Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Thermal Convection Current Theory — Holmes (1928–29)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read6 sections

Thermal Convection Current Theory — Holmes (1928–29)

Basics ⭐⭐

  • Proposed by: Arthur Holmes, British geologist, in 1928–29.
  • Type: drift theory (horizontal forces).
  • Aim: to explain mountain building and also the origin of continents and ocean basins by drift. Holmes rejected the permanence of continents.
  • Force: thermal convection currents in the substratum (now called the mantle), driven by heat from the breakdown of radioactive elements.
  • Wooldridge and Morgan called it the only unifying theory that could reconcile mountain building and continental drift.

Base of the theory ⭐⭐

  • Layers of the crust (Holmes): granodiorite (10–12 km), amphibolite (20–25 km), then eclogite (lower layer).
  • Crust = sial; substratum = sima.
  • Radioactive elements are most concentrated in the crust, but the crust loses heat (conduction and radiation), so heat does not build up there.
  • Heat accumulates in the substratum, and this sets up convection currents.

Mechanism ⭐⭐⭐

Currents
Effect
Result
Diverging (rising currents spread out under the crust)
Tension: the crust is stretched, thinned and broken
Blocks drift apart; the gap becomes a sea or ocean (continental drift). Example: opening of the Tethys
Converging (two currents meet and descend)
Compression
Crust sinks into a geosyncline and sediments are folded into mountains. Example: closing of the Tethys (Laurasia and Gondwanaland brought together, Alpine fold mountains)
  • Convection is periodic: it waxes and wanes and starts again with a different arrangement of centres.

Three stages of the cycle ⭐⭐⭐

Stage
Duration
What happens
Same as
1. Preparatory
Longest
Currents from two centres converge under the continental shelves and form a geosyncline. Sediments pile up and sink. Pushed deeper, they heat up and metamorphose: amphibolite → eclogite (density about 3.0 → 3.4). The denser rock sinks, forming a falling column
Lithogenesis
2. Orogenic
Short
Currents speed up (cold material sinking, hot rising). The fast converging currents buckle the sediments into mountains
Orogenesis
3. Waning
Declining
Rising column goes cold and the currents die. Pressure on the falling column drops, so materials rise. Eclogite melts and expands, lifting the mountains further
Gliptogenesis
  • Griggs (1939) supported the mechanism with laboratory model experiments.

Criticisms (at the time) ⭐⭐

  1. It rests on factors about which little was known; the rising and falling columns were doubtful.
  1. Is radioactive heat enough to drive the currents? Heat is also lost through the crust.
  1. Horizontal flow of the currents under the crust was doubtful.
  1. The density gain from amphibolite to eclogite (3.0 → 3.4) seems too small to make the column sink.
  1. Why do currents start only at a few centres and not everywhere?

Importance ⭐⭐⭐

  • Convection currents are now accepted in the mantle. The 1960s found just what Holmes needed: a force to move plates.
  • Plate tectonics is built on convection. Rising currents diverge under the mid-ocean ridges and plates split and move apart.
  • So Holmes was right in principle, not in every detail.
Memory tip: Holmes: diverge = drift (open Tethys); converge = mountains (close Tethys).