Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Binary Star Hypothesis — Russell (1937)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

1 min read4 sections

Binary Star Hypothesis — Russell (1937)

Basics

  • Proposed by: H.N. Russell, American astronomer.
  • Year: 1937.
  • Type: Binary star / three bodies.
  • Aim: to remove the defects of the tidal hypothesis (planet distances, angular momentum, heavy elements).

Main idea

  1. Besides the primitive sun, there was a companion star revolving around it.
  1. A third, giant approaching star came near the companion star (not the sun), moving in the opposite direction.
  1. Distance between the two stars: about 4.8–6.4 million km (48–64 lakh km). The sun was too far away to be affected.
  1. The giant star's tidal pull drew matter out of the companion star.
  1. This matter formed the planets. Planets close to each other pulled matter from one another, forming satellites.

Merit

  • Because matter came from a companion star far from the sun, it partly explains the large distances of planets and their angular momentum.

Criticisms ⭐

  1. Does not explain the fate of the rest of the companion star.
  1. The planets came under the sun's gravity, but the companion star, which was nearer, did not. This is a contradiction.
  1. Does not explain how the planets were captured by the sun.