Match the hypothesis ⭐⭐⭐
Proposer | Hypothesis | Year | Key word |
Kant | Gaseous | 1755 | Cold particles, 9 rings |
Laplace | Nebular | 1796 | Hot nebula, one ring |
Buffon | Collision | 1749 | Comet hits sun |
Chamberlin and Moulton | Planetesimal | 1905 | Planetesimals, accretion |
James Jeans | Tidal | 1919 | Cigar-shaped filament |
Harold Jeffreys | Collision (modified tidal) | 1929 | Companion star smashed |
H.N. Russell | Binary star | 1937 | Companion star, approaching star |
Otto Schmidt | Inter-stellar dust | 1943 | Dust disc, galactic revolution |
von Weizsäcker | Revised nebular | 1944 | — |
Fred Hoyle | Supernova | 1946 | Exploding companion |
Kuiper | Protoplanet | 1949 | — |
Fesenkov | Globule | 1951 | — |
A.C. Banerjee | Cepheid | — | Indian (Allahabad) |
Drobyshevski | Jupiter–Sun binary | 1974 | — |
Easy-to-confuse points ⭐
- Kant = nebula expands and spins faster (wrong); nine rings.
- Laplace = nebula contracts and spins faster (right); one ring that splits into nine.
- Roche = nine rings separate directly from the nebula.
- Planetesimal = small cold solid particles; tidal = hot gaseous filament.
- Jeans: matter from the sun. Russell and Jeffreys: matter from the companion star.
- Hoyle: companion explodes (supernova). Schmidt: sun captures dust.
One-liners
- "Give me matter and I will build a world out of it" — Kant.
- First scientific hypothesis on the earth's origin — Kant's gaseous hypothesis.
- Kant's hypothesis fails the law of conservation of angular momentum.
- Laplace's book — Exposition of the World System (1796).
- Showed that the ring's mass was too small to form planets — Maxwell and Jeans.
- Planetesimal hypothesis is a revival of Buffon's collision hypothesis.
- Chamberlin was a geologist; Moulton an astronomer (University of Chicago).
- Three stages of earth's evolution — planetesimal accession, dominant vulcanism, geological period.
- Cigar-shaped filament — James Jeans.
- Grapefruit and 100 yards analogy — Hoyle (against tidal hypothesis).
- Encounter of stars is very unlikely — B. Levin.
- Supernova hypothesis described in The Nature of the Universe — Hoyle.
- Sun captured dust during galactic revolution — Otto Schmidt.
- Titius–Bode law — D = 0.4 + 0.3 × 2ⁿ.
- Sun has ~99.9% of mass but ~1% of angular momentum.
- Planets rotating in reverse (retrograde) — Venus and Uranus.
- Cepheid hypothesis — A.C. Banerjee.
- Big Bang starts from a singularity; confirmed by COBE.
- Earth created at 9 AM, 26 October 4004 BC — Archbishop Usher (religious view).