Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Development of Geomorphology

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

4 min read8 sections

Development of Geomorphology

Branches of physical geography

  • Physical geography began in the philosophical ideas of ancient thinkers in Greece, Rome and Egypt.
  • Earlier, physical geography covered only three components: lithosphere, hydrosphere and atmosphere. The biosphere was added recently.
  • Four branches and their spheres:
Branch
Sphere
Geomorphology
Lithosphere
Oceanography
Hydrosphere
Climatology
Atmosphere
Biogeography
Biosphere

Meaning and definition ⭐

  • The word comes from three Greek words: ge (earth), morphe (form) and logos (discourse).
  • Definition: Geomorphology is "the scientific study of surface features of the earth's surface involving interpretative description of landforms, their origin and development and nature and mechanism of geomorphological processes which evolve the landforms".
  • Its subject matter is organised by: (i) the dimension and scale of relief features, (ii) the processes that shape landforms, and (iii) the approaches to geomorphic study.
  • It needs basic structural and dynamic geology, because landforms depend on crustal materials (rocks) and on endogenetic forces.

Orders of relief ⭐⭐

Order
Features
Produced by
First order (macro)
Continents and ocean basins
Earth's origin and tectonics
Second order (meso)
Mountains, plateaus, plains, faults, rift valleys, folds
Endogenetic forces
Third order (micro)
Erosional and depositional landforms made by running water, groundwater, sea waves, wind, glaciers, periglacial agents
Exogenetic denudational processes
  • R.E. Horton (1945) introduced quantitative methods for the morphometric analysis of fluvially originated drainage basins. This began the shift to quantitative geomorphology. ⭐

Ancient period

Thinker
Dates
Contribution
Herodotus
485–425 BC
Named the depositional feature at a river's mouth a "delta". Said "Egypt is the gift of the Nile" ⭐
Aristotle
384–322 BC
Described features formed on limestone; origin of springs and streams
Strabo
54 BC–25 AD
The size of a delta depends on the nature of the rocks the river flows through
  • Dark Age (1st–4th century AD): no significant development after the fall of the Roman Empire.

Catastrophism vs uniformitarianism ⭐⭐

  • The academic silence of about 1400 years was broken by catastrophism: the belief that all animate and inanimate objects originated and evolved suddenly in a very short time.
  • Catastrophism was rejected by uniformitarianism.

James Hutton (1726–1797) ⭐⭐

  • Postulated uniformitarianism and the gradual, cyclic nature of earth history in the 18th century.
  • Basic tenet: the same geological processes that operate today operated in the past, so the history of geological events repeats in a cyclic manner.
  • "The present is the key to the past."
  • "No vestige of a beginning, no prospect of an end."
  • The first geologist to observe the cyclic nature of earth history.
  • His two disciples who developed and spread uniformitarianism: John Playfair (1748–1819) and Charles Lyell (1797–1873).

Geomorphology becomes independent

At the beginning of the 19th century, geomorphology became an independent discipline and a major branch of geology. Two schools emerged: the European School and the American School.

European School

Known for work on the Pleistocene Ice Age and glaciation, glacial erosion, marine erosion, fluvial processes, and arid and karst landscapes.
Person
Contribution
Louis Agassiz (1807–1873), Jean de Charpentier, John Playfair, Venetz, Esmark
Development of glacial geomorphology
Jean de Charpentier and Louis Agassiz
Concept of continental glaciers and ice ages
James Geikie
Book The Great Ice Age (1894). An ice age has several glacial periods separated by warm interglacial periods
A. Penck and Brückner ⭐
Identified four glacial periods of the Pleistocene: Günz, Mindel, Riss, Würm, separated by three interglacials
Sir Andrew Ramsay
Marine geomorphology
J. Walther, Passarge
Aeolian geomorphology
W. Penck
Cycle of erosion and slope replacement through Morphologische Analyse
Memory tip for the glacial periods (oldest to youngest): Günz → Mindel → Riss → Würm ("Go Make Rice Warm").

American School ⭐⭐

  • Made the maximum contributions to geomorphology.
  • 1875–1920 (the last two decades of the 19th century and the first two of the 20th) = the "golden age" of American and world geomorphology. In this period W.M. Davis gave the first general theory of landscape development.
  • Powell, Gilbert, Dutton and Davis made major contributions to subaerial denudation.
Geomorphologist
Dates
Contribution
Major J.W. Powell
1834–1902
Concept of the limit of maximum vertical erosion by streams, for which he proposed the term "base level". Base level is determined by sea level ⭐
G.K. Gilbert
1843–1918
Concept of dynamic equilibrium; introduced quantitative methods of landform analysis ⭐
W.M. Davis
1850–1934
Synthesised scattered American ideas into a coherent framework; first general theory of landscape development

W.M. Davis ⭐⭐

His general theory is a synthesis of three major concepts:
  1. "Complete cycle of river life" (1889): progressive development of erosional stream valleys.
  1. "Geographical cycle" (1899): sequential changes of landscapes through time, i.e. historical evolution of landforms (a time-dependent series of landforms) or cyclic development.
  1. "Slope evolution".
  • His model is time-dependent.
  • Other names for the geographical cycle used by his followers: normal cycle of erosion, geomorphic cycle, humid cycle.

The cycle of erosion applied to other processes ⭐⭐

Cycle
Proposed by (year)
Arid cycle
Davis (1903, 1905, 1930)
Glacial cycle
Davis (1900, 1906)
Marine cycle
Davis (1912); D.W. Johnson (1919)
Karst cycle
Beede (1911); Cvijić (1918)
Periglacial cycle
Peltier (1950)

British School: denudation chronology ⭐

  • Davis's idea of the historical evolution of landscape became the basis of denudation chronology and erosion surfaces in the UK.
  • The British school studied landscape development in historical (chronological) perspective, based on the concept of palimpsest.

German criticism: W. Penck ⭐

  • Critics of Davis focused on his assumption of rapid and erosionless uplift.
  • W. Penck, through his "morphological analysis" and "morphological system", tried to reconstruct past crustal movements from exogenetic processes and landform characteristics.
  • He postulated time-independent landscape evolution. (Davis = time-dependent; Penck = time-independent.)

Climatic geomorphology ⭐

  • Developed in France and Germany.
  • Basic tenet: "each climatic type produces its own characteristic assemblage of landforms".
  • Contributors: Sauer (1925), Wentworth (1928), Sapper (1935), Friese (1935), Büdel (1944, 1948), L.C. Peltier (1950), Tricart and Cailleux.

Post-1950 trends ⭐⭐

From (old)
To (new)
Davisian cyclic model
Non-cyclic (dynamic equilibrium) model
Descriptive (qualitative) geomorphology
Quantitative geomorphology
Inductive method
Deductive method
—
Models and the systems approach
Form geomorphology
Process geomorphology
Evolution theory
Functional theory
Large spatial (mega-geomorphology) and long temporal scale
Small spatial and short temporal scale (micro-geomorphology)
  • New branches: process, climatic, applied and environmental geomorphology. Environmental geomorphology emerged as a new branch.
  • 1950–60: mainly quantitative study; theory took a back seat.
  • The rejection of the Davisian cyclic model led to the dynamic equilibrium theory by J.T. Hack, R.J. Chorley and others. It could not fully fill the "conceptual vacuum".
  • The most outstanding contribution: replacing form geomorphology with process geomorphology and evolution theory with functional theory.

Alternative recent theories ⭐

Model
Proposed by
Geomorphic threshold model
S.A. Schumm
Tectonic geomorphic model
M. Morisawa
Episodic erosion model
S.A. Schumm

Indian centres of geomorphology ⭐

  1. Allahabad University
  1. Calcutta University
  1. Poona University
  1. Central Arid Zone Research Institute (CAZRI), Jodhpur