Neo-Determinism: Griffith Taylor (1880–1963) ⭐⭐
Thomas Griffith Taylor: British-born geographer, anthropologist and explorer (Antarctic expedition with Scott). Worked in Australia, Chicago and Toronto.
- Argument: possibilists developed their ideas in temperate NW Europe, which offers many viable choices. But such environments are rare. In most of the world, as in Australia, the environment is extreme and its control is enormous.
- In the 1920s he argued that the limits of agricultural settlement in Australia were set by physical factors such as rainfall distribution. Very unpopular at first in Australia (it went against development optimism), but later accepted.
- Coined "stop-and-go determinism".
- Short term: people may attempt whatever they wish.
- Long term: nature's plan ensures the environment wins and forces a compromise.
- Australia (1948):
"The best economic programme for a country has in large part been determined by nature, and it is the geographer's duty to interpret this programme. Man is able to accelerate, slow or stop the progress of a country's development. But he should not, if he is wise, depart from the directions as indicated by the natural environment. He is like the traffic controller in a large city who alters the rate but not the direction of progress."
- Man follows nature's programme "only if he is wise". So within broad limits man can choose between the wise and the foolish.
- Criticism: wisdom and folly are human concepts; nature knows only the possible and impossible. Once alternative action is admitted, "stop-and-go" cannot claim that man is not free. Man chooses, but only from the range nature presents, which agrees with Febvre. It is a middle path between determinism and possibilism.
Probabilism: O.H.K. Spate (1911–2000) ⭐
Oskar Hermann Khristian Spate: English geographer (German father), known for building geography in Australia (ANU) and the Pacific. Wrote India and Pakistan.
- Coined "probabilism" (1957). Although the physical environment does not uniquely determine human actions, it makes some responses more probable than others.
- A middle position:
- Determinists: activities are controlled by the environment (cause and effect).
- Possibilists: the environment offers a range of options, and people choose.
- Probabilists: some choices are more likely.
- Examples (Sutlej–Ganga plain):
- Population density decreases away from market centres and metropolitan centres.
- Crop yields diminish beyond a walking distance from the village.
- There are exceptions and limits, and these demand explanation.
- Probability theory became an essential component of geographical analysis, giving a "common mode of discourse" for the scientific study of landscape. It is compatible with Vidal's conception.
- Criticism:
- Complete knowledge of environment and resources is not available.
- Data are unreliable.
- Perception of resources differs by person, community, region and country.
- So probability models may not reflect ground reality.
Cultural or Social Determinism
- Emphasises the human element. "Our thoughts determine our acts, and our acts determine the previous nature of the world" (James, 1932).
- Interests, desires, prejudices and group values vary across space, producing variation in cultural landscapes and levels of development.
- Principle (American scholars): "The significance to man of the physical and biotic features of his habitat is a function of the attitudes, objectives and technical abilities of man himself."
- A country rich for hunters may appear poor to farmers.
- Resources are not the same for those with and without technology.
- As technology advances, the importance of the environment decreases and relations become more complex.
- Edward Ullman: "The environment is essentially neutral": its role depends on the stage of technology, type of culture and other traits of a changing society.
- A mountain pass means different things to people with horses, cars or aeroplanes.
- Soil fertility is judged differently by a Japanese farmer and an Amazonian Indian.
- George Carter: three fundamental factors in human geography, with the greatest stress on culture. "Ideas remain the primary cause of change … it is these ideas that determine the human use of the physical world." Human will is decisive.
- After WWII, social determinism became popular in Austria, Holland and Sweden, as social geography: the spatial distribution of societies.
- Criticism:
- Social groups are distinguished by ethnic, religious and professional traits, but changes are rarely linked to economic causes or class structure.
- Studies reduce to external features of the cultural landscape (houses, land use, field patterns) down to a single street: painstaking "micro-territorial", purely empirical research with no significant scientific conclusions.
- It underestimates the natural environment. As rigid as environmental determinism, so not acceptable in crude form.