Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Planetesimal Hypothesis — Chamberlin and Moulton (1905)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

2 min read5 sections

Planetesimal Hypothesis — Chamberlin and Moulton (1905)

Basics

  • Proposed by: T.C. Chamberlin (geologist) and F.R. Moulton (astronomer), University of Chicago.
  • Year: 1905.
  • Type: Dualistic (two bodies); cold origin.
  • A revival of Count de Buffon's collision hypothesis (1749).
  • Failure of monistic ideas on angular momentum led to dualistic ideas.
  • Explains not only the earth's origin but also its interior, atmosphere, continents and ocean basins.

Main idea

  1. Two stars: a proto-sun (cold, made of small solid particles) and an intruding (companion) star.
  1. As the intruding star passed close, its tidal (gravitational) pull tore countless small particles from the proto-sun. Chamberlin called them planetesimals.
  1. Larger planetesimals became nuclei and attracted smaller ones (accretion), growing into planets.
  1. The rest of the proto-sun became the sun; satellites formed the same way.
  1. The earth never had to be fully molten.

Three stages of the earth's evolution

  1. Period of planetesimal accession: earth reaches its present shape and size.
  1. Period of dominant vulcanism: interior, continents and ocean basins form.
  1. Actual geological period: folds, faults, mountains and plateaus form.

Other explanations

  • Atmosphere: from an external source (gas molecules captured as earth grew) and an internal source (occluded gases such as CO₂, water vapour and nitrogen released by volcanic and fissure eruptions).
  • Interior heat: from collision of planetesimals, pressure of accumulating material, and exothermic chemical rearrangement. The interior reached over 20,000°C but did not melt because high pressure raises the melting point.
  • Oceans: water collected in crevices and volcanic craters as lakes, which joined into oceans.
  • Continents: basic material was removed in solution to the oceans, so continents became acidic and lighter, and ocean floors heavier.

Criticisms ⭐

  1. Planetesimals would have vaporised from the heat of ejection and scattered, not condensed.
  1. Does not explain the orderly arrangement of planet sizes (increasing to Jupiter, then decreasing).
  1. Why only nine planets?
  1. Does not explain the gaseous, low-density outer planets.
  1. The angular momentum given by the intruding star is not enough for the planets' present angular momentum.
  1. A close encounter between stars in infinite space is very unlikely.
  1. Compressional force for mountain building was insufficient.
  1. Jeffreys: the small nucleus could not hold an atmosphere; meteorites are completely dry, so planetesimals could not supply atmospheric material.