Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Greek Contributions to Mathematical & Physical Geography

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

3 min read4 sections

Greek Contributions to Mathematical & Physical Geography

Overview

  • The Greeks extended the horizon from the Aegean to Spain, Gaul, the Russian steppes, Central Asia, the Indus and Ethiopia.
  • They put geography on a sound footing in mathematical, physical, historical and regional geography.
  • Mathematical geography: developed by Thales, Anaximander and Aristotle, and reached its zenith with Eratosthenes.
  • Physical geography progressed more slowly: weather, tides, volcanism, Nile floods, deltas and valley formation.

A. Mathematical geography

Shape of the earth: who said what

View
Thinkers
Circular plane / disc surrounded by the Ocean River
Ionians: Homer, Thales, Anaximander, Hecataeus
Flat earth with symmetrical land and water
Herodotus (not a believer in sphericity)
Round earth at the centre of the universe, celestial bodies in circular motion
Plato, the first to announce it (possibly from Socrates)
Earth rotates on its axis but is still the centre
Heracleides Ponticus (associate of Plato)
Sphere, with arguments
Aristotle (first to give definite arguments)
Sphericity measured
Eratosthenes
Surface of the sea is convex
Archimedes (250 BC)

Aristotle's two arguments for a spherical earth (frequently asked)

  1. Gravitation: all things tend to move towards the centre. Matter coming together equally from all sides makes every part of the surface equidistant from the centre.
  1. Lunar eclipse: the earth's shadow on the Moon is curved, so the body casting it is spherical.

Climatic zones

  • Eudoxus of Cnidus (contemporary of Plato) proposed the theory of climatic zones based on increasing slope (klima) of the Sun's rays away from the Sun on a spherical surface. This is the origin of the word "climate".
  • These were deductions from the belief that the sphere is the most perfect form.

Latitudes and longitudes

  • Hipparchus developed the system of lines that was the forerunner of latitude and longitude.
  • Eratosthenes's meridians: Pillars of Hercules, Carthage, Alexandria, Thapsacus (Euphrates), the Caspian Gates, and the mouths of the Indus and Ganges.
  • First parallel (Eratosthenes): from the Pillars of Hercules to the extremity of India.

B. Philosophy and method

Plato
Aristotle
Theory by intuition
Theory from observation
General → particular = Deductive approach
Particular → general = Inductive (scientific) approach
Considered man an active agent who changes the face of the earth (deforestation and soil loss in Attica)
Senses tell us that fire is hot but not why. Observation alone cannot explain
  • Aristotle:
    • Four elements (earth, water, fire, air) plus a fifth, aether, the material of celestial bodies.
    • First teleologist: everything changes according to a pre-existing plan (like a mason who knows the finished house), and things develop towards an ideal state, not away from it.
    • Torrid zone (near the equator) and frigid zones are uninhabitable (later refuted by Posidonius).
    • Book: Meteorologica. Discusses tides (attributed to winds), the earthquake that destroyed Helice and Bura (Achaia), and deposition making the Sea of Azov shallower, so that it would one day become land.

C. Physical geography

  • Rivers and deltas: Nile delta formed from Ethiopian silt. Perennial rivers have their sources in great mountains.
  • Plato: the barren lands of Attica were once forested and fertile; deforestation and soil loss left them like "the skeleton of a sick man". An early idea of human impact and soil erosion.
  • Agatharchides: described gold mines of Ethiopia and how ore was extracted.
  • Oceans and tides:
    • Herodotus observed tides in the Red Sea. Aristotle attributed tides to winds.
    • Nearchus observed tides in the Arabian Sea, and Pytheas in the Atlantic.
    • Pytheas linked the daily recurrence of tides to the Moon's movement.
    • Posidonius explained spring and neap tides.
  • Winds: four winds since Homer. In the 2nd century BC the Athenians built the Tower of the Winds, showing 8 wind directions with weather sculptures (still stands near the Acropolis).
  • Zones and life: torrid, temperate and frigid. Greeks believed Libyans were dark because they were burnt by the Sun, so life near the equator must be impossible. They linked temperature to ecumenic (habitable) regions.
  • Earthquakes and volcanoes: Greece lies in a young Alpine fold belt.
    • Anaximander: earthquakes are fractures of the crust from drying after saturation.
    • Aristotle: caused by winds (gases) trapped underground seeking a vent.
    • Volcanoes were seen as safety valves that lessen the violence of earthquakes.
  • Biogeography: Theophrastus (pupil of Aristotle) described the habitats of trees and shrubs and correlated climate with natural vegetation.