Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Shifting Viewpoints in the Second Half of the 19th Century

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

1 min read4 sections

Shifting Viewpoints in the Second Half of the 19th Century

From description to modern geography

  • Before Varenius and Kant: geography = geo + graphy, largely descriptive.
  • Varenius and Kant = the Classical Period of Modern Geography. Humboldt and Ritter = founders of modern geography.

The Humboldt and Ritter legacies

Humboldt
Ritter
Sharp observer and wide traveller (Europe, Asia, Americas)
Teleologist
Geography as a systematic discipline; sought universal laws in physical geography
Emphasised the historical aspect. Drifted to regional geography and a primary concern with man
Established physical geography after his South American expedition
Produced a galaxy of students
Held no university post, so had no academic followers, but far greater influence outside Germany
—
After Ritter, "the real representatives of geography were the scientific travellers who took Humboldt for their model"
—

Ritter's students

  • Ernst Kapp: political problems.
  • Arnold Guyot: held the first chair of geography in the USA (Princeton). A teleologist, regional geography on Ritter's lines.
  • Élisée Reclus (France): Ritter's most successful student, drew on the Erdkunde. A social anarchist.
    • La Terre (1866–67): systematic physical geography.
    • Nouvelle Géographie Universelle (1875–94): 19 volumes of regional geography.
    • Mainly interested in the human aspect. Schmidt called him the "Ritter of France".
  • Moltke: geography in military science.

Post-1859 turmoil

  • 1859: Humboldt and Ritter both died, and Darwin's Origin of Species was published.
  • The followers split geography in several directions, and its unity was questioned. No professor of geography in any German university after Ritter's death.
  • Geography's revival came from scholars trained as geologists, who specialised in physical geography. The central problem was to overcome disunity and unite the physical and cultural.
  • Bucher attacked natural boundaries and natural regions. Ritter's teleology was rejected.

New directions

Trend
Proponents and ideas
Environmental determinism
Ratzel, Anthropogeographie: history, culture and life are largely shaped by environment. "Similar locations lead to similar modes of life." Lebensraum (living space) transformed German political thinking
"Geologification" of geography (after Darwin)
Landforms became the main field. W.M. Davis: "geographical cycle" (cycle of erosion), an analogy with organic life: landforms evolve like organisms
Extreme determinism
Ellen Semple, Influences of Geographic Environment (1911): "Man is a product of the earth's surface."
Possibilism (reaction)
Man is an active agent. Environment offers options, which multiply as knowledge and technology grow. Nature is never more than an adviser. Febvre: "There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities." Vidal de la Blache: genre de vie (ways of life)
Landform morphology (Germany)
Peschel: morphology of landforms and their influence on history. Richthofen: China (1877), landforms. Penck (geologist): landforms are the major concern
Physical vs human dichotomy
Gerland (the book prints "Wegener"): geography is a pure natural science. The French possibilists: human geography as the thrust area