Why this chapter matters: "Systematic vs regional" and "physical vs human" are classic long-answer questions. Key names: Varenius (origin), Hartshorne vs Schaefer (1953 debate), Whittlesey (compage), Berry (continuum), V.A. Anuchin (cycles of science), P.E. James ("semantic trap"), Darby (four approaches to historical geography), Mackinder ("historical present").
Overview
- Geographers have always faced the methodological problem of dualism and dichotomy. Sister disciplines share it too.
- Ancient roots: Herodotus (tribes and surroundings), Strabo (regional description), Ptolemy (mathematical). Hippocrates, Aristotle, Xenophon, Aryabhata, Al-Masudi, Al-Biruni, Al-Idrisi and Ibn Khaldun looked at environment and lifestyle.
- Dualism became conspicuous in the post-Renaissance period.
- Main dichotomies:
- General (systematic) vs regional geography
- Physical vs human geography
- Historical vs contemporary geography
- Functional (nodal) regions vs formal (uniform) regions
- (Also determinism vs possibilism, deductive vs inductive, idiographic vs nomothetic)
P.E. James: "The acceptance of many dichotomies is a semantic trap." Topical vs regional, physical vs human, determinism vs possibilism, deductive vs inductive, idiographic vs nomothetic, formal vs functional are not mutually contradictory like good and evil or reason and faith. No dichotomy exists when one alleged opposite is a subordinate part of the other or derived from it. These dichotomies have done particular damage to geographical thinking.