Feminist geography: new domains ⭐
- Initially closely tied to radical geography, with similar phases (from the mid-1970s).
- It opened new domains: (i) geographies of fear, (ii) geographies of nature, (iii) geographies of mobility, (iv) geography of development.
Domain | Key ideas |
Geographies of fear | Susan Smith (1987): women experience crime and fear of crime differently from men. They live in constant fear in urban areas, avoid city spaces at night, and lock themselves in. Public space is seen as dangerous and home as a safe sanctuary, yet most violence against women, especially rape, happens at home (private acts go unreported, while public ones are publicised). This mismatch between the geography of crime and the geography of fear reproduces gendered geographies of violence and fear |
Geographies of nature | Since the Renaissance, Western thought has associated women with nature. Gillian Rose's dualisms: Culture / Nature, Man / Woman, Masculine / Feminine, Reason / Emotion, Public / Private, Space / Place. Two feminist responses: (1) embrace the link, as in eco-feminism, to critique cold, rational masculinity (Merchant, 1989). Collard and Contrucci: woman's reproductive system links her to all living nature; she is "truly a child of nature". (2) Reject the link (implied) |
Geographies of mobility | From movements of the body to daily travel, seasonal, temporary and permanent migration. Men commute between home and work, while women make multi-purpose trips, so urban mobility differs. Walking through the city differs for men and women, and further by skin colour and ability. This challenged spatial science's "rational man". Work and travel reflect the spatiality of patriarchy and structural racism |
Geography of development | Until the 1970s, development theory ignored gender. Ester Boserup, Woman's Role in Economic Development (1970) ⭐: using UN statistics, she showed women's role in developing economies is far larger than recognised. Development brings specialisation of labour, a move from the family as the unit of production and consumption to a market economy |
- Research areas that followed: (i) women's oppression in society; (ii) sexism within geographical institutions; (iii) interpretations are context-bound and partial, not detached and universal; (iv) interconnections of economic, social and cultural life.
Making women visible: "geography of women"
- First task: make women visible. Two points:
- Women's experiences and perceptions differ from men's.
- Women have restricted access to opportunities, from paid jobs to services.
- An empirical tradition influenced by liberal feminism and welfare geography. It documented how caregiving and "housewife" roles, together with urban structure, housing design, transport access and childcare, constrain women's access to paid employment.
- Criticised for explaining inequality only through gender roles plus spatial constraint.
Women and Geography Study Group (WGSG) of the IBG ⭐
- 1984: Geography and Gender: An Introduction to Feminist Geography (Hutchinson), building on Hayford (1974) and Tivers (1978).
- The first sustained critique of human geography and a feminist alternative. Geography portrays humanity as "man and his environment", denying women's existence.
- Not just "add women": develop "an entirely different approach to geography as a whole". Feminist geography studies how socially created gender structures form and transform space, aiming to end gender inequality through social change.
- Three example topics:
- Feminist urban geography: the separation of the public sphere of waged work from the private sphere of home. Creating a new built environment is a feminist priority.
- Women's increased participation in the public sphere: workforce composition, employment patterns, regional inequality, best seen through everyday lives.
- Effects of separating home and waged work: unequal access to facilities and services.
- Research "not on people, but with them". Feminism challenges our personal, political and academic lives. Feminist geography became a fully theorised, socially engaged dimension of the discipline.
- Mid to late 1980s: divides opened (1) between feminist and masculinist radical geography, and (2) within feminist geography (post-structural and postmodern theory).
Approaches to feminist geography ⭐
- Geography of gender: spatial variation in gender relations, the construction of gendered identities in particular environments, and how nature relates to gendered distinctions.
- Harding (1986): the "trinity" of feminist epistemologies. Linda McDowell: three central concerns: space, place, nature (environment).
Approach | Meaning |
1. Feminist empiricist geography | The unfairness of women's exclusion, so equal rights. Maps women's subordination and variations in status worldwide (e.g. poverty of Black female-headed households). Objects to exclusion from public life justified by a "natural" link to home, childbirth and unpaid reproductive labour. Women are more spatially restricted because the environment is "man-made" (architecture, planning). Neglected issues: housing for single women, women's fear in cities, urban design |
2. Feminist standpoint theory | Women making their own geographies, examined through their responses to landscape. Anti-rationalist / radical: rejects the rationalist vision of equality and valorises female difference and female knowledge |
3. Postmodern / post-rational feminism | "Gender" itself implies an oppressive fiction of "woman" that ignores differences between and within women and other arenas of difference. Rejects both rationalist and anti-rationalist paradigms. "Woman" should be replaced by decentred, partial, fractured identities |
Gender and space
- The arrangement of space determines the status of women and men. Women's knowledge is reduced, which reproduces male power.
- Some women take up as little space as possible in public (unobtrusive body positioning). Different groups of women relate differently to space.
- Early work (late 1970s to early 1980s) modified Marxism or urban geography. The impetus came from women's movements (putting women first, making them visible). In the 1980s, broader feminist theory entered.
Feminist research and data ⭐
- ILO statistic (frequently quoted): women are about 50% of the world's population, do two-thirds of the world's work hours, receive only 10% of world income, and own less than 1% of world property.
- Reliable data on women's paid and unpaid work is lacking, the biggest hurdle. Women were excluded from research for methodological reasons, or dropped when analysis became hard.
- Hence primary data (questionnaires and schedules) and qualitative methods: in-depth interviews, participant observation, micro-level ethnography. Inter-subjectivity rather than objectivity is the ideal.
- Feminist geography differentiated itself from "masculinist" geography, which erases women, through fierce critique.
- Participatory methods are complicated, restrictive, expensive, time-consuming and reflexive. For measuring inequality, a qualitative-cum-quantitative approach is best. They show solidarity with the oppressed, but marginalisation is embedded in the academy.
- Feminist geography must produce its own conceptions of space and nature from women's experience. Environmental concerns will get more attention.
Gender geography
- Sex is biological; gender is socially fabricated (appropriate behaviour for each sex).
- Male-constructed space makes women feel unsafe: secluded woodland, dark alleys, ill-lit roads, multi-storey car parks.
- Gender geography = the study of how genders and geographies are mutually constituted, the spatial distribution of women and the processes that make them "less adventurous" than men. It is missing at all scales from body to world economy.
- Women's subordination is omnipresent. No significant society has produced male subordination. Women's work is valued less, and women have less access to social, economic and political power.
- Foord and Gregson (1986) (Antipode): "Patriarchy: Towards a Reconceptualisation". Two genders are basic. They asked "Under what conditions do men and women require each other's existence?" and answered biological reproduction and heterosexuality. Criticised for biologism (fixed heterosexuality) and for failing to theorise how capitalism structures gender.
Explanations of the geography of gender
- Explanations range from reproduction to production.
- Sexual asymmetry is nearly universal among primates. Among humans the male can coerce the female (one definition of patriarchy).
- J.S. Mill: subordination rests on "the law of the strongest": achieved by force, it remains a kind of slavery that distorts female personality. Its origin was physical, its maintenance social, and technical change could free women.
- Collins (1971–75): male strength used through violence for sexual gratification. Changing political and economic conditions alter female bargaining power (access to resources, role of force).
- Children as labour power: societies are shaped by institutions that expropriate women's fecundity. A woman's value lies in her reproductive capacity, which is stringently controlled in low-technology agrarian societies with high labour demand. The spatial transfer of women to the husband's group (patrilocality) is a major cause of female powerlessness.
- Children as genetic survival: Engels (1884): the family rests on male supremacy to produce children of undisputed paternity. Dickemann: in stratified societies women marry up (hypergamy), so families care about chastity and reputation, and competition can intensify seclusion and purdah.
- Marriage transfers: Jack Goody (1976): dowry and bridewealth systems have pervasive social effects and strong regional patterns. In developed countries, rising awareness and education mean women seek parity, and divorce rates are high (e.g. Russia, Belarus, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Hungary, Romania, Ukraine).
- Sexual division of labour: from women's roles in production and reproduction.
- One explanation: compatibility with childcare and breastfeeding. Lactating women avoid distant or dangerous tasks, leaving men the early stages of production (extraction, land clearing) while women do secondary processing and harvesting. Men's mobility gives dominance. But many women do "incompatible" work, so neither strength nor lactation fully explains it.
- Engels's history: communal, egalitarian societies (women dominant) → private property (domesticated animals) → women work for husbands, not society, so the division becomes exploitative. With capitalism, production and reproduction are spatially separated and the home becomes the locale of reproduction.
Gender roles in economic activity
- Almost all men aged about 25–55 are in the labour force. Women may be "economically inactive homemakers" or "active but invisible".
- Female participation (official figures) is higher in the First and Second Worlds, lower in the Third World: lowest in Islamic North Africa, SW Asia and South Asia, highest in SE Asia. Africa varies most: Angola very low vs Botswana 73%.
Women in the Third World
- Agrarian economies. No reliable wage-gap data. Legal rights may be irrelevant in practice (is abortion available? Is divorce affordable?).
- Education: literacy is a key life option, and women are more illiterate. Their choices of food, education, occupation, pay, migration, time, land and property are largely controlled by men.
- Intra-household power can be measured only through micro-level surveys: decision-making, control of resources, reproductive help, outside groups, and informal power (which may be significant).
- Widowhood: in parts of South Asia the bride was ideally one-third the husband's age, so early widowhood was common. For high-caste Hindu widows this meant "social death". Low-caste widows could remarry but lost property and children. Self-immolation (sati) was expected only of high castes. The childless widow fares worst, so there is pressure to bear children. Traditional provisions are disrupted by urbanisation.
- Marital breakdown: in Islamic societies divorce rates were relatively high, with male kin support now weakening, so divorced women in the Middle East, North Africa, Malaysia and Indonesia are entering the labour market. In Latin America divorced women were few and ostracised, but are increasing and working.
- Female-headed households: an estimated one-quarter to one-third of all households worldwide, through death, breakdown or male migration, or "naturally" (no permanent partner, or polygyny in West Africa).
- Marriage migration is important in Africa and Asia, and the resulting isolation shapes women's lives.
Female migration ⭐
- Migration greatly influences women's socio-economic status, but how sex selects migrants is unclear and varies in space and time.
- 19th-century England: women migrated more than men, especially over short distances (Ravenstein's law, commonly cited). Grigg (1977) explains it by the lack of rural jobs for women, demand for domestic servants, and moving after marriage. Men move when risks are greater and wives follow. Now in the West, men are more migratory.
- Developing countries: men outnumber women in rural–urban migration, except in Latin America and the Philippines, where women dominate. In Africa, women farm while men go to towns; women usually migrate to join husbands, though female urban migration is rising.
- India: little reliable data. The Census gives "streams" and reasons. Before WWII migration was free. Now both sexes move to metros and megacities for work.
"How women vanish": a hidden geography
- Half of humanity is overlooked: women are counted as "inactive homemakers" (subsistence food), or as too young or too old. Elise Boulding (1983): remarkable numbers are not counted at all. In the Third World, poor women work all the time. Female participation statistics have poor comparability.
- Inconsistencies in part-time and informal work. Domestic service is mostly female, but partly male in India and Africa. "Unpaid family workers" (non-domestic work for at least one-third of normal hours) are often not counted, though an important part of the informal sector.
- Time poverty: a double or triple burden: fuelwood, water, housework, childcare, cooking and farm labour. Rural women work far longer days than men.
- Needed: household and individual-level research on motivations, set in structural research on changing production relations and the growth of mass markets in Asia and Africa.
- Humans uniquely combine a sexual division of labour, sharing, authority and ingenuity: "our species possesses the capacity to carry sexual inequality to its greatest extremes, but also the potential to realise unusual social equality between the sexes."
New International Division of Labour (NIDL) ⭐
- "World market factories": standardised, repetitive, low-skill, labour-intensive production. The majority of workers are young women. Domestic work trained them in "manual dexterity", and gender subordination makes them docile, subservient and cheap.
- Electronics: stress, fatigue, eyesight deterioration (eye trouble double among microscope users), eye, ear, nose and throat, musculoskeletal and sleep problems. Chemicals bring menstrual problems, pregnancy problems and infertility. Shift work brings sleep, gastrointestinal, nervous and psychological complaints.
- Sharp gender division: management, supervision and maintenance are male; production tasks are female, because "women are delicate by nature". Women are seen as docile second earners.
Regional geography of gender
- Women are invisible in geographic literature almost everywhere. We need a regional geography of gender:
- How aspects of life vary worldwide (data for women is poor).
- How countries are incorporated into the world economy and how this links to their social structure, including the construction of gender.
- Micro-locality studies (household and individual) to build macro studies.
- Aim: not only describe regional variations in women's status and political empowerment, but explain their causes.