Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Feminist Thought: Waves & Theories

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

7 min read5 sections

Feminist Thought: Waves & Theories

Definition ⭐

  • Feminist geography is a branch of human geography concerned with the spatial differentiation and organisation of female activity and women's use of the physical environment (resources). It deals with women's relations in space and the spatial structures behind them.
  • It emphasises the oppression of women and gender inequality: how gender and geographies are mutually produced and transformed, and how gender differentiation permeates social life.
  • It developed after the 1970s, inspired by the women's movements of the 1960s. It has had a sophisticated radical view since the mid-1970s, and bears the marks of women's exclusion from the discipline's upper levels and research agenda.
  • Feminism: political and social philosophies and practices centred on the role of gender in social life, critiquing the hierarchical binaries of masculinity and femininity. A system of thought radicalised by women's experiences of multiple oppressions: gender, class, race, religion, region.

Three waves of the women's movement ⭐

Wave
Features
First wave
USA: Seneca Falls Convention (1848; the book prints 1948) and its Declaration of Rights and Sentiments, modelled on the Declaration of Independence. Demanded equality in marriage, property rights, equal wages, child custody, contracts, court testimony, inheritance, and the vote. Organisers: Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony. Suffrage was the crucial goal: entry into public life, legal equality, and the unity of all women against male domination. The International Women's Suffrage Movement (influenced by the Second Socialist International and the WCTU) used militancy, civil disobedience and mass demonstrations, and faced arrest and forced prison feeding. Asia, Latin America and the Middle East movements came after the 1920s, tied to working-class movements. Suffrage, economic growth and mass consumption demobilised the first wave
Second wave
Radicalisation of women in the anti-Vietnam War and civil rights movements (1960s). Women were denied leadership, e.g. in Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) ("women made peanut butter, waited on tables …"). Consciousness-raising groups. "The personal is political." National Organization for Women (NOW), 1966, linked liberals and socialists. Optimism and formative literature, then decline by the 1980s
Third wave ("post-feminist")
Feminism became an academic critique of knowledge. Issues: abortion, welfare, work, crime (drugs), immigration. Debates opened by women of colour and lesbians (late 1970s) on the neglect of sexual, racial and class differences. Third World women organise around economic, environmental, legal, military and cultural threats, dictatorship, fundamentalism, dependence and violence. Examples: Chipko Movement (Garhwal, Uttarakhand), Green Belt Movement (Kenya), SEWA (Self-Employed Women's Association, India), Mothers of the Disappeared (Latin America). Culturally specific feminisms, yet "unity through diversity" on economic justice, human rights and environmental degradation

Three phases of feminist geography ⭐⭐

Phase
Topical focus
Theoretical influence
Geographical focus
1. Geography of Women (mid to late 1970s)
Describing the effects of gender inequality
Welfare geography, liberal feminism
Constraints of distance and spatial separation
2. Socialist Feminist Geography (early to late 1980s)
Explaining gender inequality; capitalism and patriarchy
Marxism, socialist feminism
Spatial separation, place and localities
3. Postcolonial / post-structural Feminist Geography (late 1980s to now)
Construction of gendered identities, differences among women, gender and nature, gender and nationalism
Cultural, post-structural, postcolonial, psychoanalytic theories; writings of women of colour, lesbians, gay men, women from developing countries
Micro-geographies of the body, distance, separation, place, imaginative and symbolic spaces, environment

Basic theoretical question

  • "And what about the women?" Where are women in the situation? If absent, why? If present, what are they doing, contributing and experiencing?
  • Conclusions after 30 years:
    • Women are present in most social situations. Where absent, it is due to deliberate exclusion, not lack of ability or interest.
    • Where present, their roles differ from the stereotype (passive wives and mothers).
    • Scholars and actors of both sexes were blind to their presence.
    • Their roles are essential but less privileged and subordinate. Invisibility is one indicator of inequality.
  • Women's lives are shaped by their social location: race, ethnicity, class, religion, age, affectional preference, marital status, global location.

Varieties of feminist theory (Ritzer, 2000) ⭐

Answer to "What about the women?"
Theories explaining "Why?"
Gender difference: women's experience differs from men's
Cultural feminism; biological, institutional and socialisation, social-psychological explanations
Gender inequality: women's position is less privileged
Liberal feminism, Marxian feminism
Gender oppression: women are actively restrained, subordinated, moulded, used and abused by men
Psychoanalytic feminism, radical feminism
Structural oppression: oppression varies by position within capitalism, patriarchy and racism
Socialist feminism, intersectionality theory
—
Feminism and postmodernism

Gender inequality theories: four themes

  1. Women have less of the material resources, status, power and opportunity for self-actualisation than men of the same social location.
  1. This results from the organisation of society, not biology or personality.
  1. No significant pattern of natural variation distinguishes the sexes.
  1. Both sexes would respond easily to more egalitarian structures, so change is possible. (Gender differences, by contrast, are more durable.)
  • Alison Jaggar (Feminist Politics and Human Nature, 1983) outlines liberal, radical, socialist and postmodern conceptions of women's liberation.

1. Liberal feminism

  • The main expression of inequality theory. Women claim equality on the basis of a shared human capacity for reasoned moral agency. Inequality results from a patriarchal, sexist division of labour. Equality comes by reshaping key institutions: law, work, family, education, media.
  • (Marxian strand in the book:) women's nature forms through praxis, biology and environment. Engels: early societies had a sexual division of labour (men subsistence, women household). Growth of male productive forces gave men dominance. Monogamy was instituted to control inheritance, so women's subordination comes from class society and serves capital. Marxist feminists ask women to take the working-class standpoint.
  • Committed to neo-positivist objectivity (value-free, universal theories). No special privilege for women, only equal rights and opportunities.
  • Explanation rests on four factors: (i) the social construction of gender, (ii) the gender division of labour, (iii) the doctrine of public and private spheres, (iv) patriarchal ideology. Women get the private sphere; men get privileged access to the public sphere (money, power, status, freedom, self-worth).

2. Radical feminism ⭐

  • A critique of patriarchy. Two beliefs:
      1. Women are of absolute positive value as women.
      1. Women everywhere are oppressed, violently, by patriarchy.
  • From the 1960s women's liberation movement. Explanations:
    • Sex roles and the need for androgyny
    • Universal male privilege in biological terms: man as natural predator, woman as natural prey
  • Shulamith Firestone, The Dialectic of Sex (1970): adapts Marxism. Procreative reproduction, not productive labour, is the moving force of history. The biological family is the base and the economy part of the superstructure. Class struggle is between two reproductive classes: women (weaker due to reproductive physiology) and men. Reproductive technology (contraception, test-tube babies) can end the biological basis of subordination.
  • Susan Griffin (1980): "we are nature". Women's closeness to nature and feeling-based knowing are sources of strength. The ideal human combines empathy, intuition and protectiveness with reason.
  • Patriarchy is the most fundamental and least noticed structure of inequality, among systems of domination (heterosexuality, class, caste, race, ethnicity, age, gender). It breeds guilt, repression, sadism, masochism, manipulation and deception.
  • Hidden violence (MacKinnon, 1979): fashion and beauty standards, tyrannical ideas of motherhood, monogamy, chastity, heterosexuality, workplace sexual harassment, gynaecology, obstetrics and psychotherapy, unpaid household drudgery, underpaid work.
  • Physical violence: rape, abuse, enforced prostitution, spouse abuse, incest, child molestation, excessive surgery, pornography, witch burning, stoning of adulteresses, persecution of lesbians, female infanticide, foot-binding, abuse of widows, clitoridectomy.
  • Why patriarchy is near-universal: men can use physical force, and they have interests in women: sexual satisfaction, childbearing, labour, status display, emotional support.
  • How to defeat it: rework women's consciousness, building a sisterhood of trust and mutual defence. Then: (i) critical confrontation with patriarchy; (ii) separatism: women-run businesses, households, communities and art. Lesbian feminism: "erotic and/or emotional commitment to women is part of resistance to patriarchal domination" (Phelan, 1994).

3. Socialist feminism

  • Committed to the Marxist idea of the historical and social creation of human nature, including gender, race and ethnicity as well as class.
  • Causal emphasis on the sexual division of labour and praxis. Women are constituted by the social relations they inhabit and the labour they perform.
  • Besides production for physical needs, the needs of bearing and raising children, sexual satisfaction and emotional nurturing are equally fundamental and require (usually female) labour. Struggles over reproduction are fundamental but ignored by traditional Marxism.
  • Nancy Chodorow (1978) (The Reproduction of Mothering): the most intense early love is for the mother. Boys must separate through hostility to mothers, leading to lifelong contempt for women, denial of emotional needs and rigid super-egos, and grow up achievement-oriented for work outside the home. Girls gain femininity by being like their mothers, keeping empathy, and grow up for emotional work.
  • Procreation and public production are interdependent, not independent.

4. Feminism as postmodernism

  • Postmodernism: thought after modernism and opposed to the certainties of modern science, planning and structuralism. Modernism = the application of rationality and abstraction valid anywhere.
  • Key geography books: David Harvey, The Condition of Postmodernity (1989) and Edward Soja, Postmodern Geographies (1989). Postmodern culture is a product of late capitalism, a shift from mass production to flexible, footloose, just-in-time accumulation, with a fragmented culture.
  • Postmodernism answers "What about the women?" with "How are you constructing the category 'women'?", so it is an "oppositional epistemology" for feminism.
  • The postmodern world results from: (i) aggressive expansion of global capitalism, (ii) the weakening of centralised state power (collapse of empires, fragmentation of the communist bloc, ethnic politics), (iii) powerful, penetrative technology, plus liberation movements based on identity, not class: nationalism (anti-colonial), race (civil rights), gender (feminism), sexual orientation (gay rights), environmentalism.
  • Everything is contextual. There is no single truth; phenomena are multi-layered.
  • Postmodern feminism sees modern reason as a normalising, Western, masculine prejudice, a colonising scientific rationalism that sets a masculine knowing subject against a conquered, feminised object.