Main idea ⭐⭐⭐
- Mountains are not hollow. Their extra weight is balanced by lighter material below.
- The lighter crust (sial) floats in the denser substratum (sima), like a boat in water, with most of its mass sunk below.
- The Himalayas float in denser magma with a deep root of light rock projecting downward.
- Based on the law of floatation.
- Key phrase: "uniform density with varying thickness": all land columns have the same density; higher columns simply sink deeper.
- "The higher the column above the substratum, the deeper its root; the lower the column, the shallower its root."
Experiment
- Pieces of iron of different lengths placed in a basin of mercury sink to different depths according to their length. (Wooden blocks in water behave the same way.)
Ratio of freeboard to draught ⭐⭐
- Freeboard = part above; draught = part below.
- Taking crust density 2.67 and substratum 3.0, the ratio is about 1 : 9 (like an iceberg, with one part above water for nine below). Airy himself used only the boat analogy.
- For 8,848 m of the Himalayas, the root would reach about 79,632 m (~80 km) (8,848 × 9).
- Joly used a ratio of 1 : 8, giving a root of 70,784 m (8,848 × 8).
Criticism ⭐
- Such a long root would melt: temperature rises about 1°C per 32 m, so it would be extremely hot at 70–80 km.
Later status
- Airy's basic idea (light sial blocks floating in heavier sima) was revived by Heiskanen's work, and most geologists now favour Airy's explanation (J.A. Steers). Seismic studies confirm that mountains have deep crustal roots.