A. Physical geography vs human geography
Origin
- Greeks: Hecataeus stressed the physical. Herodotus and Strabo stressed the human.
- Arguments for separation: methods differ.
- Natural phenomena (climatology, meteorology, hydrology, oceanography, geology, landforms) allow natural-science methods and precise conclusions.
- Social and cultural phenomena allow generalisations limited in time and space, as probability rather than certainty.
- Varenius (1650) was one of the first to note this difference.
Rise of physical geography
Who | Contribution |
Kant | Lectured on physical geography at Königsberg. Studied wind deflection due to the earth's rotation |
Humboldt | Primarily physical |
Ritter | First geography professor at Berlin, inclined to human geography. Both saw the aim as clarifying the unity of nature |
Reclus | Systematic physical geography (La Terre) |
Darwin | Gave importance to the physical aspect (struggle and survival) |
Mary Somerville | Physical Geography (1848) (commonly cited) |
Penck | Coined/established "geomorphology", principles of landform evolution, relief maps |
Köppen, Davis, de Martonne, Mill, Jefferson, Dokuchaev | Stressed landforms and climate. Man was ignored. Davis: the normal cycle of erosion |
Ratzel, Semple, Huntington | The physical environment determines life |
Mackinder, Chisholm, Herbertson | Physical geography as the main field |
T.H. Huxley | Physiography (1877): "description of nature". Physical geography was renamed physiography after 1877 and became a popular school subject in the last 30 years of the 19th century |
Soviets | Geography = geomorphology + pedology + hydrology + meteorology |
- Physical emphasis existed because early teachers had a geology background.
- Wooldridge and East: it is futile to assert that "human" or "social" geography can be seen in terms of uniform categories and universal principles as physical geography can. This implies no inferiority: human geography is infinitely more complex, subtle, flexible and manifold.
- Wrigley: physical and social geography need radically different frameworks of explanation. Law statements matter in physical geography but are irrelevant in human geography (the geographical form of the Weber–Winch thesis on laws in the social sciences). This is not generally accepted: laws can be established in both. Others say laws are impossible in either, because of multivariate complexity, few cases and exceptional circumstances.
Rise of human geography
- Ritter and Ratzel: man as an agent of landscape change.
- Febvre: man is an element of the landscape that "humanises" it. The same physical factors do not always produce the same effects. "Man, not the soil or the climate, is ever in the forefront."
- Vidal de la Blache: founded the school of human geography. Natural and cultural phenomena are united and inseparable.
- Brunhes: principles of activity and interconnection. Demangeon: the Vidalian tradition.
- Jefferson (USA): central places, primate city, civilising rails. D.N. Anuchin (USSR): economic determinism.
- Basic philosophy: a mutual man–nature relationship, each dependent on the other.
Resolution
- Methods differ, but sometimes doubtfully: "the difference between the study of natural vegetation and of cultivation, or of landforms, is in many respects small".
- The dichotomy results from the historical development of the discipline. Physical and human are two extremes of a continuum.
- Hartshorne: dividing geography into physical and human makes the rest of the work illogical. We study the effect of physical factors on man's activities, not physiology. The division makes geography only a partial study. "For geography to have any value, the rift between physical and human phenomena must disappear."
B. Historical geography vs contemporary geography
- Historical geography: the geography of an area as it was in the past (e.g. cropping patterns and settlements of medieval India).
- S.M. Ali, The Geography of the Puranas (ancient India)
- Ralph Brown: what the USA was like when each region was settled
- W.G. East: the human geography of Europe at several stages
- Historical geography stands side by side with contemporary geography. Covering both general and regional work, it is a separate entity complete in itself, not a branch like social geography.
- Contemporary geography: existing patterns of spatial differentiation.
Four approaches to historical geography ⭐ (the classic H.C. Darby scheme)
Approach | Meaning |
1. The geographical factor in history | 19th century: the influence of geography on history, or the geography of a past period. Whittlesey and East: reconstruct a past geography as the context for historical events. Others: environmental control of the past, which leads to determinism and possibilism. Criticised for clarifying history, not geography: "adding the missing environmental notation to historians' work" |
2. The changing cultural landscape | Reconstruct past cultural landscapes (common in Europe). Its symmetry with genetic geomorphology: both study the evolution of landscape features. Landscape elements (settlements, house types, field patterns) are best treated as evidence for reconstructing past geographies |
3. Reconstruction of past geographies | The most orthodox view. Past agricultural, urban, industrial, social and regional geographies. Vital for understanding the present, but difficult |
4. Geographical changes through time | Factors (physical and cultural) change in space and time, so the character of regions changes. Studying these changes is a main concern |
- Historical and contemporary geography are one and the same: today's geography becomes tomorrow's historical geography.
- Mackinder: historical geography is the study of the "historical present". The geographer must put himself back into the present that existed one or two thousand years ago and restore it.
C. Functional (nodal) regions vs formal (uniform) regions
- Geography of real places vs geometric space. The idea emerged to avoid the systematic vs regional and physical vs human controversies.
Functional (nodal) location / region | Formal (uniform) site / region |
A new concept | Traditional, now looks outdated |
Diverse phenomena (relief, climate, land use, industry, transport, markets) are united by functioning together as an economic and social system, not by being stacked in one place | Homogeneous areas inhabited by societies or groups |
Flows of crops, food, raw materials, people and messages by air, water, pipe, wire, road and rail | Uniform relief + climate + soil → uniform land use, settlements and way of life |
Phenomena spread horizontally, side by side, in a logical layout to use space best. A location affects places hundreds of miles away | Studies phenomena within a place and their interdependence |
Causal relations within a place and between places | Cannot explain the complex man–environment relationship |
Studies the structure and function of communities in space | — |
Absolute distance is irrelevant. Accessibility in cost-distance, time-distance or network mileage from nodes or axes | Absolute space |
Settlement patterns, land use and diffusion depend on relative position | — |
- Forer: distances in time, cost and network are artefacts of socio-economic demand and technology, so space is dynamic and truly relative: "plastic space", continuously changing size and form.
- With quantitative techniques and computers, geographers moved from formal to functional study. But the two are complementary, so this dichotomy is also illogical.