Basics ⭐⭐⭐
- Proposed by: William Morris Davis (1850–1934), American geomorphologist.
- Year: "The Geographical Cycle", 1899. Earlier idea: "complete cycle of river life" in The Rivers and Valleys of Pennsylvania (1889).
- Inspired by Hutton's cyclic earth history and Darwin's evolution: landforms develop through stages like a living thing.
- The first general theory of landform development; dominated geomorphology until about 1950.
- Aim: a systematic description and genetic classification of landforms.
- Designed for humid temperate regions with running water as the agent (hence the "normal" cycle).
- He built in Gilbert's graded stream and the idea of base level.
The "trio of Davis" ⭐⭐⭐
Landscape is a function of structure, process and time (stage).
Term | Meaning |
Structure | Rock type and structure (folds, faults, joints) |
Process | Agents of weathering and erosion (here running water) |
Time / stage | How far the landscape has developed: youth, maturity, old age |
Assumptions ⭐⭐
- Landforms result from the interaction of endogenetic and exogenetic forces.
- Landforms develop in an orderly sequence through time.
- Uplift is rapid and short.
- Erosion does not start until uplift is complete (the most criticised point).
- After uplift there is a long period of crustal stability.
- Streams cut down quickly until they are graded.
The model ⭐⭐⭐
- Upper curve = height of the divides (summits). Lower curve = height of the valley floors. The gap between them = relative relief.
- Base level (sea level) is the lowest limit to which a river can cut.
- The uplift phase is not counted as part of the cycle.
Stage | Divides (upper curve) | Valley floors (lower curve) | Relief | Valleys and slopes |
Youth | Unchanged; wide flat interfluves | Fall fast (down-cutting, pothole drilling) | Increases to the maximum | Deep, narrow V-shaped valleys, gorges, canyons; convex slopes; rapids and falls |
Maturity | Lowered fast | Fall slowly | Decreases | Lateral erosion; valleys widen; slopes become straight; rivers graded |
Old age (longest) | Lowered slowly to near base level | Almost no down-cutting | Very low | Broad flat valleys; concave slopes; peneplain with monadnocks |
- Old age lasts longer than youth and maturity together.
- Davis split each stage into early, middle and late.
- Details of each stage: see Normal Cycle of Erosion.
Merits ⭐⭐
- Simple and easy to apply.
- Written in a clear, persuasive style.
- Based on careful field observation.
- The first general theory since Hutton; brought together base level, graded streams (Gilbert) and the profile of equilibrium.
- Useful for both prediction and historical interpretation of landforms.
- Spawned arid, glacial, marine and karst cycles.
Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐
- Rapid uplift is unrealistic; plate tectonics shows uplift is slow and long-continued.
- Erosion cannot wait for uplift to finish; it starts as soon as land rises. (Davis replied that he left it out to keep the model simple, and because erosion during uplift is small.)
- A long period of crustal stability is unlikely; plates are always moving. (Davis replied that the cycle would then be interrupted and a new one would start.)
- Penck: too much weight on time; landforms depend on the ratio of uplift to erosion, not on stage.
- Strahler, Hack, Chorley: landforms are in dynamic equilibrium with present processes and are time-independent.
- Few true peneplains exist; the model ignores climate change and varied rock.
- Despite this, later models (King's pediplanation, Crickmay's panplanation) are largely modified versions of Davis's model.