Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Quantitative Revolution (QR) & Its Advocates

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

8 min read8 sections

Quantitative Revolution (QR) & Its Advocates

Origin and background ⭐

  • Statistical methods entered geography in the early 1950s (Burton, 1963): descriptive statistics, hypothesis testing (chi-square), then bivariate regression. The General Linear Model was fully explored in the 1960s.
  • Ian Burton (1963): paper "The Quantitative Revolution and Theoretical Geography", The Canadian Geographer (7: 151–162). He declared that the revolution was over (it had been accepted).
  • Statistics generate and test hypotheses from empirical data, and estimate model parameters. Mathematics derives models from abstract assumptions (e.g. distance-decay and gravity models).
  • Crisis of geography in the USA:
    • 1948: James Conant, President of Harvard, concluded that "geography is not a university subject". The Harvard geography department closed soon after, and geography was eased out of many private US universities.
    • The threat of closure led to a frantic search for new ideas, which produced the "spatial science school", i.e. the QR.
    • Geographers felt an inferiority complex: no standard theories, models or laws like other sciences.
  • Centres: Washington (Seattle; Garrison), Wisconsin, Iowa (USA), then Britain (Cambridge: Chorley, Haggett; also Harvey) and Sweden (Lund: Hägerstrand), a famous centre of theoretical geography.

Objectives of the QR ⭐

  1. Change the descriptive (geo + graphy) character and make geography scientific.
  1. Explain and interpret spatial patterns rationally, objectively and cogently.
  1. Use mathematical language instead of literary language (e.g. "Af" in Köppen = tropical rainforest).
  1. Make precise statements (generalisations) about locational order.
  1. Test hypotheses, and formulate models, theories and laws for estimation and prediction.
  1. Identify ideal locations for economic activities to maximise profit.
  1. Give geography a sound philosophical and theoretical base and an objective, scientific methodology.
  • Stressed field surveys for data and empirical observation.

Assumptions in model-building ⭐

  1. Man is a rational (economic) person who always optimises.
  1. Man has infinite (perfect) knowledge of his space and resources.
  1. Space is an isotropic surface (uniform in all directions).
  1. No place for normative questions (social values) in scientific research.
  1. Cultural values, beliefs, attitudes, customs, traditions, likes and dislikes, prejudice and aesthetic values have no place in scientific explanation.

Sources of mathematical modelling

Source
Focus
Mathematics
Social physics
Gravity model, later entropy maximisation. Spatial interaction among discrete points
Matrix algebra
Neoclassical economics (via the regional science movement and location theory)
Optimisation over continuous space
Differential calculus
  • Models borrowed from economics and sociology:
    • von Thünen: agricultural land use / crop intensity (1826)
    • Alfred Weber: industrial location (1909)
  • Walter Christaller (1893–1969): the first geographer to contribute substantially to location theory: Central Places in Southern Germany (1933).
  • E.A. Ackerman (1958): urged quantification of cultural processes and systematic geography.
  • J.C. Weaver (1954): crop combination regions of the Middle West using a standard-deviation technique.
  • Hägerstrand: stochastic model of innovation diffusion (stochastic = random; based on probability theory, with random variables built in).
  • Gravity model: the movement of people between two cities is proportional to the product of their populations and inversely proportional to the square of the distance. J.Q. Stewart noted its isomorphism with Newton's law of gravitation.
  • More recently: dynamic linear models (space–time forecasting), non-linear (spectral analysis), spatial autocorrelation.

Merits ⭐

  • Based on empirical observation, readily verifiable.
  • Reduce a multitude of data to a manageable number of factors.
  • Help estimate, interpolate, simulate and forecast.
  • Describe, analyse and simplify geographical systems. Built locational theories (industry, agricultural intensity, stages of development).
  • Provide a framework for formal theoretical statements and a precise mathematical language (brevity and clarity).
  • Factorial designs allow objective measurement.
  • Models are generally precise and help build theories and laws.
  • Based on positivism, which distinguishes science from metaphysics and religion, giving geography a sound philosophical and methodological base.

Demerits ⭐

  1. Based on positivism (August Comte, about 1820s), it made geography a spatial science and reduced it to space geometry. Man–environment relations cannot be captured by mechanistic models.
  1. Geometry is not an acceptable language for man–environment relations, the main concern of human geography.
  1. Excludes normative questions (beliefs, taboos, hopes, fears, prejudices, emotions, aesthetics). In reality these shape decisions. Examples:
      • Khasis and Lushais (NE India): dairying does not develop because milk is taboo.
      • Muslims reject piggery. Sikhs dislike tobacco cultivation.
      • Excluding values gives a parochial picture.
  1. Locational analysis promotes capitalism: exploitation of people and resources, so the rich get richer.
  1. Automation reduces employment: wasteful production.
  1. The "rational economic man" is unrealistic. Herbert Simon: man chooses a satisfactory rather than optimal option ("satisficer").
  1. Infinite knowledge is impossible; knowledge of resources changes with technology.
  1. Models reduce people to passive agents, a kind of economic determinism.
  1. Needs mathematical skill and reliable data, which is rare in developing countries. Bad data give a distorted picture.
  1. Sacrificed useful qualitative statements about regional personality.
  1. Predictions often wrong, with a danger of overgeneralisation.
  1. Models exaggerate some features and distort others.
  1. Universal laws in human geography are impossible. Even physics gives probabilities, not definite predictions. Stephen Hawking: "the laws of science cannot completely determine the future of the universe"; God "plays dice".

Critics and aftermath ⭐

  • David Harvey (1970s): once a staunch quantifier (Explanation in Geography, 1969), he became an "apostate": "The quantitative revolution has run its course and diminishing marginal returns are setting in" (Social Justice and the City, 1973).
  • L.D. Stamp: called the QR a "civil war". Quantification is like a political ideology or religion: "its golden calf is the computer". There is a temptation to discard information that cannot be punched on a card, and ethical and aesthetic values are ignored.
  • R. Minshull: the landscape was becoming a "nuisance" to some geographers. Many models apply only to a flat, featureless surface. Ideal generalisations may be mistaken for statements about reality, and models may be subjectively justified.
  • Western bias: models from about 100 years of data in capitalist societies may be wrongly treated as universal truths. There is no universal urban or agricultural geography. Processes differ in socialist planned economies and developing countries. So the QR failed to produce universal laws and paradigms.
  • By the late 1960s spatial science dominated English-language journals, mostly positivist. As a reaction, the behavioural and humanistic approaches arose.
  • Today: mathematics and statistics are one of many tools. Some problems need quantitative methods, some qualitative, and often a combination is best.
  • Chorley and Haggett: a model is "an idealised or simplified representation of reality which seeks to illuminate particular characteristics". A model may be a theory, a law, a hypothesis or a structured idea.

Leading advocates ⭐

Peter Haggett (1933– )

  • Cambridge, then Bristol. Writes in three areas:
      1. Nature of geography: Frontiers in Geographical Teaching (1965, with Chorley), Models in Geography (1967, with Chorley), Geography: A Modern Synthesis (1972), The Geographer's Art (1990), Geography: A Global Synthesis (2001). Founded the journals Progress in Physical Geography and Progress in Human Geography.
      1. Quantitative methods: Locational Analysis in Human Geography (1965), Network Analysis in Geography (1969), Regional Forecasting (1971), Elements of Spatial Structure (1975), Locational Models and Locational Methods (1977).
      1. Geography of disease: Spatial Diffusion (1979), Spatial Aspects of Influenza Epidemics (1986), Atlas of Disease Distribution (1988), Atlas of AIDS (1992), Measles: A Historical Geography (1993), World Atlas of Epidemic Diseases (2004).

Richard J. Chorley (1927–2002)

  • Cambridge (Demonstrator 1957, Reader 1970, Chair 1974). Put British geomorphology at the world's centre.
  • Rejected Davis's cycle of erosion and replaced it with a quantitative, model-based paradigm: general system theory and numerical modelling, system dynamics.
  • 📚 Physical Geography: A Systems Approach (1971, with Kennedy), Environmental Systems (1978), Atmosphere, Weather and Climate (1968, with Roger Barry), Water, Earth and Man (1969), The History of the Study of Landforms (vol. 1, 1964; vol. 2, 1973; vol. 3, 1991).

William Bunge (1928–2013)

  • American. Self-described quantitative analyst, spatial theorist, radical humanist and Marxist.
  • Theoretical Geography (1962): geography as the science of spatial relations / geometry, with innovative cartography.
  • Later an urban radical: Detroit Geographical Expedition (1968) with Gwendolyn Warren, the Society for Human Exploration (1971), and social justice in inner cities (Fitzgerald, 1971).

Torsten Hägerstrand (1916–2004)

  • Lund University, Sweden (PhD 1953). Honorary doctorates from Bristol, Glasgow and Edinburgh.
  • Diffusion models in population geography, the Monte Carlo simulation of diffusion. Founder of time geography.
  • 📚 Innovation Diffusion as a Spatial Process (1953; English 1967), Definition of Migration (1973), The Domain of Human Geography (1973), Impact of Transport on the Quality of Life (1974), Space, Time and Human Conditions (1975).