Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Geographical Cycle — W.M. Davis (1899)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read6 sections

Geographical Cycle — W.M. Davis (1899)

Basics ⭐⭐⭐

  • Proposed by: William Morris Davis (1850–1934), American geomorphologist.
  • Year: "The Geographical Cycle", 1899. Earlier idea: "complete cycle of river life" in The Rivers and Valleys of Pennsylvania (1889).
  • Inspired by Hutton's cyclic earth history and Darwin's evolution: landforms develop through stages like a living thing.
  • The first general theory of landform development; dominated geomorphology until about 1950.
  • Aim: a systematic description and genetic classification of landforms.
  • Designed for humid temperate regions with running water as the agent (hence the "normal" cycle).
  • He built in Gilbert's graded stream and the idea of base level.

The "trio of Davis" ⭐⭐⭐

Landscape is a function of structure, process and time (stage).
Term
Meaning
Structure
Rock type and structure (folds, faults, joints)
Process
Agents of weathering and erosion (here running water)
Time / stage
How far the landscape has developed: youth, maturity, old age

Assumptions ⭐⭐

  1. Landforms result from the interaction of endogenetic and exogenetic forces.
  1. Landforms develop in an orderly sequence through time.
  1. Uplift is rapid and short.
  1. Erosion does not start until uplift is complete (the most criticised point).
  1. After uplift there is a long period of crustal stability.
  1. Streams cut down quickly until they are graded.

The model ⭐⭐⭐

Davis's geographical cycle: upper curve (divides) and lower curve (valley floors) through time
Davis's geographical cycle: upper curve (divides) and lower curve (valley floors) through time
  • Upper curve = height of the divides (summits). Lower curve = height of the valley floors. The gap between them = relative relief.
  • Base level (sea level) is the lowest limit to which a river can cut.
  • The uplift phase is not counted as part of the cycle.
Stage
Divides (upper curve)
Valley floors (lower curve)
Relief
Valleys and slopes
Youth
Unchanged; wide flat interfluves
Fall fast (down-cutting, pothole drilling)
Increases to the maximum
Deep, narrow V-shaped valleys, gorges, canyons; convex slopes; rapids and falls
Maturity
Lowered fast
Fall slowly
Decreases
Lateral erosion; valleys widen; slopes become straight; rivers graded
Old age (longest)
Lowered slowly to near base level
Almost no down-cutting
Very low
Broad flat valleys; concave slopes; peneplain with monadnocks
  • Old age lasts longer than youth and maturity together.
  • Davis split each stage into early, middle and late.

Merits ⭐⭐

  1. Simple and easy to apply.
  1. Written in a clear, persuasive style.
  1. Based on careful field observation.
  1. The first general theory since Hutton; brought together base level, graded streams (Gilbert) and the profile of equilibrium.
  1. Useful for both prediction and historical interpretation of landforms.
  1. Spawned arid, glacial, marine and karst cycles.

Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐

  1. Rapid uplift is unrealistic; plate tectonics shows uplift is slow and long-continued.
  1. Erosion cannot wait for uplift to finish; it starts as soon as land rises. (Davis replied that he left it out to keep the model simple, and because erosion during uplift is small.)
  1. A long period of crustal stability is unlikely; plates are always moving. (Davis replied that the cycle would then be interrupted and a new one would start.)
  1. Penck: too much weight on time; landforms depend on the ratio of uplift to erosion, not on stage.
  1. Strahler, Hack, Chorley: landforms are in dynamic equilibrium with present processes and are time-independent.
  1. Few true peneplains exist; the model ignores climate change and varied rock.
  • Despite this, later models (King's pediplanation, Crickmay's panplanation) are largely modified versions of Davis's model.