Humboldt vs Ritter ⭐ (frequently asked)
Basis | Humboldt | Ritter |
Dates | 1769–1859 | 1779–1859 |
Approach | Systematic (physical) geography | Regional geography |
Method | Inductive, empirical | Empirical, but called deductive (from laws to regions); comparative |
Philosophy | Agnostic, scientific; unity of nature is aesthetic (like Goethe) | Teleological, religious; unity is a God-given plan for humanity |
Focus | Nature: physical features, climate, vegetation | Man: man–nature relations, earth as the home of man |
Key concept | Zusammenhang, unity of nature, causality | Unity in diversity, earth as an organism |
Magnum opus | Kosmos (1845–62) | Erdkunde (1817–59, 19 volumes) |
Fieldwork | Unsurpassed traveller (Americas, Russia) | Fieldwork mainly in Europe; against armchair geography |
Academic post | None (influence outside Germany) | First chair of geography, Berlin (1820) |
Founder of | Plant geography, climatology, physical geography | Comparative regional geography |
Common ground:
- Both stressed the unity of nature as the ultimate aim of research, in tune with the idealist philosophy of their time.
- Both saw interrelations of phenomena in an area.
- Both followed Kant on "nature".
Status of geography in their time
- Geography was still an umbrella for expeditions and activities in the natural and social sciences, largely supported by geographical societies, which funded expeditions and published yearbooks and journals with maps.
# | Society | Year |
1 | Société de Géographie de Paris | 1821 (the first) |
2 | Gesellschaft für Erdkunde zu Berlin | 1828 |
3 | Royal Geographical Society, London | 1830 |
4 | Geographical Society, Mexico | 1833 |
5 | Geographical Society, Frankfurt | 1836 |
6 | Geographical Society, Brazil | 1838 |
7 | Imperial Russian Geographical Society, St Petersburg | 1845 |
8 | American Geographical Society | 1852 |