Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) — Geography as Chorology

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

3 min read3 sections

Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) — Geography as Chorology

👤
Born 22 April 1724, Königsberg, East Prussia (now Kaliningrad, Russia), son of a saddler. Never travelled more than about 16 km (10 miles) from Königsberg. PhD thesis De Igne ("On Fire", 1755). Lecturer at 31, professor in 1770 (age 46), rector in 1786. Lectured on physical geography for about 40 years (and anthropology). Last lecture 1796. Died 12 February 1804.

Why Kant matters

  • Ended the Christian-theological treatment of geographical and cosmological facts. Closed the era of Aristotle in Germany (dominant since Melanchthon). Freed geography from theology.
  • The history of geography is divided into "before Kant" and "after Kant".
  • His geographical writings survive only in fragments, so his importance was recognised late.

📚 Works with geographical relevance

Year
Work
1755
General Natural History and Theory of the Heavens: the Nebular Hypothesis
1757
Ankündigung (announcement of his physical geography lectures): five ways of studying the earth
1756
Treatises on earthquakes (Lisbon earthquake), mostly about the earth's interior
1781
Critique of Pure Reason
1790
Critique of Judgement
1798
Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View: races and ethnic groups
1802
Physische Geographie (lectures, edited by Rink)
Posthumous
Opus Postumum (unfinished)

Key contributions ⭐

1. Classification of knowledge (most important)

  • Empirical phenomena can be grouped in two ways:
Logical classification
Physical classification
By nature (kind) of phenomena
By position in time and space
Basis of the systematic sciences: zoology (animals), botany (plants), geology (rocks), sociology
Basis of history and geography
  • History = phenomena that follow one another in time (nacheinander) = chronological science, narrative.
  • Geography = phenomena beside each other in space (nebeneinander) = chorological science, descriptive.
  • "Geography and history fill up the entire circumference of our perceptions: geography that of space, history that of time."
  • Both are essential sciences alongside the systematic sciences.
  • Geography is the substructure of history: if there is ancient history, there must be an ancient geography. Physical geography is the basis of history and of all possible geographies.

2. Space

  • Space is a relative view, a system of relations among substances.
  • 1770: space is not a thing or event but a framework, like a system of pigeon-holes or a filing system for observations. Space and time are frames of reference used intuitively in experience.

3. Knowledge

  • Knowledge comes through pure reason or the senses.
  • Inner senses perceive the soul (Seele) / man (Mensch), the subject of anthropology. Outer senses perceive nature, the subject of physical geography, the first part of knowledge of the world.
  • Personal experience is limited, so we borrow others' experience, either narrative (history) or descriptive (geography).

4. Five ways of studying the earth (Ankündigung, 1757) ⭐

Branch
Content
1. Mathematical geography
Earth as a nearly spherical celestial body: size, shape, imaginary circles
2. Moral geography
Customs, traditions, character of man. E.g. patricide is the most fearful crime in the Orient, while in Lapland a wounded father expects his son to kill him. Mountain people are bold and freedom-loving
3. Political geography
Nature–man relations in two ways: (a) incidental causes (changes of government, annexation, intrigue), which are ephemeral; (b) permanent features: position, situation, products, trade, customs, population
4. Commercial geography
Why some countries have a surplus and others a deficiency of commodities, which gives rise to international trade
5. Theological geography
How religious principles change in different environments, e.g. Christianity in the Far East vs Europe

5. Physical geography (Kant's sense)

  • The natural composition of the globe: oceans, land, mountains, rivers, atmosphere, man, animals, plants, minerals.
  • Anthropocentric: man is one of the five principal agents changing the earth. Ritter inherited this view.
  • Maps are unimportant, useful only for teaching and demonstration.
  • Saw man and his works intimately linked with physical surroundings, but distinguished human from natural processes.

6. Nebular hypothesis

  • The solar system formed from a large gas cloud (nebula).
  • The Milky Way is a large disc of stars, formed from a spinning gas cloud. Other nebulae may be distant galaxies. This extended astronomy beyond the solar system.

7. Status of geography

  • For Kant geography was descriptive (taxonomic), a propaedeutic (introductory) discipline, not a full science.
  • He used "chorographic" (descriptive). Hettner (1927) changed it to "chorologic" (explanatory).
  • First early statement of geography as chorology.
  • Geography has great educational value: useful for conversation, newspaper readers and politicians.
  • Hartshorne (The Nature of Geography, 1939) accepted Kant's view: "Geography and history are alike in that they are integrating sciences … geography in terms of earth spaces, history in terms of periods of time."
  • Kant had "no direct influence" on Humboldt and Hettner other than "as a form of confirmation" (Hartshorne 1958; Büttner 1980).
🎯
Exam pointers: Geography = chorological, history = chronological. Nebeneinander / nacheinander. Five branches: mathematical, moral, political, commercial, theological. Nebular hypothesis (1755). Geography as propaedeutic. Hettner: chorographic → chorologic. Hartshorne revived Kant.