Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Thermal Contraction Theory — Jeffreys

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read5 sections

Thermal Contraction Theory — Jeffreys

Basics ⭐⭐

  • Proposed by: Sir Harold Jeffreys, British geophysicist (1920s; his book The Earth, first edition 1924).
  • Type: contraction theory, worked out with mathematics.
  • Aim: to explain continents, ocean basins, mountains, island arcs and festoons, but mainly the origin and distribution of mountain systems.
  • He rejected Wegener's drift because Wegener's forces (tides and gravity) seemed too weak.

Forces used ⭐⭐⭐

  1. Cooling of the earth: heat is lost by radiation from the surface, so the earth shrinks.
  1. Slowing of the earth's rotation: this reduces the equatorial bulge and adds to the contraction.

Mechanism ⭐⭐⭐

  1. The earth cools from the outside inwards. Cooling is effective only to about 700 km depth. The core stays hot and does not shrink.
  1. The outer layer cools and contracts first, then the layer below it, and so on. But the hot core obstructs the shrinking of the layers above it.
  1. Somewhere between lies the level of no strain: the layer whose contraction exactly fits the layer below it.
  1. Above the level of no strain, the layers are too big. They collapse onto the lower layers, the radius decreases, and horizontal compression buckles and folds the rocks. Result: mountains.
  1. Below the level of no strain, the layers are too short. They stretch and thin (tension), causing fractures and faults. Further collapse of the cooled outer layer raises the existing mountains higher.
  • Figures quoted: a 400 °C fall in temperature in the outer 400 km would shorten the earth's radius by about 20 km (circumference by about 130 km); maximum shortening of the crust about 200 km.

Other aspects ⭐⭐

Aspect
Jeffreys's view
Period of mountain building
Stresses build up until they exceed rock strength; then folding and faulting start. When the stresses weaken, mountain building stops. This gives long periods of quiescence between orogenies
Zones
Soft, elastic rocks are folded; hard, rigid rocks are broken into blocks (faults). So mountain building is localised
Direction of force
Cooling is greater below the oceanic crust, so the force acts from oceans towards continents
Direction of ranges
Ranges form along continental margins, parallel to oceans: Rockies and Andes ✔. The east–west Alps and Himalaya ✘ cannot be explained

Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐

  1. Contraction from cooling is too small to explain the major relief. Holmes: the calculated reduction in area falls far short.
  1. The idea of the earth cooling in concentric shells is wrong.
  1. The effect of slower rotation was inadequate (Steers).
  1. Contraction about 200 million years ago could not be so large as to form the Tertiary giants.
  1. A uniformly shrinking earth should have evenly spread continents and oceans, but they are uneven.
  1. It cannot explain the Alps and Himalaya (east–west).
  1. Contraction would give many small wrinkles (like a shrivelled apple), not great ranges.
  1. Mountains would be formed everywhere, but they occur only in definite belts.
  1. Modern view: radioactive decay keeps adding heat inside the earth, and sea-floor spreading shows the crust is not simply shrinking.
Memory tip: Jeffreys = shrinking apple; "level of no strain" is the key phrase.