Basics
- Proposed by: T.C. Chamberlin (geologist) and F.R. Moulton (astronomer), University of Chicago.
- Year: 1905.
- Type: Dualistic (two bodies); cold origin.
- A revival of Count de Buffon's collision hypothesis (1749).
- Failure of monistic ideas on angular momentum led to dualistic ideas.
- Explains not only the earth's origin but also its interior, atmosphere, continents and ocean basins.
Main idea
- Two stars: a proto-sun (cold, made of small solid particles) and an intruding (companion) star.
- As the intruding star passed close, its tidal (gravitational) pull tore countless small particles from the proto-sun. Chamberlin called them planetesimals.
- Larger planetesimals became nuclei and attracted smaller ones (accretion), growing into planets.
- The rest of the proto-sun became the sun; satellites formed the same way.
- The earth never had to be fully molten.
Three stages of the earth's evolution
- Period of planetesimal accession: earth reaches its present shape and size.
- Period of dominant vulcanism: interior, continents and ocean basins form.
- Actual geological period: folds, faults, mountains and plateaus form.
Other explanations
- Atmosphere: from an external source (gas molecules captured as earth grew) and an internal source (occluded gases such as CO₂, water vapour and nitrogen released by volcanic and fissure eruptions).
- Interior heat: from collision of planetesimals, pressure of accumulating material, and exothermic chemical rearrangement. The interior reached over 20,000°C but did not melt because high pressure raises the melting point.
- Oceans: water collected in crevices and volcanic craters as lakes, which joined into oceans.
- Continents: basic material was removed in solution to the oceans, so continents became acidic and lighter, and ocean floors heavier.
Criticisms ⭐
- Planetesimals would have vaporised from the heat of ejection and scattered, not condensed.
- Does not explain the orderly arrangement of planet sizes (increasing to Jupiter, then decreasing).
- Why only nine planets?
- Does not explain the gaseous, low-density outer planets.
- The angular momentum given by the intruding star is not enough for the planets' present angular momentum.
- A close encounter between stars in infinite space is very unlikely.
- Compressional force for mountain building was insufficient.
- Jeffreys: the small nucleus could not hold an atmosphere; meteorites are completely dry, so planetesimals could not supply atmospheric material.