Basics
- Proposed by: Sir James Jeans, British scientist, 1919.
- Modified by: Harold Jeffreys, British scientist, 1929.
- Type: Dualistic (Jeans); three bodies (Jeffreys); hot origin.
- A popular modern hypothesis until the mid-20th century.
Assumptions
- The solar system formed from the sun and an intruding star.
- The primitive sun was a big incandescent gaseous mass, stationary but rotating.
- The intruding star was much bigger than the sun and moving towards it.
- Its tidal force had a great effect on the sun's surface.
- Based on Newton's law of gravitation (1687): force ∝ product of masses, and ∝ 1/(distance)².
Main idea
- As the intruding star came closer, its pull raised a huge tide on the sun.
- At the closest approach, a cigar-shaped stream of matter, thousands of km long, was pulled out. Jeans called it the filament. ⭐⭐
- The filament was thick in the middle (pulled when the star was nearest) and thin at both ends (pulled when farther).
- The intruding star moved away; the filament stayed and revolved around the sun.
- It cooled, contracted and broke into pieces, each condensing into a planet.
- Big planets (Jupiter, Saturn) formed in the middle, small ones at the ends.
- Satellites formed from planets by the sun's tidal pull. Small planets cooled too quickly to give off matter, so Mercury and Venus have no satellites.
Evidence in favour ⭐
- Planet sizes increase to Jupiter, then decrease, like a cigar. The later discovery of tiny Pluto at the far end supported it.
- Satellites show the same pattern around big planets (Jupiter, Saturn).
- Big planets have many satellites; the smallest have none.
- Planets revolve and rotate in the same direction.
- The filament was slightly inclined, which explains the inclined axes of planets.
Jeffreys' modification: collision hypothesis (1929)
- Three stars: the primitive sun, its companion star, and an intruding star.
- The intruding star collided head-on with the companion star and shattered it.
- The intruding star escaped; the debris of the companion revolved around the sun and formed the planets.
- Jeffreys later admitted (1951) that it needed major changes.
Criticisms ⭐⭐
- B. Levin: stars are so far apart that such a close encounter is very unlikely.
- Does not explain what happened to the intruding star.
- N.N. Parisky: cannot explain the real distances of planets from the sun. Hoyle: if the sun were a grapefruit, the planetary material would be about 100 yards away. Russell doubted that matter could reach 500–3000 sun-diameters away.
- Cannot explain the angular momentum of the planets (Wooldridge and Morgan).
- Planets have heavy elements, but the sun is mainly light hydrogen and helium.
- Mercury and Venus are nearest the sun, so they should have felt its strongest tidal pull, yet have no satellites.
- The condensation process of the filament is not explained.