Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

General (Systematic) vs Regional Geography

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read4 sections

General (Systematic) vs Regional Geography

Origin

  • Raised by Varenius (17th century) in Geographia Generalis (1650): general (universal) vs special (particular) geography. This is the classical period of modern geographical thought.
  • General geography: formulation of general laws, principles and generic concepts ("the noblest end of scientific enquiry"). The whole world as a unit, mainly physical, understood through natural laws.
  • Special geography: description of individual countries and regions. Laws are hard to establish where unpredictable humans are involved, but it helps build hypotheses.
  • Over time, all generalising studies became systematic geography (inspired by the systematic sciences), and particular studies became regional geography.
  • Regional geography: brings together in an areal setting what topical geography treats separately. Interest in "a specific situation in a particular locality". Called "the highest form of the geographer's art" (Hartshorne).

Historical development

Thinker
Position
Humboldt
Cosmography = uranography + geography. Inductive, empirical. In Kosmos: the aim of all physical sciences is "to recognise unity in diversity … to grasp nature's essence under the cover of outward appearances". Moved from particular studies to the general. Compared steppes (Russia) and arid lands (Central Asia). Founder of systematic geography
Ritter
Teleologist. Study nature "as a whole, as in parts" to see the inherent plan. Convinced laws exist but "in no hurry to establish them". Empirical. Uniqueness of areas. Synthetic study, centrality of regional geography. Aim: "to get away from mere description to the law of the thing described … the connection of place with place." Influenced by Hegel. "My system builds on facts, not on philosophical arguments." Founder of regional geography
Humboldt + Ritter
The scientific organisation of knowledge has two stages: (1) an accurate inventory of facts on one aspect, (2) integration into a coherent body governed by laws expressing genetic relationships. Humboldt: "On being first examined, all phenomena appear isolated; only by multiplicity of observations combined with reason can we trace their mutual relations"
Richthofen
Purpose: diverse phenomena in interrelation on the earth's surface. Method: physical setting → man's adjustment. Regional: descriptive, but seeks regularities and hypotheses. General: spatial distribution of individual phenomena worldwide
Ratzel
Largely deductive: a priori hypotheses applied to cases. Obsessed with genesis rather than interdependence. Social Darwinism. A departure from Humboldt's integrative morphological approach
Hettner
Geography is idiographic (regional) rather than nomothetic (general). Distinctive subject = areas as they differ. Man is an integral part of an area. Approach deductive, giving weight to the physical
Vidal de la Blache
Revived the inductive method. Pays studies leading to general conclusions. Regional geography is the core; argued against systematic geography as the core. His inductive and historical method suits isolated, agricultural, self-sufficient regions. Advised research in folk museums and old agricultural tools. Inspired the regional monograph tradition
Reclus
Man is not the product of his environment but an important part of it
Late 19th to mid-20th century
Overwhelming specific knowledge with little "integrative overview". Geography failed to rise above description of the individual
Hartshorne (The Nature of Geography, 1939)
Areal differentiation (regional geography) is the essence of geography. Post-WWII geography was idiographic: description, fieldwork, integration of physical and human in particular landscapes
F.K. Schaefer (1953, "Exceptionalism in Geography")
Called for the scientific method and universal laws. Criticised the "old method" as "Hartshornian orthodoxy"
Quantitative revolution (post-WWII)
Location theory: a new order in the distribution of phenomena and their interlinkages

Systematic vs regional: comparison ⭐

Systematic (general / topical)
Regional (special)
Universal laws, generic concepts
Unique situations and peculiarities
Analytical
Synthetic
Whole world (or a continent) for one phenomenon: temperature, rainfall, crops, population
One region with all variables superimposed: landforms, climate, soils, vegetation, cultural landscape
Nomothetic
Idiographic
E.g. world soil types, or population geography across continents
E.g. the regional geography of Africa
Grid diagram (Figure 9.1): rows are systematic branches (landforms, climate, economic, settlement, population, cultural, political); columns are regions/continents (North America … Antarctica). Reading across a row = systematic geography. Reading down a column = regional geography. Many new branches grow at the intersections.

Resolution of the dichotomy

  • Geography is multidimensional and multivariate (natural sciences + social sciences + mathematics), with many definitions: landscape, place, space, location, man–nature, man–earth system, human ecology, areal differentiation.
  • Three branches? General geography, compage regional geography, and full descriptive regional geography.
    • Compage (term by Derwent Whittlesey, 1890–1956): includes only phenomena showing logical spatial arrangement and connection with other important phenomena. All features of the physical, biotic and societal environments are functionally associated with human occupancy.
    • Full regional description is still needed to educate laypeople.
  • Brian Berry: "Regional and general geography are not different approaches but the two extremes of a continuum", like a three-dimensional matrix (earth, social, geometrical). Studies range from elementary integration (topical) to complete integration (regional).
  • Philosophy of particular and universal: every object has individual (particular) traits and general (universal) traits. "The general exists in, and is seen through, the particular." They are mutually interpenetrative: the individual cannot exist without the universal and vice versa.
  • V.A. Anuchin: science moves in cycles: periods when the general absorbs the particular are followed by periods when the particular destroys the general and science disintegrates into branches. Differentiation extends knowledge but loses "integrative overviews". Contemporary geography is a victim of such a phase.
  • Conclusion: systematic and regional geography support each other, so the dichotomy falls.