1. Positivism ⭐⭐
Definition: A philosophical movement that treats science and the scientific method as the only source of knowledge, draws a sharp line between fact (data) and value, and is hostile to religion and traditional philosophy, especially metaphysics.
- Founder: Auguste Comte (1798–1857), France, in the 1830s. He called metaphysics a useless branch of enquiry and wanted a "sociocracy" ruled by scientists for humanity's unity and progress.
- Also called empiricism: knowledge is limited to observable facts and their relationships.
- Science deals only with empirical questions (how things are). Reality = the world that can be sensed. Facts "speak for themselves".
- What is not derived from the senses is not knowledge. To be scientific is to be objective, truthful and neutral.
- Unity of science: a common experience of reality, a common scientific language and method, and repeatable observation. So there is only one comprehensive science (physics, chemistry, biology, psychology and social sciences linked logically).
- Anti-idealism (idealism holds that reality is mind-dependent).
- Keep away from normative questions (values, beliefs, attitudes, prejudices, customs, tastes, aesthetics), since they cannot be tested. Science is value-free, neutral, impartial and objective. Metaphysics is unscientific.
Five claims of positivism ⭐
- Empiricism (Greek empeire = experience): observation statements are privileged over theoretical ones. (Modern view: reason gives hypotheses and experience weeds out the false ones.)
- A unified scientific method accepted by all scientists.
- Formulation of scientific laws: theories capable of empirical verification, which identify universal laws.
- Exclusion of normative questions: value judgements are "ruled out of the scientific court".
- Unification of scientific laws into a single, incontrovertible system.
- Cumulative effect: moving from the immediate → unitary → universal, "closing the system" around one version of the present.
History
- Emerged after the French Revolution as a weapon against the pre-revolution "negative philosophy": romantic, speculative, emotional and utopian. Positivists called it negative because it was neither constructive nor practical. The "positive" approach studies material objects and given circumstances.
- A science of society (sociology) on natural-science principles: the laws of society can be found like the laws of nature.
- Comte's three stages of social development:
- Theological (everything is God's will)
- Metaphysical
- Positive (causal links between observed phenomena)
- Anti-authoritarian: accept nothing on authority, only on evidence, which brought positivists into conflict with dictatorships.
- 1930: "Logical positivists" / the Vienna Circle: against everything not empirically verifiable. They saw Nazism as irrational prejudice and dogma.
- In geography: the basis of the quantitative revolution, spatial science and locational analysis (see Ch 10).
Criticism ⭐
- Realists and Marxists: it seeks laws of the superstructure unrelated to processes in the infrastructure (economic base), and such laws cannot exist because the infrastructure keeps changing.
- Humanists (idealists, structuralists, existentialists, Marxists, behaviouralists, phenomenologists): value-free research is impossible. Subjectivity enters at topic choice, problem formulation and interpretation. Example: a researcher with strong views on how world food supply should be distributed. Findings then influence decision-makers, so science shapes reality and is not a passive observer.
- The unity of science is not achieved: each social science has its own approach.
- Natural and social sciences differ: man is not a "thing". He has a brain, intentions, imagination and beliefs that cannot be put into the "thing language" of the natural sciences. Subjectivity is necessary for social laws.
2. Pragmatism ⭐
Definition: A philosophy centrally concerned with the construction of meaning through experience: "the position in philosophy that defines meaning and knowledge in terms of their function in experience, with reference to adjustment and the resolution of problematic situations."
- A modified form of positivism. It uses the scientific method but aims to solve human problems, with a value-based methodology (attitudes, beliefs, norms).
- Action-oriented and user-oriented. It extends the experimental method to evaluation and implementation. Research solves an immediate problem for a target population. The researcher is an "action agent".
- In geography: "planned action rather than thought for planning". Values are part of reality. Lobbying and persuasion matter.
- Developed in America after the Civil War (philosophers C.S. Peirce, William James, John Dewey, commonly cited). Influential until WWII. Also present in Western Europe. Borrowed by British geographers from America.
- The concrete or particular situation matters, but abstract or general laws are useful guiding principles. It handles both theory and practice.
- One geographer proposed strategies of "organisation, persuasion and action" for social transformation.
Attributes
- The imperfection of reality: current reality is a composite of knowledge and error.
- A fallibilistic view of knowledge: nothing guarantees an expected outcome, so assumptions and hypotheses must be tested and modified.
- The scientific method and hypothetical modes of investigation are the best found so far.
- Logic as a problem-solving tool.
- It led to applied geography and policy: modifying environments, removing inequality in housing, education and health, preserving cultural landscapes. These involve researcher and client values that may differ from those of affected groups.
- Spatial laws are valid as frameworks for hypotheses, which are constantly modified with empirical data.
- The human element is central: "our thoughts determine our acts, and our acts determine the previous nature of the world" (like Vidal and the French school). Humanism reconciles man and science: understanding and wisdom, objectivity and subjectivity, materialism and idealism.
Elements of pragmatic geography
- Geographic space is a composite of knowledge and error.
- Space is changeable as knowledge and measurement improve.
- Space is a manifestation of the human element through time.
- Space is structured and restructured by solving practical problems.
- Spatial reality is a composite of human experience.
- Spatial laws are useful for hypotheses, which can be modified.
- Geography studies practical problems of man in space using the scientific method.
3. Functionalism
Meanings of "function"
- A public gathering for a ceremonial purpose.
- Political science: the duties of a job involving authority.
- Mathematics: the relation between a variable and its arguments.
- Sociology and biology: processes that maintain the organism.
- Geography: synonymous with occupation.
- Functionalism studies functional linkages, with emphasis on goals, needs, and the links between role and actor: the analysis of the functions of a society.
- It views the world as differentiated, interdependent systems with repeatable, predictable regularities, where form and function are related, explained by their role in maintaining the system's continuity.
Basic principles
- Study societies holistically as interrelated systems.
- Causation is reciprocal, often multiple.
- Social systems are generally in equilibrium.
- Less interest in history, more in social interaction.
- Find interrelationships among the components of social structure.
In geography
- Jean Brunhes and his French contemporaries: culture is an indivisible whole. The region is a functional unit, an "organism" more than the sum of its parts.
- Towns by function: Mumbai (chief port), Tatanagar (iron and steel), Gulmarg (tourism). Smaller towns by their function in the central place hierarchy.
- Manifest vs latent functions: Tatanagar's manifest function is steel manufacture. Its latent function is the exchange of ideas and social meeting.
- Functional region: the region functions as a unit to maintain intense inter- and intra-subsystem interaction that meets needs.
Six interrelated concepts of functionalism
(i) Functions, (ii) functional substitutability, (iii) goals, (iv) pattern maintenance / self-regulation / status quo, (v) adaptation, (vi) integration.
Criticism ⭐
- Treats reality as equilibrium (status quo) and assumes total social integration.
- Preoccupation with the system means it ignores poverty, war, disease and racism.
- Advocates social control rather than social change: a "static bias".
- Explanations are structural: no reference to underlying motives or processes. Lacks definitional clarity.
- Teleology (main logical criticism): it explains a situation by its ends, not its causes. Example: "vultures were created to get rid of corpses". But others (foxes, hyenas, men) can do the same job: the principle of functional substitutability.
- The substitute must come from the same ecosystem. Otherwise it upsets the balance: snowmobiles and firearms among the Eskimos disturbed the balance with Arctic wildlife.