Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Ch 11 — Models in Geography

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

4 min read7 sections

Ch 11 — Models in Geography

🎯
Why this chapter matters: Definitions of a model (Skilling, Ackoff, Haines-Young and Petch, Chorley–Haggett), types of models (scale, simulation/stochastic, Monte Carlo vs Markov, mathematical, analogue, theoretical), the five-storey framework, and criticisms. Frequently asked in NET and UPSC.

Definitions ⭐

  • Post-WWII geography concentrated on generalisation, models, theories and laws: "model-building".
Author
Definition
Skilling (1964)
A model is "either a theory, a law, a hypothesis or a structured idea". It can include reasoning about the real world through relations in space or time, and can be a role, a relation or an equation
Ackoff
"The formal presentation of a theory or law using the tools of logic, set theory and mathematics"
Haines-Young and Petch
"Any device or mechanism which generates a prediction is a model". Modelling, like experiment and observation, lets theories be tested
Most post-war geographers / Chorley and Haggett
"An idealised or simplified representation of reality" (landscape and man–nature relations)

Significance

  • The earth (the "real document" of geography) is complex, diverse and dynamic. Models simplify complex situations to make them amenable to investigation. They are tools for testing theories and, in a narrower view, predictive devices.

Need for modelling (reasons) ⭐

  1. The only means to quantify unobserved or unobservable phenomena. Used for estimation, forecasting, simulation, interpolation and data generation: population growth, land use, cropping intensity, migration, urbanisation, slums; weather, climate change, sea level, pollution, soil erosion, deforestation, landform evolution.
  1. To describe, analyse and simplify a geographical system: industrial location, agricultural zoning, migration, landform stages.
  1. To structure and organise enormous data by picking out patterns and correlations.
  1. Alternative models act as "laboratories" for surrogate observation, for experimenting with changes, and for generating future scenarios.
  1. To improve understanding of causal mechanisms and micro–macro relations.
  1. To give a framework for theoretical statements and test their empirical validity.
  1. Linguistic economy.
  1. To help build theories and general and special laws.

Features of a model ⭐

  1. Selective: a selective picture, not all attributes of a region ("a highly selective attitude to information").
  1. Gives prominence to some features and obscures or distorts others.
  1. Contains suggestions for generalisation, allowing predictions.
  1. Models are analogies, different from reality.
  1. Tempt us to form hypotheses and build theory.
  1. Show reality in a more familiar, simplified, observable, accessible, controllable form.
  1. Give a framework for defining, collecting and arranging information.
  1. Squeeze maximum information from data.
  1. Explain how a phenomenon came into being.
  1. Allow comparison with more familiar phenomena.
  1. Let us visualise phenomena too large or complex to grasp otherwise.
  1. Stepping stones to theories and laws.

Types of models

Broad divisions

Basis
Types
Function
Descriptive: a stylised description of reality, organising empirical information (data, classificatory/taxonomic, experimental design models). Normative: what might be expected under stated conditions. Uses a familiar situation as a model for a less familiar one (in time or space). Strongly predictive
Material ("stuff")
Physical / experimental (iconic): the same properties at a changed scale (maps, globes, geological models). Analogue / simulation: real properties represented by different properties, in symbolic verbal or mathematical form

General classification ⭐⭐

Model
Description
Examples and notes
1. Scale (hardware) models
Direct reproductions of reality, usually smaller. Static (land-surface or geological model) or dynamic (wave tank, river flume)
Dynamic models let processes be controlled: hold two variables constant and vary the third. In a wave tank, the effects of material size, wavelength and wave steepness on beach slope. Scale problem: scaled-up sand becomes cobbles; scaled-down sand becomes silt or clay, which behave differently. Engineers use them for dams, canals, river works, harbours, flood forecasting. Used by geomorphologists (rivers, glaciers, coasts, groundwater)
Maps
The most familiar models for geographers. A special scale model, more abstract at smaller scales
From the stereo-pair vertical air photo (almost a true scale model, but static) to large-scale maps and small-scale symbolic maps. Maps show relief (contours, hill shading, hachures) and a large area at once. Diagrammatic maps (e.g. scaled by population: cartograms). A 3-D earth cannot be shown correctly on a 2-D plane. Globes are true but of little practical use
2. Simulation and stochastic models
Simulation = imitating a process with an analogous situation. Stochastic = randomly determined, analysable statistically but not precisely predictable. For dynamic situations
Random-walk drainage: grid squares, random stream sources and random flow directions produce a network like natural drainage, so natural drainage has an element of chance. Coastal spit: processes allotted ranges of random numbers; if the simulated spit matches the real one, the proportions are probably right, and it can predict. Human geography: spatial diffusion of diseases (malaria, smallpox, dengue, AIDS) and innovations (tractors, fertilisers, pesticides), with barriers of varying difficulty
• Monte Carlo
Chance alone determines each move
Hägerstrand's diffusion
• Markov chain
Each move is partly determined by the previous move
The random-walk drainage model
3. Mathematical models
Considered more reliable but hard to build. Obscure human values. Logical: "A > B, B > C, therefore A > C" is ahistorical (true at all times) and aspatial (true everywhere). Deterministic or stochastic by probability
J.F. Nye's glacier-flow model: a rectangular (U-shaped) bed, perfectly plastic ice, differential equations predict flow and profile, checked against field data, then used for unmeasurable parts (e.g. basal flow). Also river load and bed adjustment, coastal waves. Best suited to physical geography. In human geography, empirical relations: the rank–size rule (few large towns, many small; linear on double-log scale). Linear programming in economic geography: the optimum location satisfying constraints (labour, capital, raw materials, transport, markets)
4. Analogue models
Study a feature by analogy with a better-known, different one. Positive analogy (common elements) is used; negative (dissimilar) and neutral (irrelevant) analogies are ignored
James Hutton (1795): circulation of blood ↔ circulation of matter in landscapes (and the hydrological cycle). Davis's cycle of erosion and Ratzel's state as an organism are organic analogies. Metals under stress ↔ ice. Kinematic waves applied to traffic, stones and flood waves in rivers, and surges at glacier snouts (all one-dimensional flows). Gravity model from Newton: interaction ∝ (P₁ × P₂) / d², assuming no barriers (international or language). Also magnetic fields and the second law of thermodynamics (entropy)
5. Theoretical models
(a) Conceptual: a theoretical view whose deductions are matched with reality
Sea level and the coastal zone: with waves as the only process, an erosion depth of about 13 m (40 ft) and a limiting platform gradient, only a slowly rising sea level produces a very wide wave-cut platform. Also slope-profile evolution models
ㅤ
(b) Theory as the overall framework of the discipline
Must be flexible, not rigid. Models are common to all branches, so they give unity

Five-storey framework of geography (Figure 11.1) ⭐

Storey
Content
5 (top)
Tendencies and laws: the ultimate aim
4
Theories
3
Techniques of analysis (depend on the model)
2
Model: data organised for analysis
1 (ground)
Geographical data: raw material
Each storey is supported by the one below and supports the one above.

Criticisms of modelling ⭐

  1. Poorly made models:
      • Over-simplification misleads students and gives bad predictions.
      • Under-simplification explains nothing and gives an insufficient basis for prediction.
  1. Concentrate on the wrong things. Techniques like principal component analysis, stepwise regression and Q-analysis can produce models more complex than the original data, and may include some salient points while omitting others.
  1. Not appropriate everywhere: in human, regional, cultural and historical geography, modelling has distorted the subject (over- or under-emphasis), generalising from few cases at the expense of specific ones.
  1. Outright rejection: geography is not a pure physical science. Models cannot handle beliefs, values, emotions, attitudes, aspirations, hopes, fears.
  1. Generalisation itself may be futile where idiosyncratic human action and free will operate, or where interest lies in the unique case.
  1. Mathematical sophistication: few geographers (or students, policymakers, the public) are comfortable with mathematical symbolism.
  1. No model is adequate by itself: each needs constant reassessment and replacement. Feyerabend (1975): knowledge is "an ever increasing ocean of mutually incompatible alternatives … Nothing is ever settled, no view can ever be omitted." Growth of knowledge is not well-regulated but has crises and breaks (Kuhn).
  1. Data requirements: reliable data are rare in developing countries, so models give a distorted picture and exaggerated results and wrong predictions.
  1. Western bias: models built on about 100 years of European and American data risk being raised to universal truths. There is no universal human, cultural, industrial, agricultural or urban geography. Applying them to developing countries may be disastrous.
📚
Key references: Chorley and Haggett, Models in Geography (1967) and Integrated Models in Geography (1969). Cole and King, Quantitative Geography (1968). Braithwaite, Scientific Explanation (1953). Berry, "Approaches to Regional Analysis: A Synthesis" (1964). Bunge, "Geographical Dialectics" (1964).