What and why
- After Ptolemy's Guide to Geography, the period from 200 to 700 AD (about 500 years) was an age of compilation, turmoil and abridgement. Not a single original work appeared in science or the humanities. The decline was fastest from 300 to 500 AD.
- Geography still flourished in China, India and South-East Asia at this time.
Causes of decline
- Barbarian invasions: Dacia, Gaul and Spain fell to barbarians, and North Africa to the Vandals. Travel even within the empire became unsafe.
- The Middle and Far East passed to Persians, Arabs and Abyssinians. The northern overland route (via the Darial Pass and the Caspian to Central Asia) was insecure.
- The Church: discouraged scientific inquiry. Cosmography was "less valuable" because Moses said nothing of the earth's shape. A literal reading of Genesis could not be reconciled with the Ptolemaic spherical earth.
- Father Cassiodorus (early 6th century) and Father Isidore (early 7th century) described the earth as flat.
- Scholars made sterile copies of the ancients and rejected anything contrary to Church dogma.
- The earth became a flat disc with Jerusalem at the centre.
Writers of the period
Writer | Work / view |
Solinus (about 250 AD, 3rd century) | Collectanea Rerum Memorabilium ("Collection of Wonderful Matters"), a collection of marvels, not real geography. Called a plagiarist of Pliny and Pomponius |
Pomponius Mela (the book gives 335–391 AD) | The last important geographer and historian of the time, with military experience. The last of the ancients to value geography for history and defence. Work regarded as an abridgement of Ptolemy |
Lactantius Firmianus (260–340 AD) | Leading Christian protagonist. Denied a spherical earth: a spherical sky does not require a spherical earth. Called antipodes absurd |
Cosmas of Alexandria ("Cosmas Indicopleustes") | Christian Topography (about 550 AD). Refuted all pre-Christian views. Earth modelled on "Moses' Tabernacle": flat, bounded by high walls supporting a semi-spherical sky. A merchant who visited Ethiopia, the Indian Ocean, Socotra, the Persian Gulf and Ceylon. Full of absurdities, so it had no influence |
St Jerome (4th century) | Map that exaggerated the Holy Land |
Beatus (Spanish monk, 8th century) | A version of the old Roman map. Later copies distorted it into a rectangle or circle |
- Missionary travels were the only source of regional information.
T-in-O map (Orbis Terrarum / "wheel map")
- The inhabited world is a circle (O) surrounded by ocean, oriented to the east (Asia at the top).
- Water bodies form a "T" inside:
- Stem of the T = Mediterranean
- Crossbar = Aegean and Black Sea on one side, Nile and Red Sea on the other
- Three divisions: Asia (upper half), Europe and Africa (lower half, roughly equal).
- Jerusalem at the centre. Paradise in the far east beyond the inhabited world.
- Filled with mythical places, beasts, dragons, and the kingdom of Gog and Magog.
- Sphericity, correct distances and latitude/longitude were all ignored.
German scholar Schmid on the Dark Age: no new countries were discovered, the empire grew smaller, trade shrank because of war, the spirit of discovery vanished, and the only books were compilations of older works.