Classification of views on the origin of the earth ⭐⭐
All planets are believed to have formed by the same process, so any theory of the solar system's origin also explains the earth's.
1. Religious concepts
- No scientific basis, so they are rejected.
- Archbishop Usher (1664, Annals of the World): the earth was created at 9 AM on 26 October 4004 BC.
2. Scientific concepts
(a) By temperature of the original matter
School | Idea |
Hot origin | Earth formed from matter that was hot from the start, or became hot during formation (e.g. Laplace, Jeans) |
Cold origin | Earth formed from matter that was cold; it heated later through radioactivity or pressure of overlying layers (e.g. Chamberlin, Schmidt) |
(b) By number of heavenly bodies involved
Concept | Bodies | Hypotheses |
Monistic (mono-parental) | One | Kant, Laplace |
Dualistic (bi-parental) | Two | Chamberlin–Moulton, Jeans, Hoyle |
Binary star / trihybrid | More than two | Russell, Jeffreys (collision) |
All hypotheses at a glance ⭐⭐⭐
Hypothesis | Proposed by | Year | Type | One-line idea |
Gaseous hypothesis | Immanuel Kant (German philosopher) | 1755 | Monistic | Cold particles collide → hot rotating nebula → 9 rings thrown off → planets |
Nebular hypothesis | Laplace (French mathematician) | 1796 | Monistic | Hot rotating nebula cools and contracts → one ring separates → splits into 9 → planets |
Collision hypothesis | Count de Buffon (French) | 1749 | Dualistic | A comet collided with the sun; forerunner of planetesimal hypothesis |
Planetesimal hypothesis | T.C. Chamberlin and F.R. Moulton | 1905 | Dualistic | Intruding star pulls small cold particles (planetesimals) from proto-sun → accretion → planets |
Tidal hypothesis | Sir James Jeans (British) | 1919 | Dualistic | Intruding star pulls a cigar-shaped filament from the sun → breaks into planets |
Collision hypothesis (modified tidal) | Harold Jeffreys (British) | 1929 | Three bodies | Intruding star collides with sun's companion star → debris → planets |
Binary star hypothesis | H.N. Russell (American astronomer) | 1937 | Three bodies | Giant star pulls matter from sun's companion star → planets |
Inter-stellar dust hypothesis | Otto Schmidt (Russian) | 1943 | — | Sun captures dust and gas during galactic revolution → disc → planets |
Supernova hypothesis | Fred Hoyle (Cambridge) | 1946 | Dualistic | Sun's companion star explodes as a supernova → gas disc → planets |
Big Bang theory | (Lemaître, Gamow; developed 1950s–60s) | — | — | Universe began from a singularity and has been expanding since |
The common test: angular momentum ⭐⭐
- Angular momentum = mass × angular velocity × (radius)².
- Law of conservation of angular momentum: the total angular momentum of an isolated system stays constant. So if a rotating body shrinks, it spins faster; if it expands, it spins slower.
- In the solar system the sun has about 99.9% of the mass but only about 1% of the angular momentum; the planets have about 0.1% of the mass but over 99% of the angular momentum.
- Most hypotheses fail because they cannot explain this distribution.
Sub-topics
Solar SystemGaseous Hypothesis — Kant (1755)Nebular Hypothesis — Laplace (1796)Planetesimal Hypothesis — Chamberlin and Moulton (1905)Tidal Hypothesis — Jeans (1919) and Jeffreys (1929)Binary Star Hypothesis — Russell (1937)Supernova Hypothesis — Hoyle (1946)Inter-stellar Dust Hypothesis — Otto Schmidt (1943)Recent Theories and Big Bang TheoryQuick Revision — Origin of the EarthRecommended reading order: Solar System → Kant → Laplace → Chamberlin–Moulton → Jeans–Jeffreys → Russell → Schmidt → Hoyle → Recent Theories and Big Bang → Quick Revision.