Definition
- Developed as a reaction to the extreme generalisations of determinism. It presents man as an active rather than a passive agent.
- The natural environment provides options, whose number increases as the knowledge and technology of a cultural group develop.
- People perceive the range of alternative uses of an environment and select what best fits their cultural dispositions.
- For possibilists, the works of man, not the earth and its influence, are the starting point. What matters is man's freedom to choose.
- Led by the French, especially the followers of the historian Lucien Febvre, who named it "possibilism". Popular after World War I.
Key quotes ⭐⭐
Febvre: "The true and only geographical problem is that of the utilisation of possibilities. There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities. The natural data are much more the material than the determinant of human development. The 'essential cause' is less nature … than man himself."
Febvre: "Man is a geographic agent, and not the least." He invests the earth's physiognomy with changing expressions.
Vidal de la Blache: "Nature sets limits and offers possibilities for human settlement, but the way man reacts or adjusts depends on his own traditional way of life." "Nature is never more than an adviser."
Brunhes: "Nature is not mandatory but permissive."
Possibilists also recognise limits
- Febvre: "Men can never entirely rid themselves … of the hold their environment has on them."
- Brunhes: man's power is limited, and he meets bounds he cannot cross. Human activity can modify its environment but never surpass it; it will always be conditioned by it.
- Vidal: "There is no question of geographical determinism; nevertheless geography is a key that cannot be dispensed with."
- Bowman: all men everywhere are affected to some degree by physical conditions.
- In marginal environments (hot and cold deserts, tundra) and at low stages of culture, choice is very restricted. In favourable temperate zones with advanced techniques, possibilities are many. Man can never free himself entirely from nature's control.
- The range of possibilities is limited more by the price man is willing to pay than by the environment. Example: banana, rice and rubber could be grown in Antarctica, but the cost is prohibitive.
Proponents and spread
Thinker | Contribution |
Vidal de la Blache (1845–1918) | Founded the school of possibilism. Genre de vie: the product of a civilisation, an integrated result of physical, historical and social influences. Society and nature are not "two adversaries in a duel": man is "part of living creation" and "its most active collaborator". Differences between groups in similar environments come from attitudes, values and habits |
Lucien Febvre (1878–1956) | Historian. Set out to demolish determinism by asserting man's initiative and mobility against the passivity of the environment. Other humans are part of the environment (milieu). Coined "possibilism". Book: A Geographical Introduction to History (1922/1925) |
Jean Brunhes | First explicit formulation of human geography as a systematic approach. Strong supporter |
H.J. Fleure (1877–1969) | World regions based on human characteristics rather than climatic–biotic ones: "regions of effort", "regions of hunger", "industrialised regions" (also regions of increment, difficulty, debilitation) |
Carl Sauer | Cultural geography (Berkeley). Studied the transition from natural to cultural landscape through successive groups. Crops can do better where acclimatised than where domesticated: wheat yields are not highest in SW Asia, and rice is now big in the USA, Australia and Pakistan |
H.H. Barrows (1877–1960, Chicago) | Human ecology: greater importance to man than environment |
Arguments of possibilists
- Climatic–botanical zones are unequally rich in possibilities, but impossibility is never absolute, and probabilities are upset by man's persistent and supple will.
- Possibilities are awakened one after another, lie dormant, and reawaken according to the occupier's nature and initiative. They do not form a connected system and are not grasped all at once.
- Human activity "governs the game". Similarities between groups exist but are not fixed: do not confuse necessity with possibility.
- It is impossible to explain differences in human societies and their histories by the environment, because man himself changes the environment.
Criticism ⭐
- Griffith Taylor: society as a whole must choose. Since possibilism gives the geographer only an advisory role, "his function is not that of interpreting nature's plan".
- The task of geography is to study the physical environment and its effects on man, not every problem of the cultural landscape. Possibilism promotes over-anthropocentrism.
- Determinism at least obliges geographers to turn to nature. If anyone is destroying geography, blame the possibilists.
- Possibilism exaggerates culture and neglects the natural environment. It can be as ludicrous as determinism, though possibilists did recognise environmental limits and avoided sweeping generalisations.