Why this chapter matters: The core of UPSC Paper I "Contemporary approaches" and NET. For each philosophy know the founder/philosopher, key geographers, books, core principles and criticisms: positivism, pragmatism, functionalism, existentialism, idealism, realism, Marxism, radicalism, behaviouralism, humanism, public policy and applied geography, postmodernism, time geography.
Introduction
- Philosophies impose a set of subjective constraints under which research is done. Methodology is the logic of explanation (rigorous arguments, reasonable inferences, internally coherent methods).
- The methodologist cares about the logical nature of explanation. The philosopher cares about beliefs about the nature of geography.
- Their outcome is a theory or paradigm.
- Geographical thought at any time = the interaction of prevailing philosophies and methodologies, so the focus keeps extending and shifting.
- The 1970s were a turning point: positivism, idealism, pragmatism and functionalism were redefined, while idealism, existentialism, Marxism, radicalism, humanism and behaviouralism entered as humanistic approaches.
Sub-pages
Positivism, Pragmatism & FunctionalismExistentialism, Idealism & RealismMarxism & Radical GeographyBehaviouralism & HumanismPublic Policy, Welfare & Applied GeographyPostmodernism, Time Geography & Postmodern Feminism⚡ Quick Revision — Chapter 12
Approach | Core idea (one line) | Key names / works | Main criticism |
Positivism | Only sensed, verifiable facts; value-free; unity of science | Comte (1830s); Vienna Circle (1930); QR, Schaefer | Value-free impossible; man ≠ thing |
Pragmatism | Meaning via experience; solve practical problems | Peirce, James, Dewey; applied geography | — |
Functionalism | Society/region as system; form–function; equilibrium | Brunhes; manifest vs latent functions | Static bias; teleology (vulture example); ignores poverty/war |
Existentialism | Existence before essence; man makes himself | Samuels — "biography of landscape", existential space | — |
Idealism | Reality mind-dependent; verstehen (rethinking) | Guelke; Collingwood | Can't be sure explanation true |
Realism | Reality independent of mind; hidden causal structures; asks "why" | Gibson; Cook Wilson (naive); Nunn (new); Sayer/Bhaskar | — |
Marxism | Historical/dialectical materialism; mode of production; class struggle | Harvey (Social Justice and the City, 1973) | USSR failure; man as cog |
Radicalism | Social relevance: poverty, racism, sexism, Vietnam, imperialism | Antipode (1969, Clark Univ.); Peet; Bunge; Blaut; Hayford | Weak theory; radical in topics not method; time over space |
Behaviouralism | Behaviour based on perceived (behavioural) environment; satisficer | Wolpert (1964); Kirk; Boulding (1956); Downs; Sonnenfeld; Golledge; Koffka's Lake Constance | "Ratomorphic view of man"; image–behaviour link unproven |
Humanism | Human agency, meaning, place; hermeneutics | Kirk (1951); Tuan (1976); Relph; Ley & Samuels (1978); Wright's geosophy | Subjective; methodologically obscure; little applied work |
Welfare | "Who gets what, where and how" | D.M. Smith; Mishan | — |
Applied | Use geography to solve societal problems | Stamp (1960); Coppock; Applied Geography (1981) | Stoddart: "trivial issues" |
Postmodernism | No meta-theory; difference; deconstruction; return to areal differentiation | Soja (1989); Dear; Olsson (deconstruction); Gregory | — |
Time geography | Time–space paths, prisms; capability/coupling/authority constraints | Hägerstrand, Lund School | Small-scale, individual, ignores institutions |
Postmodern feminism | Gender + race, class, sexuality; masculinist discipline | Rose (1993); Johnson (1989) | — |