Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Environmental Determinism

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

7 min read4 sections

Environmental Determinism

Definition

  • "The belief that variations in human behaviour around the world can be explained by differences in the natural environment."
  • The history, culture, lifestyle and stage of development of a group or nation are exclusively or largely governed by physical factors.
  • Man is a passive agent. Physical factors shape his attitudes and decisions. Most human activity is a response to the natural environment.
  • It persisted in one form or another until World War II. It was the first approach geographers used to generalise human occupation of the earth.

Historical development

Greco-Roman

  • Hippocrates (physician), Aristotle, and the historians Thucydides, Xenophon, Herodotus.
  • Thucydides and Xenophon: Athens' greatness came from its natural conditions and position. Strabo: likewise for Rome (and slope, relief and climate are works of God).
  • Aristotle:
    • Cold Europe: brave but unintelligent. Able to keep independence, but lacking political organisation and the capacity to rule others.
    • Warm Asia: intelligent but lacking spirit, so slavery is their natural state.
    • Greece, in the "middle position", combines the best qualities and is destined by nature to rule all (Glacken, 1967). People tend to judge their own place best.
  • Greeks contrasted easy-going Asiatics in favourable environments with hard-working Europeans, and tall, gentle, brave mountain folk with lean, sinewy, blonde lowlanders.

Later European thinkers

  • Montesquieu: people in cold climates are physically stronger, more courageous, frank, less suspicious and less cunning. In warm climates they are timorous, weak, indolent and passive.
  • George Tatham (18th century, the book's spelling): explained differences between peoples by their lands.
  • Kant: people of New Holland have half-closed eyes because of flies. Inhabitants of hot lands are lazy and timid, timidity breeds superstition and, under kings, slavery. Migrant animals change: brown squirrels turn grey in Siberia.

Arabs

  • Seven kishwars (climatic zones) with characteristic races. Al-Battani, Al-Masudi, Ibn Hawqal, Al-Idrisi, Ibn Khaldun correlated environment with ways of life.
  • Al-Masudi: in water-rich Sham (Syria) people are gay and humorous; in dry lands, short-tempered. Open-air nomads have strength, resolution, wisdom and fitness.

19th century

  • Ritter: anthropocentric, introduced geographical determinism in the early 19th century. Narrow eyelids of the Turkomans are an effect of the desert. His pupils saw geography as the relation between population density and the nature of the land.
  • Humboldt: the life of mountain people differs from that of plains people.
  • Malthus (1760–1834): economist and "scientific determinist". The earth imposes limits on social development.
  • Darwin (1859) + Newtonian cause and effect + deductive approaches gave rise to "scientific" environmental determinism, which explained migrations and national character.
  • W.M. Davis: Darwinian cycle of erosion. Environmentalism prevailed in US geography around 1900.

"New" determinism: Ratzel ⭐

  • Founder of the "new" determinism. Added Social Darwinism to classical determinism. The state is an organism that owes its life to the earth and seeks more territory.
  • "Similar locations lead to similar modes of life." Example: the British Isles and Japan, whose insular location gives natural defence and rapid progress.
  • Survival of the fittest. Man is the product of evolution by natural selection according to adjustment to the environment.
  • Gave special weight to location in relation to mountains and plains.

Ellen Semple ⭐

  • Ratzel's direct heir. American History and Its Geographic Conditions (1903/05) and Influences of Geographic Environment (1911) established environmentalism in America.
  • "Man is a product of the earth's surface …": mountains give legs of iron, coasts give chest and arms, river valleys attach him to the soil.
  • Attitudes by setting:
    • Mountain dwellers: conservative, isolated, slow to adopt innovation, orthodox, suspicious of strangers, sensitive to criticism, religious, family-loving. The hard struggle makes them industrious, frugal, provident and honest.
    • European plains people: energetic, serious, thoughtful rather than emotional, cautious rather than impulsive.
    • Mediterranean people: mild climate, easy life, so gay, humorous, sporting and imaginative.

Ellsworth Huntington ⭐

  • Principles of Human Geography (1920; 1945 edition). Took "the most decisive step since Hippocrates" in environmental causation. Had a predilection for racial typecasting and stressed genetic constitution (Spate, 1968).
  • Climate is the leading factor in civilisation. Climatic changes caused "pulsations" in cultural history. Linked climatic cycles with the Golden Age of Greece, the Renaissance, even iron production and share prices.
  • Ancient civilisations (Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, Indus) flourished in fertile river valleys of mild climate.
  • Nomadic invasions (Mongols into Iran, Iraq, Central Asia, China, India; raids into Eastern Europe in the 13th century) were caused by drying pastures.
  • Religion and racial character are products of climate.
  • Ideal: about 20°C with variable, temperate cyclonic weather, found in NE USA and NW Europe, which explains Western science and technology.
  • Tropics: hot, humid, oppressive weather makes people lethargic, lazy, inefficient, suspicious and timid, hence underdevelopment.
  • His map of "health and energy" and civilisation, based on the opinions of Americans and Europeans, rated his own NE USA best. It is highly subjective, logically no different from Aristotle, just from a different home.

Others with deterministic interpretations

Mackinder, Chisholm, Davis, Bowman, Mill, Geddes, Sauer (early), Herbertson, Taylor.

Diet, soil and physique (examples in the book)

  • Climate → soil → cropping → diet → physique and attitude.
  • McCarrison: Sikhs are taller and stronger than Tamils because of a protein-rich diet.
  • Khasis (Meghalaya): poor physique from low protein and year-round humidity (breathing problems).
  • Boyd Orr and Gilks (Kenya): Kikuyu (cereals, tubers) vs Masai (meat, milk, ox blood). They live side by side but differ greatly in physique because of diet.
  • Poor physique of tribals, rural masses, slum dwellers, Somalians, Nepalis and Bangladeshis comes from undernourishment.
  • Soil and health: "The history of civilisation is the history of soil." Roosevelt: "If soil is gone, men must go."
    • Shetland ponies (about 1 m tall, 60° N) grew to normal horse size on rich American soils within generations: no separate race.
    • Chinese and Japanese migrants to the West grew taller. Pygmies grow taller in agricultural areas.
  • Geddes: poorly nourished people are more prone to malaria. Meat-eating Muslims suffer less than vegetarian Hindus.
  • Birth rate vs animal protein: Sweden 63 g / 15‰, Denmark 60 g / 18‰, India 7 g / 35‰, Malaysia 8 g / 33‰. High birth rates (above 30) are tropical. Fertility falls as animal protein rises (an over-generalisation; other factors matter too).

Criticism ⭐

  • Overly simplistic: it neglects cultural factors. Similar environments host dissimilar societies:
    • Bakarwals vs Kashmiris (J&K)
    • Nepalis vs Khasis (Meghalaya)
    • Assamese vs Bengalis (Brahmaputra valley)
    • Tharus vs Sikhs (Tarai)
    • Eskimos vs Siberian tundra tribes
    • Pygmy hunters vs Negro farmers (Central Africa, in symbiosis)
    • Khasis, Garos, Jaintias, Lushais (different traits under a similar climate)
  • The same land means different things to people with different attitudes, objectives and technology:
    • Gujjars and Bakarwals use slopes for pasture (nomads). Kashmiris use the level land for paddy and orchards (cultivators).
    • Slope for the hoe vs the tractor.
    • Water-power sites lost importance after steam.
  • Man changes the environment, often beyond recognition:
    • The Mediterranean's wheat, barley, olive and vine
    • Orchards of Kashmir, Himachal and Kumaun
    • Basmati rice in 50 cm rainfall areas of Punjab and Haryana
    • HYV wheat in West Bengal, Odisha and Dimapur
  • After WWII, environmentalism was attacked for exaggerating nature's role and treating man as passive.
  • O.H.K. Spate: "Environment taken by itself is a meaningless phrase; without man environment does not exist." The geographical environment is one factor of territorial differentiation; it acts through society, and cultural tradition has a certain autonomous influence.
  • Wolfgang Hartke (German): physical factors may be unimportant on the fringe of Frankfurt, but in the Sahara extreme climate surely plays a direct role.
  • Hartshorne: rejected environmentalism because it separates man from nature, disrupting the fundamental unity of geography.