Basics ⭐⭐
- Proposed by: Alfred Wegener, German, primarily a meteorologist.
- Year: first presented in 1912.
- Book: Die Entstehung der Kontinente und Ozeane (first edition 1915; the 1922 edition was translated into English in 1924 as The Origin of Continents and Oceans).
- Built on evidence from geology, palaeoclimatology, palaeontology, palaeobotany and geophysics.
Aim ⭐⭐⭐
- To explain major climatic changes in the earth's past (e.g. Carboniferous glaciation of the southern continents).
- Two possibilities: either the continents stayed fixed and climate zones shifted, or climate zones stayed fixed and the continents moved.
- Wegener chose the second and rejected the permanency of continents.
Basic premise
- Followed Suess: three layers, sial, sima, nife.
- Sial exists only in the continents; the ocean floor is the upper part of sima.
- Continents (sial) float on sima without friction.
Pangaea ⭐⭐⭐
- In the Carboniferous, all land was joined in one supercontinent: Pangaea.
- Pangaea was surrounded by a huge ocean: Panthalassa (the ancestral Pacific).
- Northern part: Laurasia (Angaraland) = North America, Europe, Asia.
- Southern part: Gondwanaland = South America, Africa, Madagascar, Peninsular India, Australia, Antarctica.
- The South Pole lay near Durban (Natal, South Africa) in the Carboniferous.
- Wegener's account starts from the Carboniferous; he did not describe earlier times.
Evidence for Pangaea ⭐⭐⭐
- Jig-saw fit: the two coasts of the Atlantic fit together like cut pieces of wood (especially South America and Africa).
- Matching mountains: Caledonian and Hercynian ranges on both sides of the Atlantic match; the Appalachians match the mountains of Ireland, Wales and NW Europe.
- Matching geology: Du Toit found the rocks of eastern South America and western Africa similar. (Because of continental shelves, a gap of about 400–800 km would remain.)
- Matching fossils and plants on both sides of the South Atlantic.
- Geodetic evidence: Greenland was reported drifting west (about 20 cm/year); sea-floor spreading later confirmed continental movement.
- Lemmings of northern Scandinavia run westward when numbers rise and drown in the sea, suggesting an old land link to the west.
- Glossopteris flora is found in India, South Africa, Australia, Antarctica and the Falklands.
- Carboniferous glaciation of Brazil, the Falklands, South Africa, Peninsular India, Australia and Antarctica.
Forces of drift ⭐⭐⭐
Direction | Force |
Equatorward ("flight from the poles", Polflucht) | Differential gravitational force and buoyancy: because the earth is an ellipsoid, the centre of buoyancy and centre of gravity of a floating block are not in line, so the resultant pushes it towards the equator |
Westward | Tidal force of the sun and the moon, dragging the crust westward over the interior |
How the continents drifted ⭐⭐
- Break-up began in the Carboniferous.
- Pangaea split into Laurasia (Angaraland) in the north and Gondwanaland in the south. The sea between them was the Tethys Sea ("opening of the Tethys").
- Gondwanaland broke up in the Cretaceous: Peninsular India, Madagascar, Australia and Antarctica separated.
- North America broke from Laurasia and South America from Africa; both moved west, forming the Atlantic. They moved at different speeds, giving the Atlantic its S-shape.
- India moved north, forming the Indian Ocean.
- Movement away from the North Pole formed the Arctic Ocean and North Sea.
- What remained of Panthalassa became the Pacific Ocean.
- Drift continued until the Pliocene, when the present pattern was reached.
Shifting of poles and equator
Period | North Pole | South Pole |
Silurian | 14°N, 124°W | North-west of Madagascar |
Carboniferous | 16°N, 147°W | Near Durban (Natal) |
Tertiary | 51°N, 153°W | Near 53°S, south of Africa |
- The equator lay north of Norway in the Silurian, passed through London in the Carboniferous, and through the European Alps in the Tertiary.
Other problems Wegener explained ⭐
- Fold mountains: the front edges of the westward-moving Americas crumpled against the sima, forming the Rockies and Andes. Equatorward movement of Eurasia, Africa and India folded the Alpine ranges (the equator was in the Tethys then).
- Island arcs and festoons: the trailing eastern edge of Asia lagged behind as Asia moved west, leaving Sakhalin, Kuril, Japan, Philippines. Similarly the Americas left the West Indies and the Southern Antilles arc.
- Carboniferous glaciation: the South Pole lay in the middle of Pangaea, so ice spread over the then-joined southern lands; they later drifted apart. Glossopteris spread the same way.
Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐
- Forces too weak. The tidal force would need to be about 10,000 million times stronger, and would then stop the earth's rotation within a year. Buoyancy and gravity forces, if that strong, would have piled all continents at the equator.
- Self-contradiction: sial floats on sima without friction, yet mountains form because sima resists the moving sial. Willis: if sima is more rigid than sial, no compression can form the Rockies and Andes. Bowie: sima has no strength to crumple sial.
- The two Atlantic coasts do not fit exactly.
- Did not explain the direction and sequence of drift, or events before the Carboniferous. Why did Pangaea stay together until the Mesozoic?
- Wooldridge and Morgan: Wegener argued "as an advocate" rather than an impartial scientist.
Importance
- Most details were rejected, but the central idea of horizontal movement of continents survived and led to plate tectonics after 1960.
- Wooldridge and Morgan: for mountain building, drift "solves more difficulties than it creates".