Basics ⭐⭐
- Proposed by: R.A. Daly (Canadian-born American geologist, Harvard).
- Book: Our Mobile Earth (1926).
- Aim: mainly to explain mountain building: their origin, repeated uplifts, pattern and direction.
- Force: gravity. Continents slide downhill towards the geosynclines.
- Much of the theory rests on assumptions (axioms) that Daly did not prove.
Assumptions ⭐⭐
- A solid primitive crust formed soon after the earth began.
- Ancient rigid masses formed three belts: north polar domes, equatorial domes, south polar domes.
- Between them lay depressed zones: the mid-latitude furrows and the primeval Pacific. These were the geosynclines. The northern mid-latitude furrow was the Tethys.
- Domes sloped towards the furrows.
- Daly assumed the crust was heavier than the substratum below. This is wrong: density increases with depth.
Mechanism ⭐⭐⭐
- The crust, a poor conductor of heat, lost interior heat; the interior shrank and the crust collapsed onto it under the weight of water, sediments and gravity.
- Rivers carried sediment from the domes into the furrows and Pacific. The floors subsided.
- The sinking floors pushed sideways on the continental masses, so the domes grew higher and wider.
- Dense material flowed from under the oceans towards the domes to make up for the weight lost by the swelling domes.
- The oceanic floor was finally stressed beyond its strength and cracked. Support for the domes was removed.
- Large continental blocks slid towards the geosynclines, squeezing and folding the sediments into fold mountains.
- Broken blocks sank into the substratum and melted; the extra volume of molten rock pushed the mountains up further.
- More sliding means more folding and bigger mountains.
Explaining patterns ⭐⭐
Pattern | Explanation |
East–west ranges (Alps, Himalaya) | Polar and equatorial domes slid towards the Tethys furrow |
North–south ranges (Rockies, Andes) | Continents slid towards the Pacific |
Island arcs and festoons off Asia | The Asian mass slid towards the Pacific |
Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐
- The assumed density order (crust denser than substratum) is wrong; it contradicts seismology.
- Many guesses: why was the crust asymmetrical? Why did the domes slope to the furrows? How did the Pacific form?
- His "geosynclines" were whole oceans. These could never be filled with sediment, so no mountains would form.
- It ignores the size of the ocean and the amount of sediment; it expects mountains from every ocean.
- It does not explain how gravity's pull ends and the rupture of the floor begins.
- The land and sea were arranged to suit the theory.
- Wooldridge and Morgan: rejecting the idea completely may be premature, but the cause of the first "bulges" is not explained.
Memory tip: Daly = Domes Down-slide (gravity).