Basics
- Proposed by: Pierre-Simon Laplace, French mathematician.
- Year: 1796, in Exposition of the World System (Exposition du système du monde).
- Type: Monistic; hot origin.
- A modified version of Kant's idea, given without mathematical formulation.
- Often called the Kant–Laplace hypothesis.
Assumptions (to remove Kant's defects)
- There was a huge, hot gaseous nebula (solves the problem of heat).
- It was already rotating (solves the problem of motion).
- It was cooling by radiation from its surface, and so contracting.
Main idea
- Cooling → contraction → smaller size → faster rotation (correct by conservation of angular momentum).
- At the equator, centrifugal force exceeded gravity and matter became weightless.
- One ring separated from the nebula (not nine, as in Kant).
- This ring split into nine rings; each condensed into a planet.
- Satellites formed from planets the same way. The remaining nucleus became the sun.
- Roche (mid-19th century) modified it: nine rings separated directly from the nebula.
- Explained why planets revolve in the same direction and nearly the same plane.
- Also implied the earth was first gaseous → liquid → solid crust.
- Accepted for over 150 years because of its simplicity. ⭐
Criticisms ⭐⭐
- No explanation for the origin of the nebula, its heat or its rotation.
- Why exactly nine rings and planets? A ring would more likely break into many small bodies.
- Weak cohesion means ring formation would be continuous, not intermittent (Wooldridge and Morgan).
- The sun should show an equatorial bulge where the ring separated; it does not.
- Liquid planets could not rotate and revolve properly.
- Some satellites of Jupiter and Saturn revolve in the opposite direction (retrograde).
- James Clerk Maxwell and James Jeans showed the ring's mass was too small to condense into planets.
- Cannot explain the distribution of angular momentum: the sun has ~99.9% of mass but ~1% of angular momentum. ⭐⭐