avoid metaphysical cause and effect. Phenomena are analysed by their role in an organisation: functional classification of towns, rivers by their role in denudation. Ecological concepts as a basis of explanation |
6 | Application | Use geographical laws to solve problems of resources, environment and society |