Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Concepts of Hayford and Bowie, Joly, Heiskanen and Holmes

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read4 sections

Concepts of Hayford and Bowie, Joly, Heiskanen and Holmes

Hayford and Bowie ⭐⭐

  • Very similar to Pratt.
  • There is a plane (level) of compensation where crustal parts are fully balanced, at a depth of about 100 km.
  • Above it, density varies with elevation: rocks under mountains are lighter than under the ocean floor. Below it, density is uniform sideways.
  • Columns of lighter rock stand higher; all columns exert equal pressure at the level of compensation.
  • Illustration: columns of different metals and ores with equal cross-section, floating in mercury, all reach the same level.
  • Bowie found Airy's and Pratt's views "similar but not the same".
  • Criticism: the crust is not made of vertical columns moving independently; it is made of horizontal layers.

Joly (1925) ⭐⭐

  • Rejected Hayford and Bowie's 100 km level: at that depth the heat would cause complete liquefaction.
  • Also rejected the idea of uniform density below the level: geological events would easily disturb it.
  • Proposed a zone of compensation about 16 km (10 miles) thick, lying below a shell of uniform density. Density varies within this zone.
  • So compensation is a zone, not a line.
  • Low-density parts of the zone are the downward projections of the light continental crust; high-density parts are filled with heavier substratum. This is closer to Airy's idea (floatation) than to Hayford and Bowie's.
  • Joly's freeboard-to-draught ratio: 1 : 8.

Heiskanen (1933) ⭐⭐

  • Combined Airy and Pratt.
  • Density varies within a column (it increases with depth, e.g. 2.70 g/cm³ at height and 2.76 g/cm³ at sea level) and between columns.
  • So density varies both vertically and horizontally.
  • His work helped revive Airy's idea.

Arthur Holmes ⭐⭐⭐

  • Close to Airy: higher columns stand high because light material extends deeper below them; lower columns have light material to a shallower depth.
  • A. Holmes and D.L. Holmes (1978): columns of the same area extend to the same depth, where each exerts about the same pressure regardless of surface height.
  • Level of equal pressure (isostatic compensation) at about 50 km below sea level, in areas long undisturbed.

Holmes's four columns (weight = density × thickness, summed)

Column
Layers
Total
Plateau 4 km high
54 km × 2.8 (all continental crust)
151.2
Plateau 1 km high
36 × 2.8 (crust) + 15 × 3.3 (mantle)
150.3
Plain at sea level
30 × 2.8 (crust) + 20 × 3.3 (mantle)
150.0
Ocean 5 km deep
5 × 1.03 (sea water) + 1 × 2.4 (sediment) + 5 × 2.9 (oceanic crust) + 39 × 3.3 (mantle)
150.75
  • All four weigh almost the same (150.0–151.2), so they are in isostatic balance.
  • The higher the land, the thicker the light crust beneath it (the Moho is deeper under plateaus).