Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

German School of Geography

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

9 min read8 sections

German School of Geography

Background

  • Germans gave geography a philosophical and scientific base in the 18th–19th centuries.
  • Universities: the first German university of this kind was set up in 1809 (Berlin). In the mid-19th century, science courses were standardised and optional subjects allowed. Few universities taught geography until the late 19th century.
  • Early teachers were mostly Ritter's pupils trained in other disciplines: history, mathematics, biology, geology, engineering.
  • Mid-19th-century political turmoil created demand for maps by the military and administrators, so "anything that could be plotted on maps was considered geography."
  • German unification (1871) after the Franco-Prussian War led to heavy demand for teaching geography. Geography was introduced in ten universities.

Oscar Peschel (1826–1875)

  • Professor at Leipzig (1871–75). Historian of geography. Editor of Das Ausland (a periodical on foreign countries).
  • Developed comparative geography: compared different parts of the world using maps.
  • Fiords of Norway: hypothesis that fiords were fissures in the crust occupied and gouged out by glaciers.
  • Laid the foundation of modern physical geography, focused on landforms, but ignored man.
  • 📚 New Problems of Comparative Geography as a Search for the Morphology of the Earth's Surface (1870). His physical geography was published posthumously (he died at 49).

Ferdinand von Richthofen (1833–1905)

👤
Trained as a geologist. Fieldwork in China and California. Taught at Bonn, Leipzig and Berlin (1877–1905).
  • Founder of modern geomorphology. Pleaded the cause of geography in the universities.
  • China: prepared a map of China's coalfields. Explained the loess of North China (wind-blown origin). Coined the term "Silk Road" (commonly cited).
  • Purpose of geography: to focus on the diverse phenomena that occur in interrelation on the face of the earth.
  • Method: first study the physical setting (relief, climate, soil, vegetation, fauna), then man's adjustment to it. Main objective: the relationship of man to the physical and biotic earth. This remained the basic pattern of geography for a long time.
  • First German to distinguish "general" and "regional" geography:
    • Regional geography: descriptive, highlighting a region's salient features, but also seeking regularities to frame hypotheses.
    • General geography: spatial distribution and explanation of individual phenomena worldwide.
  • Stressed fieldwork.
  • Hierarchy of areas (increasing size):
German term
Meaning
Örtlichkeiten
Localities
Landschaften
Landscapes / small regions
Länder
Major regions
Erdteile
Major divisions of the world (continents)
  • Erdkunde = study of the earth's surface where the lithosphere, atmosphere, hydrosphere and biosphere are in contact (the interface).

Friedrich Ratzel (1844–1904) ⭐

👤
Trained in zoology, geology and comparative anatomy (Munich). Patriot: joined the Prussian army in 1870 and was wounded twice. Studied Germans living abroad (Hungary, Transylvania), visited Italy (1872), and the USA and Mexico (1874–75) (Red Indians, Negroes, Chinese). Professor at Leipzig (1876), also taught at Munich.

Titles

  • Founder of human geography (universally recognised)
  • Coined "anthropogeography"
  • Father of political geography (organic state theory)
  • Pioneer of Social Darwinism in geography

📚 Works

Year
Book
1878, 1880
Two books on North America (physical and cultural)
1882–1891 (the book says 1872–1899)
Anthropogeographie, 2 volumes
1897
Politische Geographie (Political Geography)
(commonly cited)
Völkerkunde (History of Mankind); Der Lebensraum (1901)

Anthropogeographie

  • Focus: effects of physical features and location on people's ways of life.
  • Vol. I: man–earth relationship, organised by physical features and their influence on human culture (deductive, environment → man).
  • Vol. II: man's influence on environment: human activities and cultures in relation to the environment. Example: the Vosges (France) vs the Black Forest/Schwarzwald (Germany), physically alike on either side of the Middle Rhine but used differently because of French vs German culture.
  • Took Ritter's human geography further and divided it into anthropogeography and political geography.
  • Ratzel finally insisted that man joins in nature's game, and the environment (milieu externe) is a partner, not a slave, of human activity. (So he was not a crude determinist.)
  • Provided guidelines for a systematic study of human geography. "Society ought not to be left suspended in the air."

Organic theory of the state / Lebensraum ⭐

  • Applied Darwin's concepts to human societies (Social Darwinism). Groups must struggle to survive in particular environments like plants and animals. "Survival of the fittest" (a phrase coined by Herbert Spencer).
  • Political Geography (1897): a state is like an organism; it must grow or die, and can never stand still.
  • Laws of territorial growth: states must expand to thrive. Higher civilisations expand at the expense of lower ones. Extending frontiers at the expense of a weak state reflects internal strength: a natural organic necessity.
  • Campaigned in the 1890s for German colonies and a navy to challenge Britain. Context: the Berlin Conference (1884–85) partition of Africa, and the Schlieffen plan.
  • After WWI, German geopoliticians revived his ideas to justify Nazi expansion, and his writings were condemned by Anglo-American geographers.

Stages of economic development (per Ratzel)

  1. Hunting and fishing
  1. Hoe-culture
  1. Crop cultivation with the plough
  1. Mixed farming (farming + herding)
  1. Unmixed herding
  1. Horticulture
  • Not every society must pass through all stages.

Other

  • Built a "fundamental unity in diversity" by synthesising diverse physical and cultural phenomena.
  • Physical vs human debate: Georg Gerland held that geography should study the earth without man, because exact laws are possible only if unpredictable man is excluded. Ratzel opposed him: man is an essential ingredient.
  • His determinism spread to France, England and the USA. Ellen Semple was his chief disciple.
  • Semple on Ratzel: "He took a mountain view of things, kept his eyes always on the horizons … sometimes overlooked the details near at hand. Herein lay his greatness and his limitations."

Alfred Hettner (1859–1941) ⭐

👤
Pupil of Richthofen and Ratzel. Taught at Leipzig, Tübingen and Heidelberg (1899–1928). Essentially a physical and regional geographer. Founded the journal Geographische Zeitschrift (1895). 📚 Europe (1907). His methodology book: Die Geographie: ihre Geschichte, ihr Wesen und ihre Methoden (1927).
  • Supported Strabo: geography is a chorological science, the study of regions/areas. He turned Kant's "chorographic" (descriptive) into "chorologic" (explanatory).
  • Geography studies both material and immaterial (race, religion, language, customs) phenomena, on the same plane in areal differentiation.
  • Geography is to space what history is to time (Kantian).
  • Distinctive subject of geography: knowledge of earth areas as they differ from each other = areal differentiation.
  • Geography is idiographic (regional) rather than nomothetic (systematic).
  • Geography must deal with both the unique (regional) and the universal (general), but the study of regions is the main field. This theory of uniqueness remains controversial.
  • "The unity of geography is in its method."
  • Man is an integral part of the nature of an area. "Mere description has been replaced in all branches of geography by the search for causes."
  • Study relationships from man to nature, rather than nature to man.
  • Rejected the idea that geography is either general or regional.
  • Regional interrelations change through time (e.g. nomads settling down).

Landschaftskunde (landscape science)

  • Popular in Germany in the early 20th century.
  • The existing landscape of a meso or micro region results from exogenetic, historical and cultural forces. Studies man and invisible features (wind, air, temperature, humidity).
  • Landschaft = a homogeneous area of uniform appearance, the subject matter of geography, in which biotic and abiotic things are studied in relation to each other.
  • The idea that general geography is analytical and regional geography synthetic is erroneous: chorology (the areal association of things of diverse origin) applies to both.

Albrecht Penck (1858–1945)

👤
Trained in geology. Professor of Physical Geography at Vienna (1885–1906), then Berlin (1906–1926). Associated with Eduard Suess (maps of the world's geological regions).
  • Formulated the concept of "geomorphology" and the principles of landform evolution. Showed how systematic features can be studied chorologically.
  • 1910: climates can be classified from landforms even without meteorological data.
  • First to point out that evaporation increases with temperature. Effective rainfall (rainfall minus runoff plus evaporation) depends on temperature.
  • Man is an important agent that carves the earth's face.
  • Topographical maps: proposed accurate large-scale maps (1 inch to 1 mile) of relief, water bodies, vegetation and human works. Proposed the International Map of the World (1:1,000,000) (commonly cited).
  • Introduced the term "Gestalt" (from psychology) for the unified form of larger areas (wholes).
  • "Geography is a bridge between the natural and social sciences."
  • Known for the Alpine glaciation sequence (Günz, Mindel, Riss, Würm), with Brückner (commonly cited).

Followers

  • Walther Penck (1888–1923), his son: challenged Davis's cycle of erosion (slope development, Die morphologische Analyse, 1924).
  • Wladimir Köppen (Russian-born German climatologist): climate classification (1884–1918) based on temperature, vegetation, rainfall effectiveness relative to temperature, and seasonal and annual variation.
    • Found moisture deficiency all year on the western margins at 20°–30° in both hemispheres.
    • Continental interiors are colder in winter and warmer in summer than coastal areas at the same latitude.
  • Gerhard Schott: oceanography: motion, temperature, salinity, colour, deposits, ocean climates, basin structures, organisms, sea and air routes. A world map of ocean regions.

Inter-war and post-war Germany

  • 1900–1915: rapid growth and productivity.
  • After WWI: a lean period. Dissenters kept silent and many Jews were confined. Yet notable work in urban and agricultural geography:
    • Walter Christaller: Central Place Theory (1933), the functional organisation of space.
    • von Thünen: crop intensity (agricultural location) theory (The Isolated State, 1826). (The book lists it here.)
  • Stress on landscape planning, and on geopolitics.
  • Karl Haushofer (1924): inspired by Kjellén and Ratzel, held that the state is a living organism that needs space. Probably influenced Nazi policies. Tried at Nuremberg; suicide in 1946.
  • Post-WWII (1945–1960): quick revival. New journal Erdkunde (1947). Statistical tools for landscape study. Variation as a function of latitude, altitude, distance from the sea and direction from the nearest coast.
    • Cultural determinism replaced environmental determinism. The new emphasis on culture was called "social geography". Landscape interpreted through people's attitudes and technical skill, with an integrated physical–social approach.
  • Cartography: von Sydow maps and atlases. Perthes firm: Stieler's Atlas (under A. Petermann). Petermann, with W. & A.K. Johnston in Edinburgh, produced the Physical Atlas (1845–47).
🎯
German school memory chain: Peschel (comparative, fiords) → Richthofen (geomorphology, loess, general vs regional, Örtlichkeiten–Landschaften–Länder–Erdteile) → Ratzel (anthropogeography, Lebensraum, organic state) → Hettner (chorology, idiographic, areal differentiation, unity in method) → Penck (geomorphology, Gestalt, topographical maps) → Köppen (climate) → Christaller (CPT) → Haushofer (Geopolitik).