Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Humboldt vs Ritter + Geographical Societies

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

1 min read2 sections

Humboldt vs Ritter + Geographical Societies

Humboldt vs Ritter ⭐ (frequently asked)

Basis
Humboldt
Ritter
Dates
1769–1859
1779–1859
Approach
Systematic (physical) geography
Regional geography
Method
Inductive, empirical
Empirical, but called deductive (from laws to regions); comparative
Philosophy
Agnostic, scientific; unity of nature is aesthetic (like Goethe)
Teleological, religious; unity is a God-given plan for humanity
Focus
Nature: physical features, climate, vegetation
Man: man–nature relations, earth as the home of man
Key concept
Zusammenhang, unity of nature, causality
Unity in diversity, earth as an organism
Magnum opus
Kosmos (1845–62)
Erdkunde (1817–59, 19 volumes)
Fieldwork
Unsurpassed traveller (Americas, Russia)
Fieldwork mainly in Europe; against armchair geography
Academic post
None (influence outside Germany)
First chair of geography, Berlin (1820)
Founder of
Plant geography, climatology, physical geography
Comparative regional geography
Common ground:
  • Both stressed the unity of nature as the ultimate aim of research, in tune with the idealist philosophy of their time.
  • Both saw interrelations of phenomena in an area.
  • Both followed Kant on "nature".

Status of geography in their time

  • Geography was still an umbrella for expeditions and activities in the natural and social sciences, largely supported by geographical societies, which funded expeditions and published yearbooks and journals with maps.
#
Society
Year
1
Société de Géographie de Paris
1821 (the first)
2
Gesellschaft für Erdkunde zu Berlin
1828
3
Royal Geographical Society, London
1830
4
Geographical Society, Mexico
1833
5
Geographical Society, Frankfurt
1836
6
Geographical Society, Brazil
1838
7
Imperial Russian Geographical Society, St Petersburg
1845
8
American Geographical Society
1852