Basics ⭐⭐
- Proposed by: John Joly, Irish geologist and physicist.
- Book: Surface History of the Earth (1925). Also called the thermal cycle theory.
- Aim: the thermal history and structure of the earth, mountain building and drift.
- Force: expansion and contraction of the substratum caused by radioactive heat. This makes the sea advance (transgression) and retreat (regression) over continental margins.
Base of the theory ⭐⭐
- Sial (continents): density about 2.67. Sima (substratum, basalt): density about 3.0. Sial is mostly absent under the oceans.
- Radioactive elements (uranium, thorium) are more abundant in sial. Heat there escapes to the surface, so it does not build up.
- Under the oceans there is no sial to block heat, but heat still accumulates in the deeper sima.
- Joly took the sial layer as at most 30 km thick, giving about 1,050 °C at its base. The melting point of basalt is about 1,150 °C.
- Extra heat (latent heat of fusion) is needed to actually melt it. This takes about 33–56 million years.
The cycle ⭐⭐⭐
Phase | What happens |
Heating and melting: transgression | Sima melts and expands; the globe's radius increases. Sima becomes less dense, so continents sink into it. The sea spreads over the continental margins (transgression) and sediments pile up there: geosynclines. Ocean floors crack under tension; basalt rises to form oceanic islands. Tides drag continents westward (drift). Drift exposes hot sima, heat escapes, and melting stops |
Cooling: regression | Sima cools and re-solidifies; density rises; the radius shrinks. The sea withdraws from the margins (regression). Ocean beds contract and press sideways on the margin sediments, which are squeezed and folded. The vertical force of solidification raises the whole range |
- So mountains form along continental margins facing oceans. The largest ocean gives the greatest mountains (Rockies and Andes face the Pacific).
- One full cycle (solid → molten → solid) is a revolution. Mountain building alternates with long quiescent periods.
Criticisms ⭐⭐⭐
- Depends on radioactivity at depth, which is poorly known; the force may be too weak.
- Jeffreys: continental crust is at most about 16 km thick, not 30. Then the required 1,150 °C could not be reached and the whole mechanism fails.
- Regular cycles are not borne out. Mountain building was recurrent but not evenly spaced (Steers).
- It predicts mountains of the same age on both margins of a continent; this is not seen. (Greatest mountains facing the largest ocean is partly true.)
- Joly's geosynclines get sediment but do not subside, so they cannot explain the great thickness of sediments.
- Jeffreys: if radioactivity could melt the sima, it could not re-solidify.
Holmes vs Joly ⭐⭐
ㅤ | Holmes | Joly |
Energy source | Radioactive heat | Radioactive heat |
Use of the heat | Drives convection currents in the substratum | Melts and re-solidifies the substratum |
Link with sea | Geosyncline formed by converging currents | Geosyncline formed by sea transgression |
Fate of the idea | Vindicated by plate tectonics | Rejected |
Memory tip: Joly = Jelly: heat melts it, sea rises; it sets, sea falls and squeezes.