Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Tidal Hypothesis — Jeans (1919) and Jeffreys (1929)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

3 min read6 sections

Tidal Hypothesis — Jeans (1919) and Jeffreys (1929)

Basics

  • Proposed by: Sir James Jeans, British scientist, 1919.
  • Modified by: Harold Jeffreys, British scientist, 1929.
  • Type: Dualistic (Jeans); three bodies (Jeffreys); hot origin.
  • A popular modern hypothesis until the mid-20th century.

Assumptions

  1. The solar system formed from the sun and an intruding star.
  1. The primitive sun was a big incandescent gaseous mass, stationary but rotating.
  1. The intruding star was much bigger than the sun and moving towards it.
  1. Its tidal force had a great effect on the sun's surface.
  • Based on Newton's law of gravitation (1687): force ∝ product of masses, and ∝ 1/(distance)².

Main idea

  1. As the intruding star came closer, its pull raised a huge tide on the sun.
  1. At the closest approach, a cigar-shaped stream of matter, thousands of km long, was pulled out. Jeans called it the filament. ⭐⭐
  1. The filament was thick in the middle (pulled when the star was nearest) and thin at both ends (pulled when farther).
  1. The intruding star moved away; the filament stayed and revolved around the sun.
  1. It cooled, contracted and broke into pieces, each condensing into a planet.
  1. Big planets (Jupiter, Saturn) formed in the middle, small ones at the ends.
  1. Satellites formed from planets by the sun's tidal pull. Small planets cooled too quickly to give off matter, so Mercury and Venus have no satellites.

Evidence in favour ⭐

  1. Planet sizes increase to Jupiter, then decrease, like a cigar. The later discovery of tiny Pluto at the far end supported it.
  1. Satellites show the same pattern around big planets (Jupiter, Saturn).
  1. Big planets have many satellites; the smallest have none.
  1. Planets revolve and rotate in the same direction.
  1. The filament was slightly inclined, which explains the inclined axes of planets.

Jeffreys' modification: collision hypothesis (1929)

  • Three stars: the primitive sun, its companion star, and an intruding star.
  • The intruding star collided head-on with the companion star and shattered it.
  • The intruding star escaped; the debris of the companion revolved around the sun and formed the planets.
  • Jeffreys later admitted (1951) that it needed major changes.

Criticisms ⭐⭐

  1. B. Levin: stars are so far apart that such a close encounter is very unlikely.
  1. Does not explain what happened to the intruding star.
  1. N.N. Parisky: cannot explain the real distances of planets from the sun. Hoyle: if the sun were a grapefruit, the planetary material would be about 100 yards away. Russell doubted that matter could reach 500–3000 sun-diameters away.
  1. Cannot explain the angular momentum of the planets (Wooldridge and Morgan).
  1. Planets have heavy elements, but the sun is mainly light hydrogen and helium.
  1. Mercury and Venus are nearest the sun, so they should have felt its strongest tidal pull, yet have no satellites.
  1. The condensation process of the filament is not explained.