Basics ⭐⭐
- Proposed by: Arthur Holmes, British geologist, in 1928–29.
- Type: drift theory (horizontal forces).
- Aim: to explain mountain building and also the origin of continents and ocean basins by drift. Holmes rejected the permanence of continents.
- Force: thermal convection currents in the substratum (now called the mantle), driven by heat from the breakdown of radioactive elements.
- Wooldridge and Morgan called it the only unifying theory that could reconcile mountain building and continental drift.
Base of the theory ⭐⭐
- Layers of the crust (Holmes): granodiorite (10–12 km), amphibolite (20–25 km), then eclogite (lower layer).
- Crust = sial; substratum = sima.
- Radioactive elements are most concentrated in the crust, but the crust loses heat (conduction and radiation), so heat does not build up there.
- Heat accumulates in the substratum, and this sets up convection currents.
Mechanism ⭐⭐⭐
Currents | Effect | Result |
Diverging (rising currents spread out under the crust) | Tension: the crust is stretched, thinned and broken | Blocks drift apart; the gap becomes a sea or ocean (continental drift). Example: opening of the Tethys |
Converging (two currents meet and descend) | Compression | Crust sinks into a geosyncline and sediments are folded into mountains. Example: closing of the Tethys (Laurasia and Gondwanaland brought together, Alpine fold mountains) |
- Convection is periodic: it waxes and wanes and starts again with a different arrangement of centres.
Three stages of the cycle ⭐⭐⭐
Stage | Duration | What happens | Same as |
1. Preparatory | Longest | Currents from two centres converge under the continental shelves and form a geosyncline. Sediments pile up and sink. Pushed deeper, they heat up and metamorphose: amphibolite → eclogite (density about 3.0 → 3.4). The denser rock sinks, forming a falling column | Lithogenesis |
2. Orogenic | Short | Currents speed up (cold material sinking, hot rising). The fast converging currents buckle the sediments into mountains | Orogenesis |
3. Waning | Declining | Rising column goes cold and the currents die. Pressure on the falling column drops, so materials rise. Eclogite melts and expands, lifting the mountains further | Gliptogenesis |
- Griggs (1939) supported the mechanism with laboratory model experiments.
Criticisms (at the time) ⭐⭐
- It rests on factors about which little was known; the rising and falling columns were doubtful.
- Is radioactive heat enough to drive the currents? Heat is also lost through the crust.
- Horizontal flow of the currents under the crust was doubtful.
- The density gain from amphibolite to eclogite (3.0 → 3.4) seems too small to make the column sink.
- Why do currents start only at a few centres and not everywhere?
Importance ⭐⭐⭐
- Convection currents are now accepted in the mantle. The 1960s found just what Holmes needed: a force to move plates.
- Plate tectonics is built on convection. Rising currents diverge under the mid-ocean ridges and plates split and move apart.
- So Holmes was right in principle, not in every detail.
Memory tip: Holmes: diverge = drift (open Tethys); converge = mountains (close Tethys).