From description to modern geography
- Before Varenius and Kant: geography = geo + graphy, largely descriptive.
- Varenius and Kant = the Classical Period of Modern Geography. Humboldt and Ritter = founders of modern geography.
The Humboldt and Ritter legacies
Humboldt | Ritter |
Sharp observer and wide traveller (Europe, Asia, Americas) | Teleologist |
Geography as a systematic discipline; sought universal laws in physical geography | Emphasised the historical aspect. Drifted to regional geography and a primary concern with man |
Established physical geography after his South American expedition | Produced a galaxy of students |
Held no university post, so had no academic followers, but far greater influence outside Germany | — |
After Ritter, "the real representatives of geography were the scientific travellers who took Humboldt for their model" | — |
Ritter's students
- Ernst Kapp: political problems.
- Arnold Guyot: held the first chair of geography in the USA (Princeton). A teleologist, regional geography on Ritter's lines.
- Élisée Reclus (France): Ritter's most successful student, drew on the Erdkunde. A social anarchist.
- La Terre (1866–67): systematic physical geography.
- Nouvelle Géographie Universelle (1875–94): 19 volumes of regional geography.
- Mainly interested in the human aspect. Schmidt called him the "Ritter of France".
- Moltke: geography in military science.
Post-1859 turmoil
- 1859: Humboldt and Ritter both died, and Darwin's Origin of Species was published.
- The followers split geography in several directions, and its unity was questioned. No professor of geography in any German university after Ritter's death.
- Geography's revival came from scholars trained as geologists, who specialised in physical geography. The central problem was to overcome disunity and unite the physical and cultural.
- Bucher attacked natural boundaries and natural regions. Ritter's teleology was rejected.
New directions
Trend | Proponents and ideas |
Environmental determinism | Ratzel, Anthropogeographie: history, culture and life are largely shaped by environment. "Similar locations lead to similar modes of life." Lebensraum (living space) transformed German political thinking |
"Geologification" of geography (after Darwin) | Landforms became the main field. W.M. Davis: "geographical cycle" (cycle of erosion), an analogy with organic life: landforms evolve like organisms |
Extreme determinism | Ellen Semple, Influences of Geographic Environment (1911): "Man is a product of the earth's surface." |
Possibilism (reaction) | Man is an active agent. Environment offers options, which multiply as knowledge and technology grow. Nature is never more than an adviser. Febvre: "There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities." Vidal de la Blache: genre de vie (ways of life) |
Landform morphology (Germany) | Peschel: morphology of landforms and their influence on history. Richthofen: China (1877), landforms. Penck (geologist): landforms are the major concern |
Physical vs human dichotomy | Gerland (the book prints "Wegener"): geography is a pure natural science. The French possibilists: human geography as the thrust area |