1. Existentialism
Definition: The philosophical view that man is responsible for making his own nature. It stresses personal freedom, personal decision and personal commitment.
- It challenges, even abandons, purely objective, quantitative and deterministic analysis, and urges concern for human values, quality, subjectivity and spirituality. (Philosophers: Kierkegaard, Heidegger, Sartre; commonly cited.)
- Central concept: "existential space" (Samuels): the "assignment of space", a result of human reality.
- It tries (1) to restore the concrete, immediate experience of existence in situ to knowledge, and (2) to bridge subjective/objective, idealism/materialism, essence/existence.
- "Existence comes before essence": man first exists, encounters himself, surges up in the world, and defines himself afterwards. To understand man, begin with the subjective life. "Man is nothing else but that which he makes of himself."
- First principle: "once thrown into the world, man is responsible for everything he does". Man is free: "we are alone with no excuses".
- It rejects any view that makes man the product of his environment, so it provides a firm foundation for human geography.
- Existential logic: man expresses himself as a whole in even his most insignificant behaviour. Every taste, mannerism and act is revealing. The method deciphers that total expression, beginning with the subjective: "existential psychoanalysis".
- The method begins with the centres people occupy and how they define their relations with the world: an analysis of existential space.
- Existential geography = "biography of landscape" (Samuels):
- Analysis can run backward (from a landscape to the individuals or groups who made it) or forward (from people to landscape articulation). The aim is the source and meaning of a landscape.
- Scale: from individuals to societies, great figures and civilisations or ordinary people. "Every landscape is someone's existential space."
- A type of historical geography that reconstructs a landscape through the eyes of its occupants, users, explorers and students.
- For every landscape someone is responsible and accountable (individuals or groups, rational or irrational, well-intended or demonic). They make their choices and their landscapes.
- Merit: anthropocentric, greatest emphasis on the human core of existence, which widens the horizon of geographical research.
2. Idealism ⭐
Definition: Reality is mental or mind-dependent. The activity of mind is the foundation of human existence and knowledge.
- Opposed to naturalism and materialism. Mental activity has a life of its own, not controlled by material things. The world is known only indirectly through ideas.
- All knowledge rests on an individual's subjective experience: mental constructs and ideas. There is no "real" world knowable independent of mind.
- Leonard Guelke is the most celebrated advocate of idealism in geography (Historical Understanding in Geography: An Idealist Approach, 1982; commonly cited). Geographers can enter the minds of their subjects, rethink their thoughts and understand human intentions in changing the earth.
- Since behaviour is controlled by mind, social science and history are logically separate from the natural sciences. Rational human thought can be understood in a way material processes cannot.
- Verstehen = rethinking or reconstructing human activity to discover what really happened (opposed to the positivists' nomothetic approach). (R.G. Collingwood's "re-enactment" idea, commonly cited.)
- One can reconstruct the logical sequence of another's thought, though not re-experience their emotions. Geographers deal mostly with deliberate, rational actions (growing crops, building houses, exploiting resources), which are open to rethinking.
- Application: find the reasons for forest clearance, field patterns and settlement types. Cultural landscape patterns are not arbitrary; they reflect the thinking of their makers. This often needs historical research, because original purposes change:
- Victorian churches in England are now community halls and libraries.
- Old Indian forts are now tourist attractions.
- Studies activity in its overall cultural context. Idiographic: generalisations valid only for regions and peoples of broadly similar culture.
- Criticism: one can never know for sure that an explanation is true. Reply: this applies to all empirical and theoretical work. Even physics has a "history of abandoned theories". Re-interpretation with new evidence gradually gives a better account.
- Implication: a methodological separation of physical and human geography. Human geographers study the environment in terms of how cultures used it. Physical geographers study man as an agent of landscape change.
- Suits regional geography: group people who share a common culture or worldview, which shapes behaviour. Macro regions subdivided into meso and micro, differently for each region according to resource potential.
- Rational models (e.g. von Thünen's rational farmers around an isolated city) are close to idealist rethinking, and idealists accept such simplified models as aids to understanding.
- Natural-science methods reduced regional geography to systematic inventory and description (external relations like soil–settlement, climate–crops). Idealism moves beyond description to the meanings expressed in events.
- Emphasises the autonomy of social science. It contrasts with logical positivism.
3. Realism ⭐
Definition: Reality exists independent of the mind. It is antithetical to idealism. Gibson proposed realism as a viable alternative to idealism.
- Facts speak for themselves. Explanation is logical and inductive. It advocates theories and models. Close to positivism's objectivity, but with a different methodology of explanation.
- Core doctrine: human science is an empirically based rational enterprise that explains observable regularities by describing the hidden but "real" structures that causally generate them.
Evolution of realism
Phase | Idea |
Platonic–Socratic realism (vs nominalism) | Universals and abstract entities have real, objective existence. Plato's theory of ideas: particular forms we sense are mere appearance (the Himalayas will wear down to the ocean floor), but the universal "mountain" is fixed. Nominalists (Aristotelians): only particulars are real; "mountain" is a mere name |
Medieval scholastic realism | John Scot (Erigena), On the Division of Nature: divisions of the physical world signify something hidden. Cycles (seasons, astrology) prove a divine order; the ordinary world is not real |
19th-century "direct" or "naive" realism | Founder: Cook Wilson. A polemic against idealism. Nothing exists that is not observable in time and space. A commonsense logic: our views are constructed in the mind through interaction, via society, with the physical world. Influenced commercial and military geography since the Victorian period. Stamp's Land Utilisation Survey reflects its aims (social reform, national surveys). The 1960s QR = an extreme of naive realism, moving towards positivism |
New or critical realism | Propounded by T.P. Nunn (per the book). Anything we experience depends for its existence on being experienced. The objects of perception are actual properties of the physical world. (Critical realism in geography is associated with Roy Bhaskar and Andrew Sayer; commonly cited) |
Positivism vs realism ⭐
Positivism | Realism |
Asks "how" a pattern is produced | Asks "why": describes the causal processes generating patterns |
Logical (mathematical) necessity of regularity | Natural necessity: real cause and effect in nature and society |
Theory can be a logical conjecture or abstraction (a mathematical law); theories come from theoretical laws | More "commonsense" argument from analogy; theories come from problematic entities with assumed ontological status |
- Realists believe in "objects" (a physical world) existing independent of thought, which science can genuinely discover, and stress theories and models.
- (British trend: realism is now opposed to idealism. In Platonic thought it was opposed to nominalism.)