Beginnings
- Geography was diffused to the USA by Europeans in the mid-19th century. Courses in mathematical, physical and historical geography were taught at Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Columbia, Princeton and Pennsylvania as early as 1795.
- Arnold Guyot (Princeton) was the first Professor of Geography in America. A follower of Ritter and a teleologist: continents are the abode of man and the theatre of human societies. Influential school textbooks. Explored the Appalachians for over 30 years (about 12,000 observations, meteorological data).
- 1870: physical geography at Harvard (Department of Natural History). American Geographical Society, 1851/52.
- N.S. Shaler (Harvard geologist, Davis's teacher): Nature and Man in America (1891): physical conditions shape organic life, and geographic features control settlement. Thinking at the time held that man's life was ordained by the physical environment.
William Morris Davis (1850–1934) ⭐
Born to Quaker parents in Philadelphia. Harvard graduate (1869). Worked at the Meteorological Observatory, Córdoba, Argentina (1870–73). Assistant to Shaler (1876), Assistant Professor (1878), Professor of Geography, Harvard (1899). Founder of the Association of American Geographers (AAG), 1904. Introduced professional geography into the USA. Main founder of modern geography in America.
Cycle of erosion (Geographical Cycle) ⭐⭐
- Developed from observations in Montana (1877). Presented at the International Geographical Congress, 1899 (paper "The Geographical Cycle").
- Also called the geomorphological or topographical cycle.
- Davis's definition: a scheme under which a mental counterpart of every landform is developed in terms of its understructure, the erosional process, and the stage reached, from initiation by upheaval to the close when erosion is complete. Land is described by its inferred mental counterpart, not just its visible features.
- Model:
- A surface is uplifted rapidly.
- Rivers immediately start eroding: narrow V-shaped valleys extend headward.
- Rivers cannot cut below the base level (the level of the water body they flow into).
- Stages: youth → maturity → old age → peneplain.
- "Landscape is a function of structure, process and stage (time)." Based on Darwin's evolution (landforms evolve like organisms).
- Criticised by the Pencks (Germany).
Later views
- The study of man cannot be limited to the physical environment.
- "Ontography": the ecological study of human groups, like plants and animals. Adjustment to the physical earth, plus migration and segregation (Ratzel's view).
- Regionalisation results from three forces: site base, migration and association.
- Regional geography describes "the geographical elements of a given area in their totality … in their natural combinations and correlation".
- Critic of human geographers: their studies are unbalanced. Regional descriptions must be "homologous": land, climate, vegetation, animals and man given equal emphasis.
- Purpose of geography: descriptive generalisation based on explanation.
- His attitude passed through two phases: deterministic, then ecological.
- Bridged geology and geography.
- Students: Mark Jefferson, Isaiah Bowman, Ellsworth Huntington, (influenced) Ellen Semple, A.P. Brigham.
Mark Jefferson (1863–1949)
- Davis's student. Teacher at Michigan State Normal College, Ypsilanti. A linguist and prolific writer.
- Founder of real "man-oriented" geography in America, seeking generalisations about man's imprint on the land.
- Coined:
- "Law of the Primate City" (1939)
- "Central places" (cities as central places)
- "The civilizing rails": areas of access to railroads
- Studied the size, extent and functions of cities.
- His concern was with men: "where they are, what they are like, and why they are there". An ecological approach.
Isaiah Bowman (1878–1950)
- A farm boy from Michigan. Studied under Jefferson and Davis (Harvard). PhD at Yale (under H.E. Gregory, 1905).
- Fieldwork in the Andes (Peru, Bolivia, Chile) and the Atacama. Dissertation: The Geography of the Central Andes (The Andes of Southern Peru, 1916).
- 📚 The Pioneer Fringe (1931): settlement frontiers in the USA, Canada, Australia, South Africa, Siberia, Mongolia, Manchuria and South America. Also The New World (1921, political geography) (commonly cited).
- Started as an environmental determinist, later stressed man's role: "Man is changing himself as well as the world as he goes along."
- Director of the AGS. Adviser at the Paris Peace Conference (commonly cited).
Ellen Churchill Semple (1863–1932) ⭐⭐
The foremost woman geographer of her time. Vassar graduate (1891), MA in history. Attended Ratzel's lectures at Leipzig (1891–92 and 1895). Introduced Ratzel's anthropogeography to America. Travelled to Siberia, Mongolia, Japan, China, the Philippines, Java and India. A persuasive teacher with exceptional literary style.
📚 Works
Year | Book |
1903 | American History and Its Geographic Conditions |
1911 | Influences of Geographic Environment (her version of Vol. I of Ratzel's Anthropogeographie) |
1931 | The Geography of the Mediterranean Region (her final work) |
Key ideas (leading environmental determinist)
- "Location means climate and plant life at one end of the scale, civilisation and political status at the other."
- Famous opening: "Man is a product of the earth's surface." The earth has "mothered him, fed him, set him tasks, directed his thoughts":
- Mountains give him leg muscles of iron.
- Coasts give him a vigorous chest and arms for the oar.
- River valleys tie him to the soil and narrow his outlook.
- Deserts and steppes give leisure and a big horizon, so ideas take on a "gigantic simplicity": monotheism (God becomes one, like the unbroken desert), then fanaticism, then wide imperial conquests.
- Man cannot be studied apart from his land, any more than the polar bear or desert cactus apart from its habitat.
- "Man has been so noisy about the way he has conquered nature, and nature has been so silent in her persistent influence over man." The geographic factor "never sleeps": it is the permanent element in the shifting fate of races.
- Comparative method examples:
- Islands (England, Japan, Fiji, New Zealand, Crete) share traits.
- Steppe and desert belt: always pastoral nomads (Scythians, Huns, Tartars, Turks, Tuareg), whatever the race. Drought pushes them to invade river valleys (Hwang Ho, Indus, Ganges, Nile). History repeats itself.
- Arid lands depend on irrigation: "The mantle of the ancient Egyptian priest has fallen upon the modern British engineer."
- Arctic explorers succeed by imitating Eskimos. North of the 0°C isotherm in Siberia and Canada: fewer than 2 persons per square mile, a hunting economy, fur traders.
- Tropics are a melting pot: heat and disease reduce intruders to native efficiency, so hybridisation.
- History and geography: quotes Kant ("geography lies at the basis of history") and Herder ("history is geography set into motion"). "All historical problems should be studied geographically and all geographic problems historically." "Every map has its date."
- Behind Massachusetts' abolitionism lay New England's granite soil and boulder fields. Behind the South's slavery lay rich plantations.
- India vs Greece (indirect causation): Montesquieu (warm climate makes oriental customs immutable) and Buckle (great mountains and plains breed imagination and superstition) were too direct. The scientific geographer finds India's isolation (mountains, deltaic swamps, unbroken coast) produced ignorance and early crystallisation of custom, while Greece's accessibility made it an intellectual clearing house.
- Survival of traits after migration: the Jews kept pastoral traits in Palestine. Balkan Turks still prefer sheep and goat meat (suited to nomadism) over beef and pork.
- Method: compare typical peoples under similar geographic conditions, who have similar histories and ways of life.
Albert Perry Brigham (1855–1932)
- Was a church minister at Utica, then studied with Shaler at Harvard. Moved from geomorphology to human groups.
- Critical of determinists: against vague claims of climatic influence on race, skin colour and constitution.
- "Influence, response or adjustment" matter little. Interpret similar phenomena in different regions cautiously: they may arise from the unity of the human spirit, similar environments, or both.
- Helped run the AAG. Wrote Geographic Influences in American History (1903) (commonly cited).
Carl O. Sauer (1889–1975) ⭐⭐
At the University of California, Berkeley for most of his career, founding the Berkeley School. Attended Semple's lectures but rejected the determinism of Ratzel and Semple. Fieldwork in Latin America and less-industrialised parts of the USA.
Main interests
- Origin of agriculture, diffusion of plants and animals, and the impact of conquest on indigenous Americans.
- Processes of landscape change from the prehuman stage of occupance to the present.
- Princeton symposium (1955): "Man's Role in Changing the Face of the Earth" (conceived by W.L. Thomas).
- Insisted on the historical method.
- "Geography dissociates itself from geology at the point of the introduction of man into the areal scene." (Geologists object, since human changes have geological consequences: landslides, falling water tables, waterlogging, soil creep.)
"The Morphology of Landscape" (1925) ⭐
- Introduced the term "landscape" into American geography, drawing on the German Landschaft (Passarge, Schlüter). The word originally meant the appearance of an area (Dutch painters).
- An alternative to environmental determinism: describe and explain human–environment interrelations, with primary attention to human impact.
- Landscape = an area made up of a distinct association of forms, both physical and cultural. It has form, structure and function.
- Geography studies area, region or landscape. Phenomena are associated (interdependent), not merely assorted. The task is to discover their "connection and order". Geography is the phenomenology of landscape.
- "The geographic study of any region must begin with a study of its entire previous geography, chronologically arranged." Trace the natural landscape → cultural landscape (genetic method).
- Problem: the natural landscape can seldom be reconstructed, since humans changed everything long ago, so all landscapes are cultural. The Berkeley School became the study of cultural history.
- Study of the cultural landscape involves:
- (a) General geography: the forms themselves (= systematic)
- (b) Regional geography: comparative morphology
- (c) Historical geography: developmental sequence (sequent occupance)
- Every landscape has individuality and relations with others: no valley, settlement or city is a replica. (Norway: four-fifths barren highland. Libya: four-fifths desert.)
- Geography is anthropocentric: we select qualities of landscape with habitat value (present or potential) for man.
Famous formula ⭐⭐
"The cultural landscape is fashioned out of a natural landscape by a cultural group. Culture is the agent, the natural area is the medium, the cultural landscape the result."
- Under a changing culture, the landscape passes through phases, perhaps completing a cycle. An alien culture brings rejuvenation or a new landscape superimposed on remnants of the old.
- Within the wide limits of the physical equipment there are many choices. Choices come from the mind of man, not nature, so they are cultural.
- Morphology diagram:
- Natural landscape: factors (geognostic, climatic, vegetational) + time → forms (climate, land surface, soil, drainage, minerals, sea and coast, vegetation).
- Cultural landscape: culture (factor) + time → forms (population, housing, production, communication).
- Aesthetic qualities of landscape lie beyond science: Humboldt's "physiognomy", Banse's "soul", Volz's "rhythm", Gradmann's "harmony".
- "The landscape has an organic quality."
Ellsworth Huntington (1876–1947) ⭐⭐
Pupil of Davis, at Yale. A creative thinker, prolific writer (author or co-author of 28 books), and imaginative interpreter of climate's effects on human life. Sought the "architectural unity" of world structure. Travelled in North Africa (to the equator), Europe and South America.
📚 Works
Year | Book | Thesis |
1907 | The Pulse of Asia | Pulsatory climate change: the great outpourings of Central Asian nomads (the Mongol conquests of India and China, the invasion of Eastern Europe in the 13th century) were caused by pastures drying up |
1915 | Civilization and Climate | Civilisations develop only in regions of stimulating weather. The monotonous heat of the tropics forbids high civilisation |
1920 | Principles of Human Geography | A textbook read widely by historians, sociologists, doctors, ecologists |
1945 | Mainsprings of Civilization | Heredity, selection and climate |
Ideas (climatic determinism)
- A rational understanding of history requires knowledge of the changing physical background.
- Changes in the Sun cause changes in terrestrial climate, and climate profoundly influences man, culture, life and geological processes.
- Weather influences energy, health, longevity, attitudes and achievements. Levels of civilisation roughly correspond to climatic regions.
- Ideal climate: a well-defined seasonal pattern, frequent weather changes (temperate cyclonic storms), sufficient warmth and rain for agriculture. About 20°C with variable conditions gives the highest mental and physical efficiency: NW Europe and NE USA.
- Civilisation shifts towards cooler climates as culture advances.
- "In an invigorating climate it may be easier to be honest and sober and self-controlled than in an enervating one."
- Selective migration, selective survival and intermarriage shaped history.
- Used a quantitative approach to measure civilisation. Also considered heredity, culture stage and diet.
- Criticism: too much weight to climate, too little to the autonomous development of societies.
Rollin D. Salisbury (1858–1922)
- A major force from 1903 to 1919. Founded the Department of Geography, University of Chicago (1903). Teacher, administrator, textbook writer.
- 📚 Physiography: a classic on landform evolution.
- Rejected simple cause and effect between the earth and human response. Physiography = the scientific study of the "stage setting" on which the human drama unfolds, but the relation of stage to action is not causal.
Inter-war geography in the USA (1919–1939)
- Shift from the physical to the social. Description of unique places and regions. Social Darwinism attacked, strong determinism rejected.
- New approaches: (1) human ecology, (2) chorology, (3) historical geography, (4) functional organisation of space (a city and its hinterland). Geography became applied, for planning.
Human ecology
- Harlan H. Barrows (1877–1960), presidential address "Geography as Human Ecology" (1923): geography = man's adjustment to his natural environment.
- Proposed relinquishing geomorphology, climatology and biogeography (too broad). Physical conditions should be studied only in relation to man, not deterministically, but as man's place in the "web of life".
Chorology
- Jefferson and Sauer. Describe the visible character of areas and differences from place to place. Man, following his culture's norms, transforms nature into the cultural landscape.
- New jargon: Köppen's letter symbols for climates. Locational analysis gave more weight to raw materials, markets, power and labour than to relief or climate.
Historical geography
- Ralph H. Brown: Mirror for Americans (1943) and Historical Geography of the United States (1948).
- Sauer: prehistoric Indian frontier settlement on the Pacific coast of Mexico. Land means different things to people with different attitudes, objectives and technology (slope for the hoe vs the tractor; water power before steam).
- Derwent Whittlesey (1929): "sequent occupance": a succession of human occupations of an area, the antithesis of determinism. Also the hierarchy of central places (per the book).
- Platt: microgeographic field studies. Hartshorne: theoretical framework for political geography.
Scope and method: Richard Hartshorne ⭐
- The Nature of Geography (1939), Perspective on the Nature of Geography (1959).
- Geography = the study of "areal differentiation".
- "Geography is concerned to provide accurate, orderly and rational description and interpretation of the variable character of the earth's surface." Analysis and synthesis of highly heterogeneous interrelated phenomena.
- A phenomenon is significant in geography to the extent its interrelations with others in the same place, or connections with other places, determine areal variations.
- One may look back into the past as far as data allow.
- Releasing geography from a narrow focus on man–nature relations gives wider scope and more coherence. Topical geography allows generic principles, and unique places offer inexhaustible research.
- The AAG debated objectives and methods. New fields were defined: regional, population, settlement, resource, climatology, field techniques, agricultural, transport, geomorphology, medical, administrative, military.
- Applied work: resource inventories, land classification, land capability, economic surveys, conservation.
- WWII: geographers served in the military and intelligence (uniforms for climatic zones, transport). Also research on hazards, floods, droughts, pollution, and retail centres.
Post-WWII US geography
- To be scientifically respectable, geography dropped synthetic regional geography and developed systematic fields seeking universal laws. The regional method was discredited.
- Systematic specialisation: a particular phenomenon across the earth and the process behind its spatial arrangement. Man–environment system with an ecosystem approach.
- 1960s: the language of mathematics (more precise than literary language). Statistical tools, even astrophysical laws (gravity models), for the size and spacing of cities, transport networks, flows and crop distribution.
- Analysis of spatial systems, with two facets: (1) group behaviour / "spatial perception"; (2) current social problems and useful research. Quantitative "regional science".
- Interdisciplinary approach. Cultural geography: the earth as the home of man, who through culture became the ecological master.
- Political geography: interaction of area and political processes.
- Locational theory: location, spread, density and geometry; flows and linkages; temporal dynamics; normative models for efficient solutions.
- Remote sensing, computers, aerial photography. Geography as a laboratory science (cartographic labs, simulation).
- US geography is essentially a social science, and physical geography has been "woefully neglected".