Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Origin of the Earth

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

1 min read4 sections10 chapters

Origin of the Earth

Classification of views on the origin of the earth ⭐⭐

All planets are believed to have formed by the same process, so any theory of the solar system's origin also explains the earth's.

1. Religious concepts

  • No scientific basis, so they are rejected.
  • Archbishop Usher (1664, Annals of the World): the earth was created at 9 AM on 26 October 4004 BC.

2. Scientific concepts

(a) By temperature of the original matter
School
Idea
Hot origin
Earth formed from matter that was hot from the start, or became hot during formation (e.g. Laplace, Jeans)
Cold origin
Earth formed from matter that was cold; it heated later through radioactivity or pressure of overlying layers (e.g. Chamberlin, Schmidt)
(b) By number of heavenly bodies involved
Concept
Bodies
Hypotheses
Monistic (mono-parental)
One
Kant, Laplace
Dualistic (bi-parental)
Two
Chamberlin–Moulton, Jeans, Hoyle
Binary star / trihybrid
More than two
Russell, Jeffreys (collision)

All hypotheses at a glance ⭐⭐⭐

Hypothesis
Proposed by
Year
Type
One-line idea
Gaseous hypothesis
Immanuel Kant (German philosopher)
1755
Monistic
Cold particles collide → hot rotating nebula → 9 rings thrown off → planets
Nebular hypothesis
Laplace (French mathematician)
1796
Monistic
Hot rotating nebula cools and contracts → one ring separates → splits into 9 → planets
Collision hypothesis
Count de Buffon (French)
1749
Dualistic
A comet collided with the sun; forerunner of planetesimal hypothesis
Planetesimal hypothesis
T.C. Chamberlin and F.R. Moulton
1905
Dualistic
Intruding star pulls small cold particles (planetesimals) from proto-sun → accretion → planets
Tidal hypothesis
Sir James Jeans (British)
1919
Dualistic
Intruding star pulls a cigar-shaped filament from the sun → breaks into planets
Collision hypothesis (modified tidal)
Harold Jeffreys (British)
1929
Three bodies
Intruding star collides with sun's companion star → debris → planets
Binary star hypothesis
H.N. Russell (American astronomer)
1937
Three bodies
Giant star pulls matter from sun's companion star → planets
Inter-stellar dust hypothesis
Otto Schmidt (Russian)
1943
—
Sun captures dust and gas during galactic revolution → disc → planets
Supernova hypothesis
Fred Hoyle (Cambridge)
1946
Dualistic
Sun's companion star explodes as a supernova → gas disc → planets
Big Bang theory
(Lemaître, Gamow; developed 1950s–60s)
—
—
Universe began from a singularity and has been expanding since

The common test: angular momentum ⭐⭐

  • Angular momentum = mass × angular velocity × (radius)².
  • Law of conservation of angular momentum: the total angular momentum of an isolated system stays constant. So if a rotating body shrinks, it spins faster; if it expands, it spins slower.
  • In the solar system the sun has about 99.9% of the mass but only about 1% of the angular momentum; the planets have about 0.1% of the mass but over 99% of the angular momentum.
  • Most hypotheses fail because they cannot explain this distribution.

Sub-topics

Solar System
Gaseous Hypothesis — Kant (1755)
Nebular Hypothesis — Laplace (1796)
Planetesimal Hypothesis — Chamberlin and Moulton (1905)
Tidal Hypothesis — Jeans (1919) and Jeffreys (1929)
Binary Star Hypothesis — Russell (1937)
Supernova Hypothesis — Hoyle (1946)
Inter-stellar Dust Hypothesis — Otto Schmidt (1943)
Recent Theories and Big Bang Theory
Quick Revision — Origin of the Earth
Recommended reading order: Solar System → Kant → Laplace → Chamberlin–Moulton → Jeans–Jeffreys → Russell → Schmidt → Hoyle → Recent Theories and Big Bang → Quick Revision.