1. Postmodernism ⭐⭐
Origin and meaning
- A recent movement in the humanities, philosophy, arts and social sciences.
- A reaction to "historicism" in modern thought. Historicism stresses biography (chronological narrative) and neglects spatiality.
- Edward Soja (1989) (Postmodern Geographies): historicism is an "over-developed historical contextualisation" of social life that submerges and marginalises the spatial imagination. Space is subordinated to time.
- In geography it stresses openness in enquiry, artistic experimentation and political empowerment. The modern/postmodern line is not clear. It is shorthand for a heterogeneous movement originating in architecture and literary theory.
- Michael Dear (1994): "Postmodernity is everywhere, from literature, design, art, architecture, philosophy, mass media, clothing style, to music and television. Postmodernism raises urgent questions about place, space and landscape in the production of social life."
- Social and historical processes are constituted differently in different places, so history does not flow the same everywhere. Postmodern novels show simultaneous events in different places (apparently chaotic). Postmodern architecture lacks a clear functional structure.
- The synchronicity problem: Darby: a series of geographical facts is harder to present than a sequence of historical facts. Juxtaposition in time is easier to convey in writing than juxtaposition in space.
Dear's three components (1986) ⭐
Component | Meaning |
(i) Postmodernism as style | From literature and literary criticism into design, film, art, photography and architecture. Promotes difference and non-conformity to structural imperatives. Criticised as superficial "gift-wrapping" (façade, colour, iconography), but style constitutes meaning and identity |
(ii) Postmodernism as method | The most enduring (Dear). Rejects universal truths and meta-theories that explain "the meaning of everything". No portrayal dominates another. Theories are incommensurable, and even reconciling them should be resisted. Deconstruction is the principal strategy: shows how the author's or reader's position (culture, class, gender) shapes a text. A destabilising method that doubts the authority of past traditions and praises loose alternative readings. Gunnar Olsson (1980) was the earliest and most skilful exponent of deconstruction in human geography |
(iii) Postmodernism as epoch | A historic era tied to the global economy and geopolitics: "the culture of late capitalism" (Jameson, commonly cited). A radical break with modernity, so "postmodernity". "New times" marked by difference: theorising contemporaneity, a mix of obsolete, current and emergent artefacts |
Implications for geography
- Emphasis on heterogeneity, particularity and uniqueness (Gregory, 1989). The New York Times quote: "the great lesson of the twentieth century is that all the great truths are false."
- Modernist spatial science sought order, while observation showed disorder, suggesting no universal theories (Barnes, 1996).
- Gregory: "there is more disorder in the world than appears at first sight … we need to go back to areal differentiation, but armed with a new theoretical sensitivity."
- "Post-paradigm": suspicious of any complete, comprehensive system. Rejects determinism, possibilism, positivism, structuralism, behaviouralism, humanism and the systems approach. A substantial critique of 1950s–80s geography.
- Hostile to totalising ambitions: no "global coherence" of social life, and opposed to structuralism, hence also called "post-structuralism". Not another humanism.
- A remarkable return to areal differentiation, but a return with a difference.
2. Time geography ⭐⭐
- Developed by Torsten Hägerstrand and associates at Lund University, Sweden (the Lund School).
- Time and space provide "room" for collateral processes. "Every situation is inevitably rooted in past situations."
- People have goals. To attain them they undertake projects (series of tasks).
- Based on naturalism: an essential unity of method between the natural and social sciences.
- Emphasises the continuity and connectedness of events in situations bounded in time and space, each mutually modified by co-existence.
- Analogous to Kant's physical classification (by time and space) vs logical classification (by kind): geography is space, history is time.
- Time and space are resources that constrain activity. Any movement traces a path through space and time (a lifeline):
- Horizontal axis = space. Vertical axis = time.
- Vertical line = staying in one place. Sloping lines = journeys. Horizontal lines are impossible for people (but almost possible for messages).
- Time–space prism: if a person cannot leave until time I and must return by time II, the prism between them shows the maximum reachable space.
- Notation from the demographers' Lexis–Becker diagrams.
Hägerstrand's web model: four propositions ⭐
- (a) Space and time are resources individuals draw on to realise projects.
- (b) Three constraints:
Constraint | Meaning | Example |
1. Capability constraints | Limits from physical capability and facilities commanded | About 8 hours' sleep per 24 hours. Means of transport limit movement. The prism contains feasible paths through accessible stations (farms, factories, schools, shops) |
2. Coupling constraints | Individuals and groups must be at particular places at stated times | Teachers and pupils at school. Limits free-time mobility. Define time–space "bundles" |
3. Authority (steering) constraints | Preclude people from certain places at certain times | Rules, laws, access restrictions |
- (c) The constraints are interactive, not additive. Together they set possibility boundaries for paths.
- (d) Within these templates, competition between projects for "free paths" and "open space–times" is the central problem, mediated by institutions that maintain time–space coherence (Hägerstrand 1973, 1975).
Landscape vs diorama
- "Landscape" (the "momentary thereness and relative location of all continuants") does not adequately include human bodies as keepers of memories, feelings and intentions and initiators of projects.
- Hägerstrand preferred "diorama" (a museum display of people and animals in their settings): all entities are in touch in a mixture produced by history, and situations evolve as aggregate outcomes, apart from the actors' intentions.
- Written before IT, instant global communication and virtual reality.
- Baker (1981): could help reorient geography.
- Criticism: empirical work has been illustrative, small-scale, short-term and individual-level, with little attention to institutional factors that shape people and decisions.
3. Postmodernism and feminism
- Along with race and ethnicity, gender is a main concern of postmodern literature.
- Feminist geography traces interconnections of daily life across economic, social and cultural geography. It emphasises gender inequality and the oppression of women in virtually all spheres, and seeks to uncover and counter it, including within the profession.
- Johnson (1989): recognise women's common experience of, and resistance to, oppression, and commit to end it so women can define and control themselves. Geographical practice is sexist, patriarchal and phallocentric.
- Gillian Rose (1993) (Feminism and Geography):
- Geography has historically been dominated by men.
- Women in the profession have been patronised, harassed and marginalised.
- Feminism remains "outside the project" of geography.
- Male domination shapes what counts as legitimate knowledge and who can produce it. Geography is "masculinist". Gender differences are human creations.
- Postmodern (post-rational) feminism: treating "women" as a single category lumps together very different groups. Powerful groups impose their interpretations of landscape and nature. Focus now includes race, class and sexual orientation, not just male–female difference.
Themes for postmodern human geography
- Moral philosophy, moral geographies and the geographer's morality: downplay the dominant economic focus in favour of the moral frameworks of life.
- Social differentiation: race, ethnicity, class, sexuality, age, health.
- Constructions and boundaries of the self: how individuals define themselves (using psychoanalytic literature, new to geography).
- Globality and territoriality: the location of people in spaces and places, and cultural practices.
- Society, culture and nature: the social construction of "nature" and "environment" and its role in solving environmental problems.