Why the age is hard to fix
- Estimates of the earth's age by different methods differ widely; no single method is accepted by all.
- Geological processes are so slow that no one can observe them fully in a lifetime.
- James Hutton (1775): the earth's surface changes often, but so slowly that the dates are hard to find. Dating past events is "wildcatting", since there is "no vestige of a beginning, no prospect of an end".
- Accepted scientific age today: about 4.54 billion years (radiometric dating of meteorites and the oldest minerals).
All methods at a glance ⭐⭐⭐
Method | Basis | Result |
Religious | Scriptures and tradition | Usher: 4004 BC; Indian texts: ~1.97 billion years |
Oceanic salinity (Joly) | Total salt in oceans ÷ salt added each year | Oceans ~80 million years old |
Salinity + mountain-building cycles | Salt input varies with orogeny | Oceans 1500 my; earth 1875 million years |
Sedimentation | Total thickness of sedimentary rocks ÷ yearly rate | 0.5 to 6.3 billion years (varies by place) |
Erosion | Total erosion ÷ yearly rate | 10.56 billion years (too high) |
Tidal force of the moon | Moon's recession and slowing of earth's rotation | ~4 billion years |
Lord Kelvin | Rate of cooling of the earth | 40 million years (too low) |
Radioactivity | Decay of uranium/thorium to lead | 2–3 billion years (older figure); modern: 4.54 billion ⭐ |
Russell | Uranium–lead and thorium–lead | 2250 and 4600 million years |
Biological evolution | Time needed for evolution | ~1000 million years |
1. Religious concepts
Source | Age of the earth |
Old Iranian (Zoroastrian) priests | About 12,000 years |
Archbishop Usher (1664) | Created at 9 AM, 26 October 4004 BC |
Indian religious texts (Karmakand) | 1,972,949,032 years (about 2 billion years) |
- Based on guesswork; not accepted. The Indian figure is closest to scientific estimates but still short of the accepted 4–5 billion years.
2. Oceanic salinity ⭐⭐
- Assumption: oceans were fresh water at first; rivers have carried salt from land every year since.
- About 60% of the sodium in ocean salt comes from rivers.
- Age of the oceans = total salt in the oceans ÷ salt added per year.
- John Joly: total salt = 1.26 × 10²² g; yearly addition = 1.56 × 10¹⁴ g → oceans about 80 million years old.
- If the earth formed 40 million years before the oceans → 120 million years. Too young: 200-million-year-old oceanic crust has been dated by palaeomagnetism.
- Variant: salt input is high after each period of mountain building and falls as mountains wear down. On this basis oceans are 1500 million years old; adding a quarter (375 my) gives the earth 1875 million years.
Defects: total salt and yearly rate cannot be measured accurately; erosion varies in space and time; land is not the only source of salt (convection currents also bring salt from the oceanic crust).
3. Sedimentation ⭐⭐
- First igneous rocks broke down → sediments → first sedimentary rocks; sedimentation has continued since.
- Age of first sedimentary rocks = total thickness ÷ yearly rate of deposition.
- Known total thickness of sedimentary rocks: about 100 miles (160 km) = 528,000 ft.
- The earth is then taken as 2 or 3 times older than the first sedimentary rocks.
Example | Rate | First sediments | Earth (×3 / ×2) |
Statue of Ramses II, Egypt (found 1854) | 9 ft in 3000 years (3 ft / 1000 yr) | 176 million years | ~500 million (×3) — too low |
Colorado and Wyoming, USA | ½ mile in 6.5 million years | 1300 million years | 3.9 billion (×3) / 2.6 billion (×2) |
England | 1 ft in 4000 years | 2112 million years | 6.3 billion (×3) / 4.2 billion (×2) |
- Conclusion from this method: the earth is more than 2000 million years old.
Defects: rate varies by year, place, climate and rock type; older layers get compressed by the load above, so real thickness cannot be measured.
4. Erosion
- Land is lowered by about 1 ft in 10,000 years.
- 528,000 ft eroded → 5280 million years; doubled → 10,560 million (10.56 billion) years. Too high.
- Defects: erosion depends on lithology, structure, relief, vegetation, slope, climate, etc., so its rate cannot be fixed.
5. Tidal force of the moon
- Assumes the moon split off from the earth, starting very close, with maximum tidal friction.
- Method 1: from the rate at which tidal friction has decreased → about 4 billion years.
- Method 2: tidal friction slows the earth's rotation and pushes the moon away. Taking a recession of about 13 cm/year over today's distance of 3,84,000 km gives about 2.95 billion years; the estimate quoted is about 4 billion years. (Measured recession today is about 3.8 cm/year.)
- Defect: moon rocks from the Apollo missions (from 1969) are older than the oldest earth rocks, so the idea that the moon split from the earth is rejected, and this method fails.
6. Lord Kelvin: rate of cooling ⭐⭐
- Temperature rises with depth at about 1°C per 32 m; heat flows from the interior and is lost by radiation.
- From the temperature gradient, thermal conductivity of rocks and the earth's surface area, the rate of heat loss can be found.
- Assumed the earth solidified at 7,000°F → crust solidified about 40 million years ago.
- Defect: radioactivity was unknown then. Radioactive decay keeps adding heat, so the earth cools far more slowly than Kelvin assumed.
7. Radioactive elements (radiometric dating) ⭐⭐⭐
- The most reliable method.
- Pierre Curie (1903): radioactive elements give off heat.
- Rutherford (1904): proposed dating rocks by radioactivity.
- Uranium and thorium occur in all rocks and decay at a fixed rate into lead, giving off alpha particles.
- Measuring the uranium-to-lead ratio gives the rock's age. Older estimates: radioactive minerals existed at least 1500 million years ago; earth 2000–3000 million years.
- Modern radiometric dating gives 4.54 billion years.
8. Other estimates
- John Joly: pleochroic haloes (concentric rings) in mica; age from ring diameter and decay rate.
- H.N. Russell: uranium–lead 2250 million; thorium–lead 4600 million years. Earth: 2–5 billion years.
- Biologists: from evolution, about 1000 million years.