Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Nebular Hypothesis — Laplace (1796)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read4 sections

Nebular Hypothesis — Laplace (1796)

Basics

  • Proposed by: Pierre-Simon Laplace, French mathematician.
  • Year: 1796, in Exposition of the World System (Exposition du système du monde).
  • Type: Monistic; hot origin.
  • A modified version of Kant's idea, given without mathematical formulation.
  • Often called the Kant–Laplace hypothesis.

Assumptions (to remove Kant's defects)

  1. There was a huge, hot gaseous nebula (solves the problem of heat).
  1. It was already rotating (solves the problem of motion).
  1. It was cooling by radiation from its surface, and so contracting.

Main idea

  1. Cooling → contraction → smaller size → faster rotation (correct by conservation of angular momentum).
  1. At the equator, centrifugal force exceeded gravity and matter became weightless.
  1. One ring separated from the nebula (not nine, as in Kant).
  1. This ring split into nine rings; each condensed into a planet.
  1. Satellites formed from planets the same way. The remaining nucleus became the sun.
  • Roche (mid-19th century) modified it: nine rings separated directly from the nebula.
  • Explained why planets revolve in the same direction and nearly the same plane.
  • Also implied the earth was first gaseous → liquid → solid crust.
  • Accepted for over 150 years because of its simplicity. ⭐

Criticisms ⭐⭐

  1. No explanation for the origin of the nebula, its heat or its rotation.
  1. Why exactly nine rings and planets? A ring would more likely break into many small bodies.
  1. Weak cohesion means ring formation would be continuous, not intermittent (Wooldridge and Morgan).
  1. The sun should show an equatorial bulge where the ring separated; it does not.
  1. Liquid planets could not rotate and revolve properly.
  1. Some satellites of Jupiter and Saturn revolve in the opposite direction (retrograde).
  1. James Clerk Maxwell and James Jeans showed the ring's mass was too small to condense into planets.
  1. Cannot explain the distribution of angular momentum: the sun has ~99.9% of mass but ~1% of angular momentum. ⭐⭐