Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Behaviouralism & Humanism

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

9 min read2 sections

Behaviouralism & Humanism

1. Behavioural geography ⭐⭐

Origin

  • Came from dissatisfaction with positivist models based on the "economic rationality" of man. QR models gave poor descriptions of reality, theory developed slowly and predictive power was weak.
    • Central Place Theory was inadequate to explain spatial organisation.
    • Economic rationality could not explain the floodplain dweller who stays despite flood risk.
  • A "psychological turn" in human geography: cognitive (subjective) and decision-making variables mediate between environment and spatial behaviour.
  • Julian Wolpert (1964) ⭐: in a sample of Swedish farmers, optimal farming was not attained. Farmers are not optimisers but, in Herbert Simon's term, "satisficers". They face an uncertain physical and economic environment and act on available information and their image of it.
  • Introduced in the 1960s, out of frustration with normative, mechanistic models based on the "rational economic man" and an "isotropic" surface. Normative models assume omniscient, fully rational actors competing on a homogeneous plain. People behave rationally, but within the constraints of the cultures in which they were socialised.

Objectives ⭐

  1. Develop alternatives to the location theories of the QR.
  1. Define the cognitive (subjective) environment that shapes decisions.
  1. Unfold the spatial dimensions of psychological and social theories of decision-making and behaviour.
  1. Explain the spatial dimensions of those theories.
  1. Shift from aggregate populations to individuals and small groups (disaggregate scale).
  1. Seek methods other than mathematics and statistics to uncover latent structure in data and decisions.
  1. Stress process-based rather than structural explanations.
  1. Generate primary data on behaviour, not rely on published data.
  1. An interdisciplinary approach to theory and problem-solving.

Fundamental arguments (three) ⭐

  1. People have environmental images.
  1. Those images can be identified accurately by researchers.
  1. There is a strong relationship between environmental images and actual behaviour (decision-making).

Nature

  • Based on behaviouralism (a psychological and philosophical approach). Largely inductive: general statements from observations of ongoing processes.
  • Behaviour is mediated by people's understanding of their environment. Environmental cognition and behaviour are intimately related.
  • Man shapes and responds to his environment; they are dynamically interrelated. Man is a motivated social being whose decisions are mediated by cognition of the spatial environment.

Salient features ⭐

  1. Two environments (environmental cognition may differ markedly from reality):
      • Objective (phenomenal) environment: the world of actuality, gauged directly by the senses.
      • Behavioural environment: the world of the mind, studied only indirectly. It is the basis of decision and action (reality as perceived by individuals).
      • Koffka (1935–36), the Lake Constance story: a rider crossed a snow-covered plain in a storm and reached an inn. Told he had ridden across the frozen Lake Constance, he dropped dead. His behavioural environment (a plain) differed from the objective environment (a frozen lake), and he acted on the former.
  1. Focus on the individual, not the group or society. Each person's actions affect the environment, however slightly. Man is a goal-directed animal.
  1. A mutually interacting man–environment relationship (Gold, 1980).
  1. Multidisciplinary: psychology, philosophy, history, sociology, anthropology, ethnology, planning. But it lacks theories of its own.

Historical perspective

  • Implicit since Kant. Reclus: man is not passive. The American landscape school: man as a morphological agent. Human ecology and the French possibilists (choice). Sauer: man shapes his socio-cultural environment.
  • J.K. Wright (1947), "Terrae Incognitae": study geographical knowledge in all forms, formal and informal (travel books, magazines, newspapers, fiction, poetry, painting). Coined "geosophy".
  • Sauer, Gilbert White (natural hazards perception) and others: people act according to habit and experience, not as rational persons.
  • W. Kirk (1952/1963): one of the first behavioural models. The same information has different meanings for people of different socio-economic, cultural and ethnic backgrounds in the same environment ("behavioural environment").
    • Indian example: in one Indo-Gangetic village, a Jat prefers sugarcane, wheat and rice. An Ahir, Gada or Jhoja grows fodder for milch animals. A Saini practises intensive vegetable cultivation, for whom 5 acres is big while a tractor-owning Jat finds 10 acres small. Each perceives the same environment differently.
  • Man is not an "economic man". Most decisions are based on the behavioural environment (mental map), not the objective one.

Models of perception ⭐

Model
Scheme
Boulding (1956)
Environment → Image → Behaviour. Images form through everyday contact with the environment and are the basis of behaviour (The Image)
Downs (1970)
Real world information → perceptual receptors → filters (personality, culture, beliefs, cognition, value systems) → image → decision → behaviour (and back to the real world). Objective and behavioural environments both exist
Porteous (1977)
Three environments: phenomenal (physical objects), personal (perceived images), contextual (culture, religion, beliefs, expectations)
Sonnenfeld (1972)
Four levels: (a) geographical (the world), (b) operational (parts that impinge on man, aware or not), (c) perceptual (parts he is aware of through experience), (d) behavioural (the part of the perceptual environment that elicits a response)

Criticism ⭐

  • Bias towards urban topics and developed countries. Little synthesis of findings, poor communication, duplication, conflicting and loosely defined terminology. No systematic theoretical base.
  • Much data comes from laboratory experiments on animals applied to humans. Koestler (1975): behaviourism replaced the anthropomorphic fallacy with the opposite one: "for the erstwhile anthropomorphic view of the rat, a ratomorphic view of man". Elegant but unhelpful theories.
  • Too ego-centred. Two doubtful assumptions: (1) that images can be measured accurately without distortion; (2) that images strongly predict behaviour (little research on image–behaviour congruence).
  • Treats man as homo psychologicus, overlooking economic, social and political factors.
  • A gap between theory and practice / public policy: behavioural geographers are observers, not participants, and lack planning knowledge. Small student samples should not drive big policy recommendations.
  • Yet it is widely accepted within the positivist orientation: inductive generalisation leading to environmental planning. Golledge: advances come from studying "process variables" (preferences, attitudes, cognitive maps, perception).

2. Humanistic geography ⭐⭐

Origin and meaning

  • Emerged in the late 1960s as the most sophisticated critical reaction against logical positivism. Deep dissatisfaction with the mechanistic models of spatial science. Cultural and historical geographers attacked positivism from the early 1970s.
  • It rejected "geometric determinism": people responding automatically to spatial laws, treated as "dots on a map, data on a graph, numbers in an equation". It claimed a "people's geography", with the human being at its very centre.
  • W. Kirk (1951) was among the first to attract an audience for it. Yi-Fu Tuan (1976) used the term "humanistic geography" for the first time (paper "Humanistic Geography", Annals of the AAG).
    • Tuan: a perspective disclosing the complexity and ambiguity of relations between people and place. Commonly cited books: Topophilia (1974), Space and Place (1977).
  • Central and active role to human awareness, agency, consciousness and creativity. Understanding meaning, value and the human significance of life events, and the dignity of the individual.
  • It sees environment as place: locales where people live, experience, interpret and find meaning.
  • Uses a historical approach. Does not treat humans as machines. A subjective approach aiming at verstehen.
  • Ralph (Relph, 1981): humanism is the conviction that people best improve their lives by thinking and acting for themselves, using reason.
  • Objection to the QR: its tools cannot explain the human world: institutions, attitudes, morals, customs, traditions, aesthetics.
  • Reasoning should keep contact with everyday experience and celebrate human creativity. Geography = "the study of the earth as the home of man".
  • Not an earth science in its ultimate aim. It belongs to the humanities and social sciences, and studies people's relation with nature, their behaviour, and their feelings and ideas about space and place.
  • Rejects reducing space and place to geometric surface and point. Place is the key concept. The meaning of a place is inseparable from the consciousness of its inhabitants.

Methodology ⭐

  • (a) A self-conscious link with the humanities: human experience and expression.
  • (b) Methods of literary criticism, aesthetics and art history, based on hermeneutics (the theory of interpretation and clarification of meaning).
  • (c) Recovery of place and iconography: reading landscape as a carrier of symbolic meaning (widening iconography from portraiture to landscape).
  • (d) Participant observation, interviews, focus groups, film, and logical inference, rather than statistics.
  • (e) Disclose the world as it shows itself before scientific inquiry: the "pre-given" (a phenomenological stance).
  • (f) "Objectification" is never as simple as conventional science assumes.

Tuan's five themes ⭐

Theme
Meaning and examples
1. Geographical knowledge (personal geographies)
Man has a special capacity for thought, so the primary task is to study articulated ideas. Geographical knowledge is needed for survival: even Siberian birds that winter at Bharatpur have a mental map for their return in late February. All groups have spatial ideas at different levels: Polynesians are able cartographers, while some materially advanced people lack maps
2. Territory and place
Territoriality is an animal instinct (honeybee, tiger, lion). A songbird surveys its whole area, but ground mammals know a network of paths and places. Hunter-gatherers see territory as paths and places, while cultivators have a strong sense of bounded property. Man forms an emotional attachment to place and has memory (birth, death, birthplace). How mere space becomes intensely human place is the humanist's task
3. Crowding and privacy
Crowding causes stress, but culture and institutions reduce it: crowded Hong Kong is no more crime-prone than spacious Western cities. Kalahari Bushmen crowd by choice near water with no biological stress. Privacy and solitude: in solitude one creates one's own world, safe from another's gaze
4. Livelihood and economics
All activities, even sacred cow worship or ritual sacrifice, have economic consequences. Man distinguishes life-sustaining from life-destroying activities (e.g. armaments). How far do planners use economic theory, and with what results?
5. Religion
Universal. Distinguishes humans from animals. Religion (Latin religare) = "to bind again" to beliefs. A religious person seeks coherence and meaning; in that broad sense everyone (even Einstein) is religious. Study differences in the desire for coherence and how they show in the organisation of space and time and attitudes to nature

Historical perspective

  • Traced to Vidal, but its real beginning is Kantian (history = time/narrative; geography = space/description; together they "fill up the entire circumference of our perception").
  • Febvre and Vidal (possibilism): "nature is never more than an adviser". The milieu shows man as both active and passive. (Vidal's writings also carry hallmarks of functionalism and pragmatism, and he saw human geography as a natural science.)
  • Sauer (1925): the phenomenology of landscape. Wooldridge (1936): historical geography should see the countryside through the eyes of the farmer. J.K. Wright (1947): "geosophy": geographical knowledge is part of everyone's mental stock.
  • Hartshorne (1939): accepted the Kantian task.
  • Kirk (1951) and Tuan (1976) laid a strong foundation.
  • 1970s revival began alongside behavioural geography, but they parted: humanism recognised the essential subjectivity of both investigator and investigated.
  • It then moved from attacking positivism to attacking structuralism (man bound in socio-economic and political structures), and developed a sharper empirical methodology.
  • Kropotkin, Reclus, Fleure and Herbertson were also humanistic in spirit.
  • The researcher must discover the actor's definition of the situation and see the world as the actor sees it.

Criticism ⭐

  1. One can never be sure an explanation is true (but the same applies to physics, whose history is one of abandoned theories).
  1. Separates physical from human geography methodologically, eroding the unity of the subject.
  1. Based on participant observation, so it is hard to build theory, abstraction, generalisation or spatial geometry. More subjective than objective.
  1. Little applied research (industrial location, land use). Risks losing ground to other disciplines' "academic imperialism": location economics to economics, climatic variability to atmospheric physics, slopes and soils to soil mechanics.
  1. Not a viable alternative to scientific geography. Entrikin (1976): humanism is best understood as a form of criticism.
  1. "Methodologically obscure": any method seems acceptable. Eclectic, more thinking than practice.
  1. Called unscientific: cannot produce generalisations, theories or laws.
  • Author's view: most criticisms are ill-founded. "All history is the history of human thought." Place can be understood through participant observation and social interaction, giving human awareness and agency an active role.