Claudius Ptolemy, a Greco-Roman scholar of Alexandria (Egypt, a Roman province). Mathematician, astronomer, poet and geographer. Made observations in 139 AD. Died about 168 AD. A birthplace at Pelusium is uncertain.
Position in geographical thought
- Developed sound principles of mathematical geography. The highest point reached by ancient (Phoenician–Greek–Roman) geography.
- His writings inspired the explorers of the Great Age of Discovery to explore the Terra Incognita.
- Called a plagiarist of Marinus of Tyre by some. That is unfair: he used Marinus's and Hipparchus's material but presented it more scientifically.
- Geocentric universe (as Aristotle): a stationary spherical earth at the centre, with heavenly bodies in circular orbits. Accepted until Copernicus (De Revolutionibus, 1543; the book says 17th century).
📚 Works
Work | Content |
Almagest (Arabic name, from Greek He Megiste Syntaxis = "The Great Synthesis"; also Syntaxis, Mathematical Treatise) | Classical astronomy: geocentric theory of the Sun, Moon and planets, improving Hipparchus's solar theory. Star catalogue of 1,022 stars in 48 constellations with celestial latitude, longitude and magnitude. Discovered the irregularity of the Moon's orbit. Not superseded until a century after Copernicus |
Geography / Guide to Geography (Geographike Hyphegesis) | 8 volumes. Opens with map projection theory. A gazetteer of about 8,000 places with latitude and longitude (the system he devised), brief descriptions of continents, countries and tribes, one world map + 26 regional maps |
Tetrabiblos | Astrology |
Optics | Reflection and refraction (the only work that was not influential) |
Definition of geography (very important)
- "Geography is a science which deals with the art of map-making."
- Geography vs chorography:
- Geography = a view of the whole, like drawing the whole head.
- Chorography = describing the parts, like drawing only an ear or an eye. Ptolemy also called the topographical description of places and their history "chorography".
- Aim: "to reform the map of the world" on astronomical principles, following Eratosthenes and Hipparchus. A staunch follower of Hipparchus: maps must rest on the latitude and longitude of important points.
- Problem: few astronomical observations were available, so he relied on travellers' exaggerated distances.
Major contributions in mathematical geography
1. Circumference of the earth
- Adopted Hipparchus's 360° circle.
- Took 1° = 500 stadia (50 miles) instead of 600 stadia (60 geographical miles), i.e. Posidonius's smaller earth. The error multiplied. Combined with exaggerated travel distances, this distorted his map.
2. Dimensions of the habitable world
- Length: from the Fortunate Islands (Canaries) to Sera (China) = 180° (really about 130°).
- This error shortened the apparent westward distance from Europe to Asia, encouraging the idea that it could be crossed, and so indirectly led to Columbus's discovery of America.
- Breadth: from Thule (63° N, longest day 20 hours, per Marinus) to Prasum (about 16½° S).
- Rejected an ocean east of Asia. Sera and Sinae (China) are the easternmost points, Agisymba the southernmost. Beyond lies Terra Incognita.
3. Prime meridian, graticule and projection
- Prime meridian through the Fortunate Islands (Canaries). Ferro (the westernmost island) remained a prime meridian for centuries, still used by some German geographers. He placed them only 2½° west of the Sacred Promontory instead of the true 9°.
- Main parallel: Rhodes at 36° N (Eratosthenes's line from the Sacred Promontory through Gibraltar and Rhodes to the Gulf of Issus). Longitudes were measured along it.
- Errors: Sardinia placed too far south (really 39°12′ N), which distorted Sicily. Correct on Massilia (43°5′).
- Projection: first drew the equator and parallels as parallel curves, with meridians as straight lines converging at a pole beyond the map. Later he made the meridians curved too, closer to reality: a conic-type projection.
- Climata: like Hipparchus, but zone widths were based on the increase in the length of the longest day:
- Equator to 45° N (longest day 15½ hours): each zone = ¼ hour difference
- Beyond 45° N: each zone = ½ hour difference
4. Ptolemy's longitudes (east of Ferro)
Place | Ptolemy | Real |
Sacred Promontory | 2°30′ | 9°20′ |
Mouth of the Baetis | 5°20′ | 12°0′ |
Caralis (Sardinia) | 32°30′ | 27°30′ |
Lilybaeum (Sicily) | 37°0′ | — |
Issus | 69°20′ | — |
Regional knowledge on his map
Europe
- British Isles: two sections. Helped by Caesar's conquests and Agricola's voyage around Scotland. Hibernia/Ivernia (Ireland) close to reality. North and west coasts exaggerated.
- Gaul and Spain: well known thanks to Roman roads and administrative reports. Errors on Spain's west coast and the Brittany peninsula. Missed the Cotentin.
- Germany (beyond the Rhine): not conquered, so distorted. Scandia (Scandinavia) shown as a small island in the Sarmaticus Oceanus (Baltic) opposite the Vistula. Weser, Elbe and Vistula rise in the Sarmatian (Carpathian) mountains. Sarmatia Europaea between the Baltic and the Euxine.
- Sea of Azov exaggerated (stretched to 55° N).
- First to plot the Rha (Volga), flowing into the Caspian.
- Caspian shown as an inland sea (reviving Herodotus), but elongated west–east.
- Greece far superior to earlier maps. Errors on Italy, the Gulf of Genoa and the Adriatic.
Asia
- Central Asia on either side of the Imaus. Tribes: Abii, Alani, Hippophagi, Issedones.
- Serica / land of the Seres (China): Sera, the great silk trade centre reached by caravans. Rivers Oechardes and Bautisus.
- First to plot the Gangetic Gulf (Bay of Bengal). Ganges and tributaries rise in the Himalayas. West coast of India correctly north–south.
- Taprobane (Sri Lanka) shape fairly correct but size exaggerated (12° of latitude, extended 2° south of the equator).
- India extra Gangem: Chryse (golden peninsula = Malaya), Kattigara (near Hanoi), Magnus Sinus (Gulf of Siam/Thailand).
- Good on the Red Sea, Arabian Sea and Persian Gulf, and Oman's projection. Poor on interior Arabia.
Africa and the Indian Ocean
- Indian Ocean as an enclosed (landlocked) sea: an unknown land joins south-east Asia to East Africa. This Terra Australis Incognita idea was borrowed from Hipparchus.
- East Africa known to Cape Prasum (15°30′ S). Sailors went from Aromata (Somali coast) past Cape Guardafui to Rhapta (Tanganyika).
- Source of the Nile solved (most asked):
- Citing Nero's Roman expedition, which reached the Nile marshes (9° N).
- Blue Nile: from Lake Coloe (Lake Tana) in the Abyssinian highlands.
- White Nile: from the snowy "Mountains of the Moon" (Lunae Montes), identified with Kilimanjaro and Kenya.
- Gir and Niger rivers in north-west Africa ("Gir" = stream). Not the modern Niger.
- Mauretania coast (Daradus and Stachir rivers, Hesperi peninsula). Probably nothing beyond Sierra Leone. Named the land between Sudan and equatorial Africa "Ethiopia".
Features and legacy of his world map
- Exaggerated land hemisphere, a distorted Black Sea and Azov, the Caspian as a lake, and a landlocked Indian Ocean.
- Its errors and its Terra Incognita spurred the discovery of the New World (15th century) and Australia and Antarctica (18th century), more than 1,300 and 1,600 years later.
Exam pointers: Almagest (1,022 stars, 48 constellations). Guide to Geography, 8 volumes, 26 regional maps, about 8,000 places. Geography = art of map-making; chorography = parts (eye or ear) vs geography = whole (head). Prime meridian at the Canaries (Ferro). 1° = 500 stadia. 180° east–west extent, which helped Columbus. Nile sources: Lake Tana and the Mountains of the Moon. First to plot the Volga and the Bay of Bengal. Landlocked Indian Ocean.
Summary of Greco-Roman concerns (per the book)
- Detailed topographical description of places and their history (chorography)
- Measurement of the earth and map production
- A philosophical interest in human–environment relations: the environment influences people, and people can modify it only to some extent