Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

Thornthwaite's and Trewartha's Classifications

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

6 min read11 sections

Thornthwaite's and Trewartha's Classifications

Why it matters: For Thornthwaite, know the idea of precipitation effectiveness and thermal efficiency (1931), potential evapotranspiration and the moisture index (1948), the provinces, and the criticism. For Trewartha, know the major groups, how they differ from Koeppen's, and why the scheme is popular.

Part A: Thornthwaite

1. Background ⭐

  • C.W. Thornthwaite, American climatologist.
  • 1931: classification of the climates of North America; 1933: extended to the world. Revised scheme 1948 (with a further revision by Thornthwaite and Mather in 1955).
  • Empirical and complex. Like Koeppen, he took vegetation as an indicator of climate in 1931, but stressed that evaporation decides how much rain is actually useful to plants.

2. The 1931 scheme ⭐⭐

Two indices, plus the season of rainfall.

(1) Precipitation effectiveness (P/E)

  • Precipitation effectiveness: the part of the precipitation actually available to plants.
  • P/E ratio = monthly precipitation ÷ monthly evaporation. Because evaporation data were scarce, he used: P/E ratio = 11.5 × [r / (t − 10)]^(10/9), with r = mean monthly rainfall (inches) and t = mean monthly temperature (°F).
  • P/E index = sum of the 12 monthly P/E ratios.
Humidity province (P/E index)
Vegetation
A Wet (128 and above)
Rainforest
B Humid (64–127)
Forest
C Sub-humid (32–63)
Grassland
D Semi-arid (16–31)
Steppe
E Arid (below 16)
Desert
  • Seasonal distribution: r = rain adequate in all seasons; s = deficient in summer; w = deficient in winter; d = deficient in all seasons. 5 provinces × 4 = 20 sub-divisions.

(2) Thermal (temperature) efficiency (T/E)

  • T/E ratio = (t − 32) / 4 (t in °F), i.e. the positive departure of monthly mean temperature from freezing. T/E index = sum of the 12 monthly ratios.
Temperature province
T/E index
A′ Tropical
128 and above
B′ Mesothermal
64–127
C′ Microthermal
32–63
D′ Taiga
16–31
E′ Tundra
1–15
F′ Frost
0
  • Combining humidity provinces, seasonal distribution and temperature provinces gives 120 possible types, but only 32 were shown on the world map (e.g. AA′r tropical wet with adequate rain all year; BB′w mesothermal humid with winter deficit; plus D′ taiga, E′ tundra and F′ perpetual frost).

3. The 1948 scheme ⭐⭐⭐

  • Vegetation was dropped as the basis. The new basis was potential evapotranspiration (PE): the water that would be lost by evaporation and plant transpiration if water were always available. PE depends on the energy received, so it is itself an index of thermal efficiency.
  • PE is calculated (not measured) from mean monthly temperature, corrected for day length (standard 12-hour day, 30-day month):
    • PE (cm) = 1.6 × (10t / I)^a, where t = mean monthly temperature (°C), I = heat index (sum over 12 months of (t/5)^1.514), and a = a further function of I.
  • By comparing precipitation with PE month by month (the water balance), one finds the water surplus (S) and deficit (D).

Four indices

  1. Moisture index: Im = (100S − 60D) / PE, using annual totals. (Equivalent to humidity index − 0.6 × aridity index.)
  1. Thermal efficiency = annual PE in cm.
  1. Aridity index (100D/PE, used for moist climates) and humidity index (100S/PE, used for dry climates): show the season of water shortage or surplus.
  1. Summer concentration of thermal efficiency: percentage of annual PE occurring in the three summer months.

Moisture (humidity) provinces

Province
Moisture index
A Perhumid
100 and above
B4, B3, B2, B1 Humid
80–100, 60–80, 40–60, 20–40
C2 Moist sub-humid
0 to 20
C1 Dry sub-humid
−20 to 0
D Semi-arid
−40 to −20
E Arid
−60 to −40
  • In the 1955 revision the index became 100(S − D)/PE, and the lower limits became −33.3 (C1), −66.7 (D) and −100 (E). Some books mix the two sets of values.

Thermal provinces (annual PE)

Province
PE (cm)
A′ Megathermal
114 and above
B′ Mesothermal (B′4, B′3, B′2, B′1)
57.0–114.0 (steps at 99.7, 85.5, 71.2)
C′ Microthermal (C′2, C′1)
28.5–57.0 (step at 42.7)
D′ Tundra
14.2–28.5
E′ Frost
Below 14.2

Summer concentration of thermal efficiency

  • a′ below 48%; b′4 48–51.9%; b′3 51.9–56.3%; b′2 56.3–61.6%; b′1 61.6–68.0%; c′2 68.0–76.3%; c′1 76.3–88.0%; d′ above 88%. Low values mean little seasonal contrast (tropics); high values, strong summer concentration (high latitudes).

Seasonal variation of moisture

Moist climates (A, B, C2): aridity index
Dry climates (C1, D, E): humidity index
r little or no deficit: 0–16.7
d little or no surplus: 0–10
s moderate summer deficit: 16.7–33.3
s moderate winter surplus: 10–20
w moderate winter deficit: 16.7–33.3
w moderate summer surplus: 10–20
s2 large summer deficit: over 33.3
s2 large winter surplus: over 20
w2 large winter deficit: over 33.3
w2 large summer surplus: over 20
  • A climate is written with four letters. Example: AA′a′r = perhumid, megathermal, summer concentration under 48%, little or no water deficit.

4. Evaluation of Thornthwaite ⭐⭐

Merits

  1. Uses effective precipitation (water balance), not just totals: scientifically sounder; very useful for agriculture, irrigation and hydrology.
  1. Quantitative and objective.
  1. The 1948 scheme does not depend on vegetation, so it avoids circular reasoning.

Limitations

  1. Formulae are complex and need much calculation.
  1. Evaporation / PE data are not available for many places; PE is estimated from temperature only.
  1. Ignores the causes of climate, so it was less appreciated by meteorologists.
  1. The 1931 scheme gave 32 types (about three times Koeppen's main types) with vague boundaries; the 1948 scheme has so many combinations that no world map could be produced.

Part B: Trewartha

5. Background ⭐

  • G.T. Trewartha, American climatologist, modified Koeppen's scheme from the 1930s onward; final version with L.H. Horn (1980).
  • Aim: a simple, generalised, unambiguous scheme with few major types that can be easily mapped. A compromise between empirical and genetic methods. Based on temperature and precipitation; B climates on precipitation, the rest on temperature.

6. Major groups (final form) ⭐⭐⭐

Group
Criterion and types
A Tropical humid
All months above 18°C. Ar tropical wet (rainforest; up to 2 dry months), Aw tropical wet-and-dry (savanna, dry in the low-sun season), As dry summer (rare). Monsoon areas fall in these types
B Dry
Evaporation exceeds precipitation. BW desert and BS steppe; h (hot) or k (cold). Hot dry climates are dominated by sub-tropical anticyclones; cold dry climates lie in continental interiors and rain shadows
C Sub-tropical
8–12 months at 10°C or more (coldest below 18°C). Cs dry summer (Mediterranean, west coasts); Cf humid sub-tropical (east coasts, rain all year with summer maximum; Cw where winters are dry)
D Temperate
4–7 months at 10°C or more. Do oceanic (marine west coast; coldest month above 0°C); Dc continental (coldest month below 0°C), with Dca (warm summer) and Dcb (cool summer)
E Boreal
1–3 months at 10°C or more; long, very cold winters (taiga)
F Polar
All months below 10°C. Ft tundra (warmest month 0–10°C) and Fi ice cap (all months below 0°C)
H Highland
Mountain climates, changing with altitude
  • Note: some textbooks give an intermediate form in which C is divided into Cs (Mediterranean), Ca (humid sub-tropical, China type) and Cb (marine west coast), and D is divided by summer and winter temperature into Da (warm summer, above 22°C), Db (cool summer, below 22°C), Dc (sub-polar, short summer) and Dd (coldest month below −38°C). In that form E is boreal and F is polar, with Ft and Fi.

7. Main departures from Koeppen ⭐⭐

  1. h/k boundary of dry climates: Koeppen used a mean annual temperature of 18°C; Trewartha used the 0°C isotherm of the coldest month (later, 8 months at 10°C or more).
  1. C/D boundary: Koeppen used the −3°C isotherm of the coldest month; Trewartha used 0°C (later, the number of months at 10°C or more).
  1. C climates: Koeppen divided them by season of rain (Cs, Cw, Cf); Trewartha by location and character (Cs and Ca/Cf, with marine west coast climates separated).
  1. D climates: Koeppen divided them by precipitation (Df, Dw); Trewartha by temperature.
  1. Trewartha added boreal (E) and highland (H) groups and made the polar group F.

8. Evaluation of Trewartha ⭐

  • Simple and unambiguous; avoids heavy calculation; uses only temperature and precipitation.
  • Mixes empirical limits with genetic reasoning (air masses, pressure belts), and takes account of the effects of land and sea.
  • Easy to map at world scale, which made it very popular with geographers.
  • Being generalised, it hides local detail; boundaries are still empirical.

Quick comparison ⭐⭐

Point
Thornthwaite
Trewartha
Basis
Effective precipitation, thermal efficiency, PE
Temperature and precipitation; partly genetic
Nature
Empirical, complex
Empirical–genetic, simple
Number of types
Very many
Few major groups
Mapping
Hard (no world map for 1948)
Easy