Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Landform Development — Walther Penck

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

1 min read4 sections

Landform Development — Walther Penck

Basics ⭐⭐

  • Walther Penck, German geomorphologist (son of Albrecht Penck).
  • Main work: Die morphologische Analyse ("Morphological Analysis"), published in 1924, after his death in 1923.
  • He rejected Davis's time-dependent stages and proposed a morphological system.
  • Core idea: landforms express the ratio between the rate of uplift (endogenetic) and the rate of erosion (exogenetic). Uplift and erosion act at the same time.
  • He is "the most misunderstood geomorphologist" because: he died young and left work unfinished; he wrote in difficult German with unclear terms; Davis's review misrepresented him; and some ideas seemed contradictory.

Terms ⭐⭐⭐

Penck's term
Meaning
Primarrumpf (Primärrumpf)
Initial, low, almost flat surface before uplift (a "primary peneplain")
Aufsteigende Entwicklung
Waxing (accelerating) development
Gleichförmige Entwicklung
Uniform development
Absteigende Entwicklung
Waning (decelerating) development
Piedmonttreppen
Piedmont benches: steps around a rising dome
Böschung
Steep upper gravity slope
Haldenhang
Gentle lower wash slope (talus slope)
Inselberg
Steep residual hill left by retreating slopes
Endrumpf
Final low surface (like Davis's peneplain)
Memory tip: Penck replaced Davis's youth, maturity, old age with waxing, uniform, waning.

The three phases ⭐⭐⭐

Phase
Uplift vs erosion
Altitude
Relief
Slopes
1. Waxing (aufsteigende)
Uplift starts slowly, then accelerates; uplift faster than down-cutting
Rises
Rises
Deep V-valleys; convex slopes; piedmont benches form around the dome
2. Uniform (gleichförmige)
Uplift and erosion balance; later uplift stops
Rises, then steady, then begins to fall
Constant
Straight slopes retreating parallel to themselves
3. Waning (absteigende)
No uplift; lateral erosion dominates
Falls
Falls
Steep Böschung above, gentle Haldenhang below; the wash slope grows at the expense of the gravity slope; inselbergs remain, then vanish → Endrumpf
  • Penck's pattern of uplift (slow start, acceleration, slowing, then rest) matches what is now known of many tectonic movements (Chorley).

Evaluation ⭐⭐

  • Criticised in the USA, just as Davis was criticised in Germany. Attacks focused on parallel retreat and continuous uplift.
  • Early English translations said he believed in parallel retreat; later ones suggest slope replacement (each slope unit replaced by a gentler one below). Much criticism came from mistranslation.
  • His tectonic speculations found little support, but his work on slope development and weathering is valuable.
  • His idea of parallel slope retreat was developed further by L.C. King (pediplanation).