Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Paradigms in Geography (Kuhn) & Laws

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

3 min read3 sections

Paradigms in Geography (Kuhn) & Laws

Laws in geography

  • Geography, like psychology and economics, moved from description → classification → law-making (model formulation), a process that started in the 19th century and accelerated in the 1960s–70s.
  • Natural laws (e.g. gravity) are universal and testable everywhere, endlessly. If a law fails once in a million trials, it is disproved.
  • Individual molecules or people behave randomly, though the mass conforms. Hence stochastic laws describe what the majority will probably do.
  • Golledge and Amedeo: there is no single accepted definition of law. Types: probabilistic, cross-sectional, equilibrium, historical, developmental, statistical, mathematical, stochastic laws and composition rules.
  • Geographical laws differ from natural laws: geography is not an experimental science. No controlled experiments, so testing happens in the uncontrolled field and laws hold "other things being equal" (like economics). The principle of activity applies: everything changes in time and space.
  • Braithwaite: a natural law is "a generalisation of unrestricted range in time and space" (universal validity). Only physics and chemistry qualify, and even physics needs probability.
  • Most geographical laws are empirical, valid for a specific place and time, so they are called models, structured ideas or paradigms.
  • Harvey's three-tier hierarchy of scientific statements: (1) factual statements (systematised descriptions) → (2) empirical generalisations / laws → (3) general or theoretical laws.

Kuhn's paradigm ⭐⭐

  • Thomas S. Kuhn (American historian of science), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962).
  • Science is not a well-regulated, cumulative activity. It is a process of varying tension: tranquil periods of steady accretion separated by crises that cause upheaval and breaks in continuity.
  • Paradigm (Kuhn): "universally recognised scientific achievements that for a time provide model problems and solutions to a community of practitioners". Haggett: a kind of "super-model". It tells researchers what to look for and which methods count as "geographic".

Kuhn's sequence (graphed by Henriksen, 1973, as a stepped "plateau")

Pre-paradigm phase → Professionalisation → Paradigm phase 1 (normal science) → Crisis → Revolution → Paradigm phase 2 → Crisis → …
Phase
Features
1. Pre-paradigm
Conflict among several schools around individual scientists. Indiscriminate data collection over a wide field, low specialisation, much communication with laymen. No school considers itself more "scientific"
2. Professionalisation
One school dominates (new methods or more interesting questions). Mathematics and astronomy left the pre-paradigm phase in antiquity; parts of the social sciences may be doing so today
3. Paradigm phase: "normal science"
A dominant school; concentrated research within a clear problem area
4. Crisis
Stagnation, problems the ruling paradigm cannot solve, a "temporary dark phase". Re-assessment of data, free theoretical speculation, philosophical and methodological debate. Ends (a) if the old paradigm solves the problem, (b) if nothing better appears, or (c) when a new paradigm attracts more researchers
5. Revolution
A complex break in continuity: comprehensive reconstruction of theory, not accumulation. New perception of the world. Younger scientists gain recognition, compete with the old, and prevail as the elders pass away
  • Paradigm change is not wholly rational. The new paradigm solves problems the old one could not, but may fail on problems the old one solved easily. It is seldom provable that the new is better. Normative and aesthetic considerations (simplicity, beauty) and the vested interests of the young (to take over from their elders) play a part.
  • Merits: a scientific account of growth phases, and it eased acceptance of new theories.
  • Demerits: lets young researchers declare paradigms without objective justification. Not value-free, so against positivism. It may give poorly qualified people easy entry. Useful for understanding the history of a subject, but not a complete explanation.

Geographical paradigms: a historical perspective ⭐

Stage
Paradigm
Notes
Ritter
Teleological / holistic synthesis
Inductive, simple empirical generalisations. Phenomena distributed by God's plan, not empirically testable, so not scientific. Still has the character of a paradigm (organic, holistic)
Post-Darwin
Cause and effect; determinism; nomothetic
Hypothetico-deductive methods replaced induction. Models: Davis's cycle of erosion, Mackinder's heartland. Geography gained scientific respect, but human geography was stunted. Geomorphology and determinism = the first paradigm phase in Kuhn's terms
Vidal
Possibilism and French regional geography (idiographic)
Man not passive. Micro-level (pays) studies. Determinism survived alongside: Kuhn's "revolutionary phase". George Chabot: "Regional geography is the centre around which everything converges."
Crisis
Regional geography could not explain regional personality
Led to the quantitative revolution and the functional approach
QR
Spatial science, models, systems
—
Today
No complete revolution. Many schools in parallel: positivists, pragmatists, phenomenologists, existentialists, idealists, realists, dialectical materialists
A crisis phase with revolution, leading to a new paradigm
  • Geography passed from descriptive and teleological to quantitative, radical and dialectical materialist stages, without consensus on its nature, laws and paradigms.