Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Continental Drift Theory — Alfred Wegener (1912)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

4 min read10 sections

Continental Drift Theory — Alfred Wegener (1912)

Basics ⭐⭐

  • Proposed by: Alfred Wegener, German, primarily a meteorologist.
  • Year: first presented in 1912.
  • Book: Die Entstehung der Kontinente und Ozeane (first edition 1915; the 1922 edition was translated into English in 1924 as The Origin of Continents and Oceans).
  • Built on evidence from geology, palaeoclimatology, palaeontology, palaeobotany and geophysics.

Aim ⭐⭐⭐

  • To explain major climatic changes in the earth's past (e.g. Carboniferous glaciation of the southern continents).
  • Two possibilities: either the continents stayed fixed and climate zones shifted, or climate zones stayed fixed and the continents moved.
  • Wegener chose the second and rejected the permanency of continents.

Basic premise

  • Followed Suess: three layers, sial, sima, nife.
  • Sial exists only in the continents; the ocean floor is the upper part of sima.
  • Continents (sial) float on sima without friction.

Pangaea ⭐⭐⭐

  • In the Carboniferous, all land was joined in one supercontinent: Pangaea.
  • Pangaea was surrounded by a huge ocean: Panthalassa (the ancestral Pacific).
  • Northern part: Laurasia (Angaraland) = North America, Europe, Asia.
  • Southern part: Gondwanaland = South America, Africa, Madagascar, Peninsular India, Australia, Antarctica.
  • The South Pole lay near Durban (Natal, South Africa) in the Carboniferous.
  • Wegener's account starts from the Carboniferous; he did not describe earlier times.

Evidence for Pangaea ⭐⭐⭐

  1. Jig-saw fit: the two coasts of the Atlantic fit together like cut pieces of wood (especially South America and Africa).
  1. Matching mountains: Caledonian and Hercynian ranges on both sides of the Atlantic match; the Appalachians match the mountains of Ireland, Wales and NW Europe.
  1. Matching geology: Du Toit found the rocks of eastern South America and western Africa similar. (Because of continental shelves, a gap of about 400–800 km would remain.)
  1. Matching fossils and plants on both sides of the South Atlantic.
  1. Geodetic evidence: Greenland was reported drifting west (about 20 cm/year); sea-floor spreading later confirmed continental movement.
  1. Lemmings of northern Scandinavia run westward when numbers rise and drown in the sea, suggesting an old land link to the west.
  1. Glossopteris flora is found in India, South Africa, Australia, Antarctica and the Falklands.
  1. Carboniferous glaciation of Brazil, the Falklands, South Africa, Peninsular India, Australia and Antarctica.

Forces of drift ⭐⭐⭐

Direction
Force
Equatorward ("flight from the poles", Polflucht)
Differential gravitational force and buoyancy: because the earth is an ellipsoid, the centre of buoyancy and centre of gravity of a floating block are not in line, so the resultant pushes it towards the equator
Westward
Tidal force of the sun and the moon, dragging the crust westward over the interior

How the continents drifted ⭐⭐

  1. Break-up began in the Carboniferous.
  1. Pangaea split into Laurasia (Angaraland) in the north and Gondwanaland in the south. The sea between them was the Tethys Sea ("opening of the Tethys").
  1. Gondwanaland broke up in the Cretaceous: Peninsular India, Madagascar, Australia and Antarctica separated.
  1. North America broke from Laurasia and South America from Africa; both moved west, forming the Atlantic. They moved at different speeds, giving the Atlantic its S-shape.
  1. India moved north, forming the Indian Ocean.
  1. Movement away from the North Pole formed the Arctic Ocean and North Sea.
  1. What remained of Panthalassa became the Pacific Ocean.
  1. Drift continued until the Pliocene, when the present pattern was reached.

Shifting of poles and equator

Period
North Pole
South Pole
Silurian
14°N, 124°W
North-west of Madagascar
Carboniferous
16°N, 147°W
Near Durban (Natal)
Tertiary
51°N, 153°W
Near 53°S, south of Africa
  • The equator lay north of Norway in the Silurian, passed through London in the Carboniferous, and through the European Alps in the Tertiary.

Other problems Wegener explained ⭐

  • Fold mountains: the front edges of the westward-moving Americas crumpled against the sima, forming the Rockies and Andes. Equatorward movement of Eurasia, Africa and India folded the Alpine ranges (the equator was in the Tethys then).
  • Island arcs and festoons: the trailing eastern edge of Asia lagged behind as Asia moved west, leaving Sakhalin, Kuril, Japan, Philippines. Similarly the Americas left the West Indies and the Southern Antilles arc.
  • Carboniferous glaciation: the South Pole lay in the middle of Pangaea, so ice spread over the then-joined southern lands; they later drifted apart. Glossopteris spread the same way.

Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐

  1. Forces too weak. The tidal force would need to be about 10,000 million times stronger, and would then stop the earth's rotation within a year. Buoyancy and gravity forces, if that strong, would have piled all continents at the equator.
  1. Self-contradiction: sial floats on sima without friction, yet mountains form because sima resists the moving sial. Willis: if sima is more rigid than sial, no compression can form the Rockies and Andes. Bowie: sima has no strength to crumple sial.
  1. The two Atlantic coasts do not fit exactly.
  1. Did not explain the direction and sequence of drift, or events before the Carboniferous. Why did Pangaea stay together until the Mesozoic?
  1. Wooldridge and Morgan: Wegener argued "as an advocate" rather than an impartial scientist.

Importance

  • Most details were rejected, but the central idea of horizontal movement of continents survived and led to plate tectonics after 1960.
  • Wooldridge and Morgan: for mountain building, drift "solves more difficulties than it creates".