1. Marxist geography ⭐⭐
Definition: A perspective within historical materialism centrally concerned with how the production of space, place and landscape is implicated in the reproduction of specific "social formations". It developed against capitalism.
- Historical materialism rests on the dialectic: the perpetual resolution of opposites (rich and poor, developed and underdeveloped). Each resolution produces a new contradiction.
- Concerns: uneven development, social justice, regional inequality arising from the division and exploitation of labour, resources and environment through surplus value.
- Rejects value-free research, yet gives no importance to social values such as religion (per the book).
- Discloses the social processes that produce spatial appearances, which in turn feed back into social processes. Space and society interact.
- Marxism is a form of realism: it relates the empirical world of appearances to infrastructural determinants (economic processes).
- A theoretical and political base for resistance to capitalism.
- Rooted in Marx's humanism: capitalism alienates people. The proletariat loses its dignity by selling its labour. To restore it, capitalism must be overthrown and replaced by communism, ending bourgeois ideology.
- Key figure in geography: David Harvey, Social Justice and the City (1973) and The Limits to Capital (1982) (commonly cited). Also Richard Peet, Neil Smith, Doreen Massey.
Objectives of Marxist and realist human geography ⭐
- Explain spatial organisation and society–environment relations, which can be understood only through economic processes.
- Economic processes cannot be understood directly, only via theories of the superstructure (religion, legal system).
- Economic processes change continuously, so universal laws of the superstructure cannot be derived.
- Class struggle (bourgeoisie vs proletariat) is central.
- Any attempt to keep the present superstructure helps the unjust system (capitalism) survive.
- The aim of human geography is social change: to overcome the exploitation of man and environment.
Critique of spatial science (positivism)
- It treated social realities as spatial: it mapped urban segregation without questioning the political and economic processes that produce it.
- It sought efficient locations for factories, supermarkets and services, so it served capitalism.
- Universal spatial laws are a misnomer: different societies produce different spatial arrangements.
Core Marxist ideas
- The state has historically been a device for exploiting the masses by the dominant class. Class struggle drives history. Economic classes and private property are the main causes of historical change and shape man–environment relations.
- Territorial structures reflect socio-spatial dialectics. Geography analyses the dialectical relations of social processes, natural environment and spatial relations.
- Materialism: "It is not consciousness that determines life, but life that determines consciousness" (Marx). Reality (space and place) changes ideas, not the reverse.
- Society develops in stages with the forces of production (materials and instruments of labour). Consciousness grows with productivity, needs, population, and especially the division of material and mental labour. The mode of production is the key to social life and consciousness.
- Laws of society are not eternal (unlike positivism). Engels: economic laws are historical laws that appear and disappear.
- Social formation = a social whole of interrelated "instances":
- The mode of production / economic structure (forces and relations of production)
- The superstructure: political–legal (law, state) and cultural–ideological (religion, ethics, politics)
- Man–space relations change with the mode of production: nomadism → settled agriculture (domestication) → urban culture with many vocations → classes emerge, with beliefs, hierarchy, codes, punishment, worship, family and authority forming the cultural landscape. Classes produce class struggle (exploiters vs exploited).
- Private property (land, forests, mines, factories, the primary means of production) should be community-owned. Private profit confers irresponsible power and luxury. Property breeds pride, vanity, extravagance, fear, envy, hate, corruption and crime.
- Dialectical materialism: the world contains antithetical entities (day and night, rich and poor, wet and dry, elevation and depression, torrid and frigid). Class interests are irreconcilable, so clash is inevitable ("like the robber and his victims").
Man–nature relationship (Marxist view)
- Man is part of nature, yet "apart" as a conscious subject. Consciousness is a product of his nature, not drawn from nature via the senses.
- The key interaction between man and nature is labour. Labour transforms natural objects into use values within particular social relations. Each mode of production has its own environmental relations.
- Capitalism: competition compels constant expansion (accumulation of capital), so demand for raw materials grows, nature is exploited, and environmental crisis follows. Labour is exploited for maximum surplus value. An exploitative, competitive, alienated, commoditised society produces the same in its environmental relations. An economy compelled to expand contradicts a finite, fragile world, which threatens the natural basis of life.
- Geography (Marx's sense): the part of science dealing with dialectical relations between social processes and the natural environment and spatial relations. It aims to change social relations of production (see the Soviet school).
Criticism ⭐
- Failure in practice (USSR):
- Failed agriculture, chronic shortages, massive imports
- Deficient consumer goods
- A privileged elite of state functionaries
- Environmental hazards (Chernobyl)
- Workers no better off
- Black markets around Moscow and Leningrad
- The disintegration of the USSR proved the point.
- It reduces man to a cog in a machine, governed by space, unable to change space through his mind.
2. Radicalism in geography ⭐⭐
Origin
- Mid-1960s (late 1960s) USA, part of oppositional politics, "the movement".
- Domestic issues: inequality, racism, sexism, environment, and opposition to the Vietnam War.
- Reaction against the QR, positivism and locational analysis (geography as spatial science).
- Began as a critique within liberal capitalism, later coalesced around Marxian analysis.
- Inequality is inherent in capitalism. Tax redistribution will not solve poverty. Richard Peet: alternative environmental designs, removing central bureaucracies, anarchistic community control.
- Triggers: burning of big cities, student unrest, the Paris workers' uprising (1968), anti-Vietnam protests, cultural radicalism. These exposed the social irrelevance of spatial science and the hollowness of locational analysis.
- Three political issues (USA): (1) the Vietnam War, (2) civil rights (especially of Black Americans), (3) poverty and inequality in urban ghettos and deprived rural areas.
- Journal Antipode (1969, Clark University, Worcester, Massachusetts): founded to publish young revolutionary geographers on urban poverty, discrimination against women, people of colour and minorities, unequal access to amenities, crime, deprivation, sexism, and Third World underdevelopment, hunger and resource misuse.
- Peet (1977): radical geography developed largely as a negative reaction to spatial science, and introduced poverty, hunger, health and crime into human geography.
- Radicalism took the side of the oppressed: a quest for social relevance in a time of crisis.
Objectives ⭐
- Expose inequality, deprivation, discrimination, health, exploitation, crime and environmental degradation in capitalist countries.
- Highlight the weaknesses of positivism and the QR.
- A cultural revolution against permissiveness, sexism and discrimination against women.
- Remove regional inequality.
- Oppose political centralisation and economic concentration (multinationals). Favour small, self-sufficient communities in harmony with nature.
- Oppose imperialism, nationalism, national chauvinism and racism.
- Oppose the idea of white or Western superiority.
- Man–environment relations are understood through history: the mode of production decides economic relations.
- Not only explain, but prescribe revolutionary change.
- Build a more just, equal, tension-free and peaceful society.
Themes
(a) Geography and imperialism
- Imperialism: an unequal territorial relationship of domination and subordination, usually between states. It need not mean colonialism (control can be economic and political without military rule).
- Responsible for the "destructive / robber economy" (Brunhes opposed this), and so for Third World poverty. Radicals saw the US in Vietnam as imperialist.
- Radicals followed J.A. Hobson's theory of imperialism (1902), elaborated by Lenin (1915/16): imperialism causes war and sustains capitalism. Concentration of production and capital creates monopolies, which form international monopolies that divide the world, leading to rivalry and wars.
- James Blaut (Clark University, later Illinois–Chicago), 1970 onwards:
- Western science is interwoven with imperialism. Imperialism = "white exploitation of the non-white world", underpinned by Western "ethnoscience".
- Ethnocentrism: prejudice assuming one's own culture is superior (a mild racism or xenophobia).
- McGee (1991): geography defined Asia and Africa in Eurocentric terms.
- European "unicentric" model: inner Europe vs outer non-Europe. Europe has unique advantages (race, culture, mind), Europe makes history, the rest is traditional and primitive, and progress is diffused from Europe: "diffusionism".
- Blaut's alternative: a multicentric model. Development centres arose all over the world at relatively equal levels, and this was disrupted by European plunder of the New World and colonisation of Asia and Africa. Bullion and wealth flowed to Europe, financing its development and widening the gap.
- Against the "European miracle" (The Colonizer's Model of the World, 1993):
- Europe was not superior before 1492. When Greeks and Romans flourished, NW Europe had barbaric tribes. Arabs led commerce and science in Europe's Dark Age. India, Iran and China were centres of learning and crafts.
- Colonialism and plunder caused Europe's rise.
- Europe's advantage lay solely in the "mundane realities of location": nearness to the Americas (Blaut, 1994).
- White superiority and Eurocentrism are prejudice and racism.
(b) Women and environment
- Women are oppressed in both developed and developing countries. The women's movement of the 1960s inspired the study of women and space (early 1970s; Mackenzie, 1984).
- Early work criticised the "invisibility" of women and the "gender blindness" of neoclassical and behavioural models. 1970s liberal feminist geography created a geography of women documenting disadvantages and constraints on spatial choice from gender roles (housekeeping, family care).
- Alison Hayford (1974): women are as invisible in geography as in history.
- Women embody the means of relieving the tensions of dealing with finite space in finite time. They are "the essence of locality".
- In traditional societies women bear the main responsibility for gathering, herding and agriculture, and the public/private distinction is small.
- The household was the nodal point of productive systems, the basis of land-use rights, the iconography of locality, "the complete expression of 'here'", and the site of the most dependable relationships and private moments.
- With class society and capitalism, public and private separate. The impersonal power of capital replaces personal, women-centred organisation. Women move from centrality to periphery, "from being the pivot of society's relations to being nowhere".
- Separation of work and home creates spatial tension (ideological commitment to the household vs economic need to work outside). Women lack men's freedom to move in or organise space.
(c) Racism and apartheid
- Strongly opposed apartheid (spatial separation of races), which produced inequality: whites highest standards, blacks and coloureds lowest.
(d) Anarchic leaning
- Anarchism: remove the state, replace it with voluntary groups that keep order without external authority. Either individualist (liberal) or socialist (rejecting private property).
- Kropotkin and Reclus (anarchist communists) were rediscovered by radical geographers.
- Kropotkin: long periods of human life were organised on co-operation and mutual support. Altruism is the lasting basis of social life and of ethics. Capitalist competition increases disparity and threatens survival, so return to co-operation and mutual aid (still practised in the family).
- Anarcho-radicals: "integrated labour" rather than division of labour. Several tasks in free associations, with means of production held in common in a decentralised society. Self-sufficient regions as "integrated cells" that exchange ideas and products equally. Grassroots democratic production decisions. Workplace and home close together. Many supported radically democratic, decentralised communism.
Criticism of radicalism ⭐
- Weak theoretical base: borrowed sophisticated ideas without much success.
- Drew on many sources, including anarchism. Aimed to turn society upside down but failed to change capitalism, and geography stayed a statistical regional science.
- Radical in topics and politics, but not in theory or method.
- Could not develop an integrated, dynamic population–resource model to remove regional inequality.
- Over-reliance on Marxism: evicted human agency, reducing people to passive "bearers" of structural determination. Man actually creates history.
- Gave priority to time over space. Critics: "just as there is a theory of history in historical materialism, there is also a geography". Humanists: liberate ourselves from "spaceless Marxist orthodoxy".
- No theory of uneven development. The focus on wage labour. The collapse of the USSR and Eastern Europe (1989–91) looked like capitalism's final victory and exposed the bureaucratic, oppressive character of real socialism.
- Removing social injustice and regional inequality in both capitalist and socialist societies is a gigantic task needing deeper thought and empirical research.
Author's conclusion: Geography cannot evolve through positivism alone or radicalism alone. It must return to its roots: the environment–society relationship within place, area, region or context, using an amalgam of quantitative and qualitative methods.