Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Positivism, Pragmatism & Functionalism

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

7 min read3 sections

Positivism, Pragmatism & Functionalism

1. Positivism ⭐⭐

💡
Definition: A philosophical movement that treats science and the scientific method as the only source of knowledge, draws a sharp line between fact (data) and value, and is hostile to religion and traditional philosophy, especially metaphysics.
  • Founder: Auguste Comte (1798–1857), France, in the 1830s. He called metaphysics a useless branch of enquiry and wanted a "sociocracy" ruled by scientists for humanity's unity and progress.
  • Also called empiricism: knowledge is limited to observable facts and their relationships.
    • Science deals only with empirical questions (how things are). Reality = the world that can be sensed. Facts "speak for themselves".
    • What is not derived from the senses is not knowledge. To be scientific is to be objective, truthful and neutral.
  • Unity of science: a common experience of reality, a common scientific language and method, and repeatable observation. So there is only one comprehensive science (physics, chemistry, biology, psychology and social sciences linked logically).
  • Anti-idealism (idealism holds that reality is mind-dependent).
  • Keep away from normative questions (values, beliefs, attitudes, prejudices, customs, tastes, aesthetics), since they cannot be tested. Science is value-free, neutral, impartial and objective. Metaphysics is unscientific.

Five claims of positivism ⭐

  1. Empiricism (Greek empeire = experience): observation statements are privileged over theoretical ones. (Modern view: reason gives hypotheses and experience weeds out the false ones.)
  1. A unified scientific method accepted by all scientists.
  1. Formulation of scientific laws: theories capable of empirical verification, which identify universal laws.
  1. Exclusion of normative questions: value judgements are "ruled out of the scientific court".
  1. Unification of scientific laws into a single, incontrovertible system.
  • Cumulative effect: moving from the immediate → unitary → universal, "closing the system" around one version of the present.

History

  • Emerged after the French Revolution as a weapon against the pre-revolution "negative philosophy": romantic, speculative, emotional and utopian. Positivists called it negative because it was neither constructive nor practical. The "positive" approach studies material objects and given circumstances.
  • A science of society (sociology) on natural-science principles: the laws of society can be found like the laws of nature.
  • Comte's three stages of social development:
      1. Theological (everything is God's will)
      1. Metaphysical
      1. Positive (causal links between observed phenomena)
  • Anti-authoritarian: accept nothing on authority, only on evidence, which brought positivists into conflict with dictatorships.
  • 1930: "Logical positivists" / the Vienna Circle: against everything not empirically verifiable. They saw Nazism as irrational prejudice and dogma.
  • In geography: the basis of the quantitative revolution, spatial science and locational analysis (see Ch 10).

Criticism ⭐

  • Realists and Marxists: it seeks laws of the superstructure unrelated to processes in the infrastructure (economic base), and such laws cannot exist because the infrastructure keeps changing.
  • Humanists (idealists, structuralists, existentialists, Marxists, behaviouralists, phenomenologists): value-free research is impossible. Subjectivity enters at topic choice, problem formulation and interpretation. Example: a researcher with strong views on how world food supply should be distributed. Findings then influence decision-makers, so science shapes reality and is not a passive observer.
  • The unity of science is not achieved: each social science has its own approach.
  • Natural and social sciences differ: man is not a "thing". He has a brain, intentions, imagination and beliefs that cannot be put into the "thing language" of the natural sciences. Subjectivity is necessary for social laws.

2. Pragmatism ⭐

💡
Definition: A philosophy centrally concerned with the construction of meaning through experience: "the position in philosophy that defines meaning and knowledge in terms of their function in experience, with reference to adjustment and the resolution of problematic situations."
  • A modified form of positivism. It uses the scientific method but aims to solve human problems, with a value-based methodology (attitudes, beliefs, norms).
  • Action-oriented and user-oriented. It extends the experimental method to evaluation and implementation. Research solves an immediate problem for a target population. The researcher is an "action agent".
  • In geography: "planned action rather than thought for planning". Values are part of reality. Lobbying and persuasion matter.
  • Developed in America after the Civil War (philosophers C.S. Peirce, William James, John Dewey, commonly cited). Influential until WWII. Also present in Western Europe. Borrowed by British geographers from America.
  • The concrete or particular situation matters, but abstract or general laws are useful guiding principles. It handles both theory and practice.
  • One geographer proposed strategies of "organisation, persuasion and action" for social transformation.

Attributes

  1. The imperfection of reality: current reality is a composite of knowledge and error.
  1. A fallibilistic view of knowledge: nothing guarantees an expected outcome, so assumptions and hypotheses must be tested and modified.
  1. The scientific method and hypothetical modes of investigation are the best found so far.
  1. Logic as a problem-solving tool.
  • It led to applied geography and policy: modifying environments, removing inequality in housing, education and health, preserving cultural landscapes. These involve researcher and client values that may differ from those of affected groups.
  • Spatial laws are valid as frameworks for hypotheses, which are constantly modified with empirical data.
  • The human element is central: "our thoughts determine our acts, and our acts determine the previous nature of the world" (like Vidal and the French school). Humanism reconciles man and science: understanding and wisdom, objectivity and subjectivity, materialism and idealism.

Elements of pragmatic geography

  1. Geographic space is a composite of knowledge and error.
  1. Space is changeable as knowledge and measurement improve.
  1. Space is a manifestation of the human element through time.
  1. Space is structured and restructured by solving practical problems.
  1. Spatial reality is a composite of human experience.
  1. Spatial laws are useful for hypotheses, which can be modified.
  1. Geography studies practical problems of man in space using the scientific method.

3. Functionalism

Meanings of "function"

  1. A public gathering for a ceremonial purpose.
  1. Political science: the duties of a job involving authority.
  1. Mathematics: the relation between a variable and its arguments.
  1. Sociology and biology: processes that maintain the organism.
  1. Geography: synonymous with occupation.
  • Functionalism studies functional linkages, with emphasis on goals, needs, and the links between role and actor: the analysis of the functions of a society.
  • It views the world as differentiated, interdependent systems with repeatable, predictable regularities, where form and function are related, explained by their role in maintaining the system's continuity.

Basic principles

  1. Study societies holistically as interrelated systems.
  1. Causation is reciprocal, often multiple.
  1. Social systems are generally in equilibrium.
  1. Less interest in history, more in social interaction.
  1. Find interrelationships among the components of social structure.

In geography

  • Jean Brunhes and his French contemporaries: culture is an indivisible whole. The region is a functional unit, an "organism" more than the sum of its parts.
  • Towns by function: Mumbai (chief port), Tatanagar (iron and steel), Gulmarg (tourism). Smaller towns by their function in the central place hierarchy.
  • Manifest vs latent functions: Tatanagar's manifest function is steel manufacture. Its latent function is the exchange of ideas and social meeting.
  • Functional region: the region functions as a unit to maintain intense inter- and intra-subsystem interaction that meets needs.

Six interrelated concepts of functionalism

(i) Functions, (ii) functional substitutability, (iii) goals, (iv) pattern maintenance / self-regulation / status quo, (v) adaptation, (vi) integration.

Criticism ⭐

  • Treats reality as equilibrium (status quo) and assumes total social integration.
  • Preoccupation with the system means it ignores poverty, war, disease and racism.
  • Advocates social control rather than social change: a "static bias".
  • Explanations are structural: no reference to underlying motives or processes. Lacks definitional clarity.
  • Teleology (main logical criticism): it explains a situation by its ends, not its causes. Example: "vultures were created to get rid of corpses". But others (foxes, hyenas, men) can do the same job: the principle of functional substitutability.
    • The substitute must come from the same ecosystem. Otherwise it upsets the balance: snowmobiles and firearms among the Eskimos disturbed the balance with Arctic wildlife.