Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Carl Ritter (1779–1859)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

4 min read3 sections

Carl Ritter (1779–1859)

👤
Born 7 August 1779 at Quedlinburg (the book says Berlin). Father a physician, died when Ritter was 5. Educated at Schnepfenthal by Rousseau-type methods (teachers Salzmann and GutsMuths). Influenced by Pestalozzi and Hegel. Met Humboldt in 1807. Studied at Göttingen (1814). First Professor of Geography in Germany: University of Berlin, 1820. Founded the Berlin Geographical Society (1828). Served Berlin for 39 years. Also taught at the military college. Died 1859.

Titles ⭐

  • Founder of modern geography (with Humboldt)
  • Founder of the comparative method in regional geography
  • Teleologist: a firm believer in God (unlike agnostic Humboldt)
  • First great opponent of "armchair geography" (a dedicated fieldworker)
  • First holder of a geography chair in Germany

📚 Erdkunde ⭐

  • Full title: Die Erdkunde im Verhältnis zur Natur und zur Geschichte des Menschen ("Earth science in relation to nature and the history of mankind").
  • 19 volumes (1817–1859), covering only Africa and parts of Asia. Europe was never finished.
  • Conceptualised regional geography, contrasted with Humboldt's systematic geography.
  • "The earth and its inhabitants stand in the closest reciprocal relations, and one cannot be truly presented in all its relationships without the other. Hence history and geography must always remain inseparable." Land affects people and people affect land.
  • Theory of the north-west movement of civilisation in Europe: the east had uniform environments, so uniform history; the west and south had varied environments, so rich history.
  • Humboldt called Erdkunde a "great and inspired work" that proceeds "from observation to observation, not from hypothesis to observation".

Core ideas

1. Teleology

  • From the Greek telos = purpose: explaining events by their purpose, the opposite of mechanical, cause-and-effect explanation.
  • God is the planner of the universe. The shape and location of continents are not accidental but designed for human development.
  • The earth is an organism, and the continents are "individuals" or "organs".
  • "As the body is made for the soul, so is the physical globe made for mankind." The earth is made for man, fitting his needs to perfection even in the smallest details.
  • His studies revealed "more and more of God's plan".
  • Teleology was later rejected as unscientific.

2. Unity in diversity (fundamental principle) ⭐

  • There is a fundamental unity in the biotic and abiotic components of the habitat in which man shapes his cultural environment.
  • Every naturally bounded area is a unity in climate, production, culture, population and history. This is a regional approach.
  • The merit of Ritter's work lies in deducing regional descriptions from a system of laws governing the "regional association of terrestrial phenomena".

3. Definition and scope

  • Geography deals with the globe in all its features, phenomena and relations as an independent unit, and shows the connection of this whole with man and with man's Creator.
  • Central principle: "the relation of all phenomena and forms of nature to the human race." Anthropocentric, inherited from Kant.
  • Earth = the home of man. "The outer shell of the earth, not the entire earth, is the area of geographical study."
  • "We must ask the earth itself for its laws."
  • Geography is not a dry gazetteer of names but a "new" scientific geography of man–nature relations.
  • Three attributes of place:
    • Topical (natural divisions of the surface)
    • Formal (distribution and movement of water, sea, atmosphere: the base of human life)
    • Material (distribution of minerals, plants and animals)

4. Method

  • Called "deductive" in the book (deduces conclusions from fundamental assumptions), though he insisted on empirical observation. Studied areas synthetically (in their totality) and holistically.

5. Stimulating ideas

  • Land and water hemispheres. The difference in heating and cooling of land and water. The N–S hemisphere difference in the land/water ratio.
  • Continents compared:
    • Africa: shortest, most regular coastline; interior has the least contact with the sea
    • Asia: more inlets, but an isolated interior
    • Europe: most varied, long accessible coastline
  • Continents and races (an over-generalisation): Africa black, Europe white, Asia yellow, America red.
  • Physical environment can determine the course of human development, strengthened by Darwin (1859).

Major concepts (book's summary)

  1. Geography is an empirical science, not deduced from a priori theory.
  1. Coherence in the spatial arrangement of phenomena. Interrelated phenomena make each area unique (an individual unit).
  1. Boundaries (wet or dry: rivers, mountains) are tools for understanding the content of areas.
  1. Geography studies objects as they exist together in an area, synthetically.
  1. A holistic view culminating in man.
  1. The earth is an organism made with divine intent for man (teleology).
🎯
Exam pointers: Erdkunde, 19 volumes. Unity in diversity. Teleology. Comparative regional method. "Ask the earth for its laws." First geography chair (Berlin, 1820). Earth as the home of man. Students: Kapp, Guyot, Reclus.