Background
- Little academic attention until the mid-19th century. Geography = exploration and travel description, taught in schools by historians and geologists as memorisation: "an encyclopaedia of information".
- After Darwin (1859), British scholars began studying the earth as the home of man.
- Geography entered British universities at the end of the 19th century.
Halford J. Mackinder (1861–1947) ⭐
Founder of the British School of Geography. A dynamic lecturer with an imaginative mind. First recorded person to climb Mt Kenya (1899). Appointed Reader in Geography at Oxford in 1887, the first of the new academic geographers. Later Director of the LSE and an MP (commonly cited).
Views on geography
- To be a discipline rather than a mere body of information, geography must bridge the natural sciences and the humanities (and history and geology).
- Core: "the interaction of man in society and his environment, varying locally".
- Held physical and human geography together in an evolutionary perspective. Stressed geography's utility for teachers, scientists, statesmen and merchants. Often recalled in debates on keeping physical and human geography together.
- Thinking governed by visualisation (on the map and in the mind) of world regional complexes.
- Founder of historical geography in Britain: geographers should reconstruct past geographies and show how sequences of change produced present features. Otherwise geography is mere description of the present.
Heartland Theory ⭐⭐
- 1904: paper "The Geographical Pivot of History" (Royal Geographical Society) = the Heartland Theory.
- World Island = Eurasia + Africa.
- Heartland (Pivot Area) = the inaccessible interior of Eurasia (roughly Siberia/USSR). Low population and difficult access, inaccessible to sea power, so invulnerable. The coastlands have always been vulnerable to attack from it.
- Famous dictum (1919):
Who rules East Europe commands the Heartland;
Who rules the Heartland commands the World Island;
Who rules the World Island commands the World.
- Restated in 1943 ("The Round World and the Winning of the Peace"): warned of the Heartland falling wholly under Soviet control and Russia striking at the peripheral lands.
- Contains environmental determinism, but its simplicity shaped Western Cold War geopolitics (the image of an expansionist USSR). "A generation ahead of his time."
📚 Works
Year | Work |
1902 | Britain and the British Seas: a classic regional interpretation |
1904 | "The Geographical Pivot of History" |
1919 | Democratic Ideals and Reality: world power politics |
Regional tradition before WWI
- H. Robert Mill: The Realm of Nature (races of man), International Geography. Director of the British Rainfall Organisation (1901): rainfall maps from 50-year averages. Proposed a land-use map at 1 inch : 1 mile (rejected). Wrote biographies of polar explorers.
- Influences: Vidal de la Blache and the French sociologist Frédéric Le Play.
- Le Play formula: Place – Work – Family. Family life depends on work (means of subsistence), and work depends on place (environment).
- Sir Patrick Geddes (Scottish biologist, sociologist, planner) changed it to Place – Work – Folk, the basic concepts for studying cities and regions.
- The Geddes scheme of regional survey (a 3×3 matrix of place/work/folk interactions) was widely used between the wars in teaching and in regional and town-planning surveys.
- Geography is not merely descriptive but an applied science.
- Le Play Society (founded through Geddes's influence): 71 field surveys, 8 monographs, disbanded 1960.
- Andrew J. Herbertson (Geddes's assistant, later Director of the Oxford School of Geography): 1905: "The Major Natural Regions of the World": the world divided into 15 natural regions by surface features, climate and vegetation. The same regions recur in similar positions on each continent.
- A.G. Ogilvie: edited Great Britain: Essays in Regional Geography (1928).
- P.M. Roxby: a scheme for regional study: geology, drainage, coastline, climate, vegetation → natural regions → man's relation to his physical environment.
Branches in the inter-war period
Economic geography
- Buchanan: Pastoral Industries of New Zealand (influence of environment on the economy).
- G.G. Chisholm: Handbook of Commercial Geography (1889).
- Wilfred Smith (1949): An Economic Geography of Great Britain, a systematic, statistical, ecological approach, far ahead of its time, with no fieldwork.
Man–nature interaction (1880–1914)
- Geography = description of the earth's surface and its influence on man. Delineated natural regions to see man's role in them.
- The British rejected French regional synthesis as unachievable, so more physical geography (geomorphology) monographs were produced.
- C. Daryll Forde: Habitat, Economy and Society (1934) on primitive societies. Culture and cultural contacts, not the direct physical environment, explain modes of life. Environmental determinism flatly rejected.
Agricultural geography
- L. Dudley Stamp: Land Utilisation Survey of Britain (1930s). Used for emergency crop expansion in WWII and post-war reconstruction. Knighted (the book says 1965).
- Little progress in rural settlement (H.J. Fleure and followers) and urban structure.
Historical geography
- Founded by Mackinder: changing man–nature connections through time.
- Contributors: M.I. Newbigin, E.G.R. Taylor, E.W. Gilbert, H.C. Darby (Darby commonly cited).
Contemporary trends
- Quantitative revolution (from the USA): Richard Chorley and Peter Haggett used statistics, models, multivariate analysis and hypothesis testing. Geography as a spatial science: an "accurate, orderly and rational description of the variable character of the earth's surface" (Hartshorne's phrase).
- Books: Models in Geography (1967), Locational Analysis in Human Geography (Haggett, 1965), Frontiers in Geographical Teaching (1965).
- New concerns: regional inequality, environmental degradation and management, welfare, medical geography, landscape ecology.
- Philosophies:
- Positivism: a type of empiricism; science deals only with empirical (factual, sensed) questions, not normative (value) ones; unity of science (one method, repeatable observation); laws of society can be discovered like laws of nature.
- Pragmatism (from America): emphasis on practical problems and concrete situations.
- Realism: now opposed to idealism. (In Platonic thought, realism opposed nominalism: universals have real existence.)
- Behaviouralism and humanism.
- RGS sponsors expeditions and publishes the Geographical Journal. Institute of British Geographers (IBG), founded 1933, merged with the RGS in 1995.