Geography and public policy
- Geography developed through alternating periods of tranquillity and crisis (Kuhn). Each phase was shaped by the author's beliefs, the political system, social needs and economic institutions.
- Until WWII geography was seen as general knowledge (topography, climate, rivers, towns, ports).
- Now syllabi are built around social welfare: awareness of local surroundings, regional milieu, pollution and world environment, environmental management. Geographers tackle backwardness, pollution, uneven development, inequality and social justice, with approaches from positive to normative, radical to humanist, idealist to realist.
- The focus shifted from what the spatial distribution is to what it should be: tracing the origins of disparity rather than merely condemning injustice.
- Problems:
- In developed countries, early employment was mostly teaching. In the Third World, geographers are hardly involved in planning.
- Research stays in libraries.
- Indian policymakers are unaware of the spatial dimension of their problems, and there is prejudice against geography (the "general knowledge" image).
- Key issues: poverty, hunger, pollution, racial discrimination, social inequality, resource misuse.
- Works useful for policy: Geography of Crime, Black Ghetto (Rose), Geography of Social Well-being (D.M. Smith).
- The QR gave the rigour needed for policy analysis.
Welfare geography ⭐
- David M. Smith adopted the welfare approach (Human Geography: A Welfare Approach, 1977). Objective: evaluating the social desirability of alternative geographical states.
Definition | By |
"That branch of study which endeavours to formulate positions by which we may rank, on a scale of better or worse, alternative geographical situations open to society" | Mishan (theoretical welfare) |
"That part of geography where we study the possible effects of various geographical policies on the welfare of society" | Nath |
"Who gets what, where, and how" | D.M. Smith ⭐ |
- A "geographical state" = any spatial arrangement of human existence: allocation of resources and income, incidence of poverty, industrial location, population distribution, location of social services, transport networks, movements. Beneath them lie the economic, social and political structures that generate the patterns.
- Welfare and humanist ideals appear in many traditions: Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Confucian, Hellenistic, scientific, realist, Marxist, existentialist.
Stages of welfare research ⭐
- Description: empirical identification of territorial levels of human well-being (very little done in India).
- Explanation: the how: cause and effect links that decide who gets what, where.
- Evaluation: judging the desirability of alternative geographical states by equity as well as efficiency (profit maximising and cost minimising).
- Prescription: specifying alternative states and societal structures. The ethical question: who should get what, where?
- Implementation: replacing the undesirable state by a better one: how.
Geographers' role in spatial allocation
- All physical development has a redistributive impact: any facility (hospital, school, road, park, sewage works) benefits some people in some places more. Distance and accessibility decide who gains or suffers. So location decisions need utmost care, which requires geographers.
- Allocation problems: priority areas, routes, factory location, infrastructure, health care, housing, shopping centres, land for agriculture, urban and recreational use. Disentangling economic, social, cultural and ecological networks easily disturbed by ill-conceived projects.
- India: high inequality. About 50% below the poverty line (the book's figure), over half of national assets held by about two dozen families, activity concentrated in metropolitan cores while about 70% live in villages (2011). Urban-biased policy widens the gaps (rich vs poor, urban vs rural).
- USA: the richest society, yet Black ghettos, rural poverty in the South, crime and drugs. 1976: about 12% (26 million) below the poverty line. This shows capitalist growth failing to lift everyone.
- The capitalist argument (people are born unequal) ignores how birthplace and family constrain opportunity, worsened by urban-biased policy.
- Limits: geographers cannot make all deserts fertile or create minerals. Physical limits exist in harsh environments.
- Geographers' unique skill: handling spatially distributed data, the spatial dimension of environmental and resource management that others overlook.
- Where geographers help design policy (Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands, Israel, Denmark, the USSR, France, New Zealand, Australia), benefits reach all.
Applied geography ⭐
- The application of geographical knowledge and skills to the solution or resolution of problems within society.
- Adams (1976): research should highlight particulars, and teaching should emphasise man in harmony with nature rather than master of it, social health over economic health, equity over efficiency, and quality of life over quantity of goods.
- L. Dudley Stamp, Applied Geography (1960): the first major statement.
- The geographer's unique contribution is the holistic approach: seeing man–environment relations and their problems as a whole.
- Method: (i) field survey, (ii) systematic, objective data gathering, then mapping and cartographic study.
- Relevant to population pressure on land, economic development, inequality in living standards and regional planning.
- Conducted the first Land Use Survey of Great Britain. Book: The Land of Britain: Its Use and Misuse.
- Saw the geographer as an information gatherer and synthesiser standing outside politics.
- Many geographers became planning officers in the 1940s–60s. In wartime, geographers worked in military intelligence and air-photo interpretation, which grew into remote sensing. Now GPS.
- 1960s onwards: the QR, then GIS and computer cartography, widened applied work in the private and public sectors. Predictive models (e.g. traffic flows). Entropy-maximising models.
- After Stamp: society–environment interaction, environmental hazards and rehabilitation. The journal Applied Geography (1981). J.T. Coppock (1974): "geography and public policy".
- 1980s: pressure on universities to tackle social problems and earn income from consultancy. Emphasis on "marketable skills": GIS, remote sensing.
- More developed in North America (graduate profession). The AAG Applied Geography Specialty Group.
- Capitalist countries: urban and regional planning, private consultancy. Socialist countries (1950–2000): state-directed applied work, larger in volume than in most of the capitalist world.
- Three types of geography, each with its own applied programme:
- Spatial analysis (positivist): technical solutions, GIS for location–allocation.
- Humanistic: human agency at the centre.
- Radical: to emancipate people by clarifying the nature of their society so they can restructure it.
- Criticism, Stoddart (1987): applied geographers concentrate on "trivial issues". They should "do some real geography" on the large issue of people–environment relations.