Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Soviet (Russian) School of Geography

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

5 min read6 sections

Soviet (Russian) School of Geography

Pre-revolution Russia

  • Many faculties, institutions, atlases, maps and monographs appeared in the late 19th century.
  • Humboldt's Siberian expedition (1829) was sponsored by the Czar (Nicholas I; the book wrongly says Peter the Great) to guide eastward expansion.
  • Imperial Russian Geographical Society (1845): promoted geology, meteorology, hydrology, anthropology and archaeology, collectively called the "geographical sciences".
  • Eminent pre-1917 scholars: Semenov-Tyan-Shansky, Voeikov, Dokuchaev, Anuchin, mainly in physical geography. Russians did not accept extreme environmental determinism.
Scholar
Contribution
P.P. Semenov (Tyan-Shansky) (1827–1914)
Explored the Dzungarian Basin, Altai, Tien Shan (1858) and the Turkistan desert (1888). Met Ritter but, like Reclus, rejected teleology. Used geography to reduce rural poverty, giving it practical, social relevance. Regional monographs
A.I. Voeikov (1842–1916)
Physical geographer: heat and water balance of the earth. Climatology for agriculture, the science of snow. On his suggestion: tea in Georgia, cotton in Turkistan, wheat in Ukraine. Overgrazing of the steppes causes gully erosion. Irrigation raises productivity in semi-arid lands. Wrote on man's influence on the earth (1901)
V.V. Dokuchaev (1846–1903) ⭐
First Professor of Geography in Russia (St Petersburg, 1885). Father of soil science (pedology). Soils are identified by horizons (layers) formed by soil-forming processes. Soil reflects the interaction of climate, slope, plants and animals with parent material. An old, mature soil reflects climate and vegetation more than parent rock (the basis of zonal soils). Little known abroad (wrote in Russian)
D.N. Anuchin (1843–1923)
Head of the Department of Geography and Ethnography (1887), trained in Germany. School textbooks. Student: L.S. Berg (landscape zones)

Peter Kropotkin (1842–1921) ⭐

👤
A founding thinker of anarchism, an idealist and close friend of Reclus. Worked on the physical geography of northern Europe and Siberia (Siberian expeditions; glaciation). Jailed in Russia and France, expelled from Switzerland, took refuge in Britain. Returned to Russia after 1917.
  • 📚 "What Geography Ought to Be" (1885), Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution (1902) (commonly cited).
  • Tried to revolutionise geography:
    • Theories of geographical education (teach children of other peoples, against race hatred)
    • Humanity–nature relations
    • Decentralisation
    • Against using geography for exploitation and imperialism, militarism, national chauvinism and racism
  • Mutual aid vs Social Darwinism:
    • Opposed the reading of Darwin as an incessant struggle and extermination of the weak.
    • Attacked Herbert Spencer, whose "general law of evolution" held that evolution is concentration, differentiation and determination, and that the "fittest" thrive under free enterprise.
    • "I failed to find … that bitter struggle for the means of existence between animals of the same species." The struggle is carried on by co-operating groups.
    • Mutual aid within small, self-sufficient communities in harmony with nature is the best path. He opposed political centralisation and industrial concentration.
  • Reclus and Kropotkin: geography must embrace both humanity and nature.
  • A friend of J. Scott Keltie (RGS secretary). Supported the Keltie Report (1886) to establish geography in British universities. But Keltie wanted geography value-free and positivist, and regretted that Kropotkin's politics "diminished services he might have rendered to geography".
  • Little direct influence in their day, but they kept alive critical social inquiry, revived by radical geographers about 50 years after his death.

After the October Revolution (1917)

  • Only geographers following Marx, Engels and Lenin could work.
  • Lenin, an economic determinist: geography is the foundation for designing the new economy. Its key product is the identification of rational economic regions. Geography is applied.
    • Lenin rejected environmental determinism, e.g. the claim that the steppes north of the Black Sea could never be farmed ignored technological change.
  • Stalin era: dissenters were arrested. Strong central control made regional geography less relevant.
  • GOSPLAN (1921): the State Planning Commission divided the USSR into 21 regions for planning, with geographers, economists and engineers. Planned the Ural–Kuznetsk and Dnieper Basin industrial regions.
  • N.N. Baransky: stressed economic geography (Economic Geography of the USSR), an applied regional approach, and opposed topical geography. 1946: called for a classification of cities.
  • Physical vs economic geography dichotomy was strong. In the early 1930s some held that their laws are different and cannot be combined.
  • Post-Stalin (1950s): resource planning, territorial production complexes, industrial location (minimum cost of raw materials), resource inventories.

Physical geography (post-revolution)

  • Climatology: forecasting theory, a dynamic typology, radiation budget and moisture cycle.
  • Hydrology: water-budget theory, surface water–soil water relations.
  • Glaciology: heat and mass exchange in glaciers.
  • Geomorphology: crustal movements, the morphostructural approach.
  • Soils: many types identified. Biogeography: ecological approach.

Philosophy of Soviet geography

  • V.A. Anuchin, Theoretical Problems of Geography (1960): ⭐
    • Supported unified geography and opposed the dichotomy of physical and economic geography.
    • Rejected geographical determinism (equated with capitalism) and also indeterminism / economic determinism.
    • Geography should use a regional approach to delineate territorial complexes, integrating nature, history, settlement, population and economy.
    • Critics called this anti-Marxist (too little weight to economic geography).
  • Aim: build a socialist economy and society, using quantitative techniques.
  • Geography as "landscape science" (not "regional science"). Landscape is dynamic: circulation of matter and energy, seasonal changes in heat and water balance and biological productivity. It helps delineate physical regions as a basis for planning regions, moving towards regional synthesis.
  • I.P. Gerasimov (1905–1985): landscape science is inadequate for "constructive geography". Geography must actively transform nature, e.g. investigate the heat and water budgets of virgin land and then apply technology to raise productivity.

Contemporary Russian trends

  • Management of natural resources and the environment, regional problems.
  • Brezhnev, 25th CPSU Congress: geography must serve production and its management, and address environment and population (demographic policy).
  • Recycling of raw materials: the cycle of matter (extraction → production → waste returned to the environment).
  • Territorial Industrial Complexes (TICs): the planned organisation of large industrial units.
  • Recreational geography: recreation zones near large towns to counter urbanisation.
  • Constructive (applied) research as a productive force: regional and town planning, water management, industrial location, agriculture, forecasting, soil erosion, mudflows, avalanches, droughts, road routing, tourism, health resorts.