Meaning ⭐⭐⭐
- A cycle of erosion is the time in which an uplifted landmass is worn down by exogenetic agents, passing through stages, until it becomes a low, almost flat plain (a peneplain).
- Endogenetic forces raise the land; exogenetic forces wear it down.
- Davis's definition: the geographical cycle is "the period of time during which an uplifted landmass undergoes its transformation by land sculpture, ending in a low featureless plain, a peneplain".
How the idea developed ⭐⭐
Who | When | Idea |
James Hutton | 1785 | Earth history is cyclic: "no vestige of a beginning, no prospect of an end". Led to uniformitarianism: "the present is the key to the past" (phrase popularised by Lyell) |
G.K. Gilbert | 1870s | Graded streams |
W.M. Davis (USA) | 1899 | Geographical cycle (first general theory of landform development); earlier "complete cycle of river life" (1889) |
Walther Penck (Germany) | 1924 | Rejected Davis's stages; landforms depend on the ratio of uplift to erosion |
C.H. Crickmay | 1933 | Lateral planation gives a panplain rather than a peneplain |
L.C. King | 1950s | Pediplanation: parallel retreat of slopes gives a pediplain (Africa, dry and savanna lands) |
Strahler, Hack, Chorley | 1950–62 | Dynamic equilibrium: landforms are time-independent, adjusted to present processes |
- Davis's idea was extended to other agents: arid (Davis 1905), glacial (Davis), marine (Johnson 1919), karst (Cvijic 1918) and periglacial (Peltier 1950) cycles.
- Davis's model dominated geomorphology from 1899 to about 1950.
Davis vs Penck ⭐⭐⭐
ㅤ | W.M. Davis | Walther Penck |
Key phrase | Landscape = f(structure, process, time/stage) ("trio of Davis") | Landforms reflect the rate of uplift vs rate of erosion |
Uplift | Rapid, short; then a long stable period | Slow at first, then faster, then slowing; uplift and erosion happen together |
Erosion starts | Only after uplift stops | During uplift |
Stages | Youth, maturity, old age (time-dependent) | Waxing, uniform, waning development (not "stages") |
Slopes | Slopes become gentler with time (slope decline) | Slopes keep their angle and move back (parallel retreat) / slope replacement |
Start surface | Uplifted land | Primarrumpf (low initial surface) |
End product | Peneplain with monadnocks | Endrumpf with inselbergs |
Slope form in youth | Convex | Convex (waxing) |
Interruptions ⭐⭐⭐
A full cycle needs a long period of crustal stability, which is rare. So cycles are often interrupted.
Kind | Cause | Effect |
Base-level change | Fall in base level (land uplift or sea-level fall) | Rejuvenation: cycle goes back to youth; cycle time is lengthened |
Base-level change | Rise in base level (land sinks or sea rises) | Rivers deposit more; cycle moves forward; cycle time is shortened |
Accident: volcanic | Lava floods bury the old surface and drainage | The old cycle ends; a new one starts. E.g. Deccan lavas (late Cretaceous) ended the earlier cycle on the Peninsula |
Accident: climatic | Big climate change (humid → arid or glacial) | The fluvial cycle is replaced by an arid or glacial cycle |
- Polycyclic (multicyclic) landscapes show the marks of more than one cycle: Appalachians (USA) and Chotanagpur (India). ⭐